Home > Football > Spurs or Liverpool? The stay-or-go question that's tormenting Robbie Keane
by gerald mclaughlin on 06 July 2008
Email this Article (20) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Big savings on football products from boots to balls!
It’s amazing to think that Robbie Keane is still only 27 years old. He seems to have been around forever. At the centre of a supposed transfer struggle between Liverpool and his current employers Tottenham, the Dublin-born Irish International has reputedly made clear that he wants to try Champions League football. There is no doubt he enjoys playing with Spurs but the indication he has given serves as a major doubt as to what he believes are Tottenham’s chances of finishing in the top four.
Perhaps he wants an immediate guarantee of such football, which is what Liverpool will give him. Perhaps, at a crossroads in his career, he feels the need for a final challenge at a bigger club, which Liverpool are.
Keane has more of a chance of silverware at Anfield. By that I mean the Champions League and not the Carling Cup. I don’t mean this as a detrimental statement concerning Spurs, who seem to be on the up and up on every level; yet Keane obviously has more of an idea as to the potential contained in the current Tottenham squad and their ability to be contenders for the bigger prizes.
After an impressive start to his career at Wolves and Coventry, Keane was the hottest property in British football yet found himself in tricky situations at Inter Milan and Leeds United after Marcello Lippi was sacked after signing the youngster and Leeds ran into their much-publicised troubles.
On signing for Spurs in 2002 Glenn Hoddle stated in typical fashion that Keane would find his ‘‘spiritual home’’at White Hart Lane. For once Hoddle was not wrong - 80 goals in 197 appearances is a good return from a man who is simply not just a striker.
Adored by the Spurs faithful, Tottenham’s insistence on having too many strikers who consider themselves first-team players stifled and frustrated Keane for some time. Mido and Freddie Kanoute kept him playing second fiddle during his third season at the club. Keane has shown great character and ability through troubled times, including a bust-up with Edgar Davids in training which went on to become a pivotal moment in galvanising the Irishman’s apparent love for the club.
Has Keane now seen the end of the road at Tottenham? Perhaps a continual battle to prove himself at a club where he should have always been first choice is/has began to grate on his psyche. Yes, he is at an age where he will be thinking about guaranteed top-class football. Even the might of playing in the richest league in the world is not enough for Keane. He has never played in the Champions League, which is a situation that a man with such talent will find frustrating. He has another five years at the top but if Spurs don’t make the top four this coming season it could be another wasted year in his eyes.
Hoddle once said of Keane, "He’s such a bubbly lad that anyone who meets him loves him’’. I don’t think Robbie is the type of guy who would intentionally want to upset people, especially those fans who have supported him at White Hart Lane. However, no one could blame him for wanting to further his career at this stage. Whether a move to Anfield would benefit him or not, Keane will not make this decision lightly. Unfortunately I cannot see him being first choice at Anfield if he did go - that privilege belongs to Fernando Torres. It’s difficult because Keane must know that he will not be the main striker at Anfield and even the possibility of more games if Rafa Benitez stuck him on the wing would not appeal.
If Juande Ramos can convince Robbie that Spurs can make that top four spot then he will stay. It’s an intriguing and very important decision for one of Britain’s top strikers; he really can’t afford to make the wrong choice - for his own sake.
Comments (20)
by Keanes Best Friend on July 06, 2008
You can just see the torment in the first training day pictures. Absolute rubbish by someone bored on a Sunday.
by spurfect one on July 06, 2008
i cant see robbie starting the amount of games at liverpool as he does at spurs, we all know rafa's rotation policy and we all know robbie likes playing most games look at his reaction when being subbed last season. i think he should stay spurs are close to the CL anyway.
by paul b on July 06, 2008
"i think he should stay spurs are close to the CL anyway" how are you close? where did you finnish again....
by West Derby Red on July 06, 2008
Yes Spurs are a club on the up. But not even the most ardent Spurs fan can suggest that they will pass Liverpool this season or for the next 3 or 4. That would take Keane into his 30's to be effectively at the stage Liverpool are at now.
by KEITH ROBINS on July 06, 2008
PRAY TEL US WHO HAS SAID WHAT TO WHOM KEANE HAS SAID NOTHING RAMOS HAS ZILCH YET U MAKE UP THIS GARBAGE ALL OF U WHAT GREAT JOURNALISTS U ARE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! PATHATIC
by Boris Armchair on July 06, 2008
Your joking Liverpool are rubbish - pants in premiership Keane should stay, liverpool dont haved a clue. what kind of idiot would buy Crouch Enuff said
by Mark Lynn on July 06, 2008
After we won the Carling Cup Keane said "I am happy to stay here for the rest of my career". If he deserts us now I hope he gets the Campbell treatment everytime he returns to White Hart Lane. Ramos has carefully strengthend the back and built the mid field. He thought, like the rest of us, that in Robbie Keane we had a great striker who was as good as his word.We need players like Keane and King to lead this revolution of Spurs.And bringing in prats like Poldolski won't cut it.
by Robert Vipers on July 06, 2008
I have supported SPURS for over 50 YEARS I am more excited about this season than i have been for many a season, I believe we have now got a real manager. Juande has already made some great signings and with more in the pipeline i think this could be time for us to really make our mark we have waited to long.. C'MOn U SPURS. C U at NORWICH Cant Wait.
