Peaceful Olympic protest will help the Tibetan cause more than violence
Scenes of violence following the Olympic Torch as it makes its way round the world will not sway the Chinese government. The demonstrators should learn from the great silent protesters of history.
by Craig Hackney on 12 April 2008
Email this Article (7) Comments
Some people just don’t get it.
The clowns who have been disrupting the Olympic Torch relay in cities around the world may well have sealed the fate of this anachronistic, but very powerful symbol of the Olympic ideal with the IOC looking likely to scrap the international leg of future relays.
By abusing the very right that is denied to those on whose behalf they are protesting, the opportunity for future protests may well have been lost. Those whom PJ O’Rourke labelled the “perennially indignant”, the professional protesters who jump on any cause to engage in antisocial behaviour, are apparently incapable of seeing the irony of acting violently in support of those who only wish to live in peace.
They certainly aren’t capable of seeing the damage that they are causing. What is happening in Tibet is shameful, but this message is lost when protest turns violent. Media coverage of the relay has focused on the acts of the protesters – not the message that they are trying to deliver.
Comments (7)
by James on April 12, 2008
Generally, I agree with Craig. Uforunately, not only the violent protesters are making troubles, but also some of the countries are promoting these violence. Another thing is the media, who is also taking an important role in promoting this environment.
by Laurence on April 12, 2008
"Tiananmen Square. That's how you make a statement. No histrionics, no bloodshed, just a lone man saying enough is enough" 1000 protestors were murdered at Tiananmen Square according to Amnesty International. And what has changed? The Chinese government continues to oppress and silence any voices of protest or descent. The Tiananmen Square protests achieved... nothing. Can the present day protests be called violence? A few people trying to grab the flame, is that really what passes for a 'violent protest' nowadays? Nonsense. As for "protest against the wrongdoings in tibet if you wish, but stop attacking the olympics", where would you have them protest Craig? China? Tibet? Because demonstrations there inevitably seem to end up with chinese soldiers repeatedly smashing their jackboots into protesters faces, before the executions start, of course. The olympics are the ONLY place tibet is going to have a chance to show the world the atrocities which still occur until this day. As for sport and politics remaining separate, i think athletics is really a glorious irrelevance in the face of appalling human rights violations. Craig you have some serious thinking to do about your romanticised views of 'silent' protest.
by Cindy Luk on April 13, 2008
Unlike in Tiananmen Sq., the average Chinese people are supporting the govt. on this issue. Before you pass such strong opinion like "shameful", educate yourself about the history of Tibet first, and what really happened during the riots. Eyewitnesses Recount Terrifying Day in Tibet http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/ar ticle/2008/03/26/AR2008032603275.html It's insulting to mention an ex-slave owner who were on CIA payroll (well-documented by newly declassified papers) with the likes of MLK, Mendela in the same breath. And yes, there IS an enduring and powerful image coming out from the relay as well, that of a wheelchair-bound young woman protecting the torch from a burly mobster in Paris!
not Gandhi that I meant. And do not "brainwashed" me, I haven't lived a day under the commies.
by home insurance home insurance on April 14, 2008
3b19rvq-vz03gk9-tw6qefd0-0 <a href="http://wholelifeinsurance.browser.to#2">whole life insurance</a> http://lowcostautoinsurance.andmuchmore.com#1 [url=http://lifeinsurance.iMegastores.com#3]life insurance[/url] [url]http://lifeinsurance.radpages.com#4[/url] [http://carinsurance.thrill.to#5 car insurance] "car insurance":http://carinsurance.stop.to#6 [LINK http://webalias.com/lifeinsurance#7]life insurance[/LINK]
by Mr china man on April 14, 2008
you cindy, are a fool, a big fool and you are wrong, you big fool
by Weak Truevoice on April 25, 2008
Tibet is a historical region of central Asia between the Himalaya and Kunlun mountains. A center of Lamaist Buddhism, Tibet first flourished as an independent kingdom in the seventh century. It fell under Mongol influence from the 13th to the 18th century and later came under Chinese control (1720). Dalai Lama was the traditional governmental ruler and highest priest of the Lamaist religion in Tibet,he was not only the dictator but also the largest slave owner. In 1959, he refused democracy reform and escaped to India. After that, Chinese government freed all the slaves in Tibet. So, you can understand why Dalai Lama and previous slave owners hate China government and lie to western courntries for continuing reap without sowing. You are welcomed to Tibet to find out the truth by yourself. During Dalai's ruling time, riding horse was the only way to visit Tibet, but now, Chinese had built alot highways for travel. You can also go to Lhasa (the capital) by air, but the weather of plateau is changing quickly, the flight may delay or be cancelled frequently. Railway is another good choice, which is built last year as the highest altitude railway in the world, very good for sight seeing, So good that you may need to order ticket weeks before. Well, before you go, pay attention to altitude anoxia, it could be dangerous to some one. Wish you good luck!
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Last Name
Sport
Email
League
Heading
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
X-tra special Xavi can lead Spain to the 2010 World Cup
Keep cricket captain Collingwood - let's face it, there's no one better!
Don't blame Tim Henman or Andy Murray - our Wimbledon failure is down to Britain's tennis chiefs
Arsenal Aston Villa Barcelona Chelsea Everton Football Liverpool Manchester City Manchester United Newcastle United Portsmouth Real Madrid Sunderland Tottenham Hotspur West Ham United