by Ben Flude on July 06, 2008
If your happy to get the last champions league spot and no silverware fair play. Ramos came to spurs with us in bottom three, i have no doubt he was told his priority was to get into europe, which he did. I thought liverpools was to win th cl and premiership close on cl league awful in prem considering. This debate is about keane who has always been a liverpool fan an has said in his biography he want to play for them one day. Try concentrating on your'It doesnt matter about the premiership we're good in europe' team and look forward to another season of disappointment with or hopefully without keane
on July 06, 2008 on July 06, 2008
o.k, Robbie has not got much to considor, it is either join liverpool to take part in the champions league only to get knocked out early as there team is not good enough to win it, and finish the season trophy less, or stay with the club where he is becoming a legend nd are going to win more silerware and quite likely playing champions league soon any way. simple as that really!
by Browny on July 07, 2008
Get knocked out early??! Liverpool often get knocked out early dont they??? WHAT!!! And finishing 11 points off the top of the league is shit too eh... Champ final twice in last 4 years and semis last year.. or play 4 spurs and finish about 30 points off the top and actually closer to the bottom.. mmmm which team appears to be the better??? no.. I cant tell... hang on.. found some white blinkers.... oh now I know.. SPURS will win the quadruple.. oh.. zzz where am i?? oh I just woke up
by yiddy blueblood on July 07, 2008
are pants, rafa a weirdo, owners cast uncertanty over every thing, fans unloyal glory hunters only there if you winning,anfield like a libary, brain dead fans who only no 1 song, all 4 words of it!! brains like goldfish cant manage anything longer!!!!! p.s. can you really see keane with a perm wearing a shellsuit???????????
by Brian W on July 07, 2008
Firstly as a football fan it makes me completely sick to see some of the biased nonsense that is written by fans lookin through rose tinted glasses. Now as a Spurs fan it is very obvious to me that Liverpool are a better team and a bigger club then we are. No argument However to imply that Keane will definately leave just because of some newspaper reports linking him with Liverpool is utter rubbish. Personally I don't think he will leave. (And that is an honest opinion not a biased one!) For one he has a four year contract so Spurs will not sell unless a ridiculously large bid is made. Liverpool will not bid such a large sum(20 plus million) because a)they don't have much money b)They already have the best striker in the league, and there are areas of their squad which need strengthening far more urgently Keane was indeed a reds fan growing up but over the last 5 years he has no doubt built a special bond with the spurs crowd, deservedly giving him the title of white hart lanes favourite son. Because of this i cant see keane doing a gareth barry and bitchin about the club in order to get a move. Maybe he fancies a move to liverpool and he may tell the chairman that. But if the answer is no then i cant see Keano commin out in the press badmouthing spurs. Would Keane move to liverpool if a bid was accepted? probably. Will a bid be accepted? highly unlikely
by Frankie Ng on July 07, 2008
I'm a fan of Spurs in Hong Kong for more than 25 years. Definitely, Keane is a professional footballer. I'd respect he is willing to challenge himself to a new height, no matter in Spurs or somewhere else. However, he needs to balance out all the factors around him before making the decision, say, long-term development in football career, personal /family life in London Vs Liverpool, chance of getting first team in Liverpool, style of playing balls with Torres (they are alike to a certain extent), and other pros & cons of staying Vs moving, etc. Once Keane is feeling right to do so, we should respect him without any regret ..... a team is not a one-man team but has 11 players. Like our rival, Arsenal, it lost Henry a yr ago but still performed well last season. There is no reason if Spurs cannot do the same if we lost few key players but should have new bloods coming in.
by Billy Styles on July 07, 2008
I think he'd be a good signing for Liverpool, but I think Liverpool's best formation is 4-2-3-1 and should stick to that formation throughout the season. I think this would be the best team Liverpool could get this summer: GK: Reina RB: Degen RCB: Carragher LCB: Skrtel/ Agger LB: Dossena/ Aurelio RDM: Mascherano LDM: Alonso RM: Babel LM: Silva AM: Gerrard CF: Torres Bench: Cavalieri, Skrtel/ Agger, Dossena/ Aurelio, Plessis, Lucas, Kuyt, Nemeth.
by Yid Army on July 07, 2008
Liverpool can't afford Keane FACT
by paulyid on July 08, 2008
The gulf between spurs and liverpool is not enough to convince Keane that Liverpool will finish above Spurs this year, he is personally not world class but has formed a world class partnership with Berba, therefore it can only be money as an incentive, if so let him go and spend the money on someone that wnats to become a real legend at spurs if Keane does not understand what a real lengend is, then maybe a night out with Hoddle, Ossie, Perryman, Crookes, Falco etc..would do him the world of good PS Dawson is a future Spurs Captain, last year was not brilliant but the guy needs a little more confidence and he will be up there with the best. Do people remember Ledley needing someone like Naybet to learn his trade
by Jonathan Craig on July 11, 2008
Hold on a minute just because get into the CL dosen't mean their automatically going to win it Spurs have never won the CL. And as far as Liverpool are concerned they haven't done too bad in the CL in the past 4 years: They have reached the final twice and won it once, and have reached the semi-final. Could you tell me the last time Spurs got to a Champions League semi-final?
by david smith on July 11, 2008
'i think he should stay spurs are close to the CL anyway' how are you close? where did you finnish again....
by no 1 spurs fan on July 11, 2008
Keane must stay at Tottenham, he is the main man who can push us up to where we want to be. Ramos must build the team around him to stand any chance of reaching the CL. He is already a legend and whatever happens will always be so in my eyes.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *