Home > Cricket > Why Test cricket needs two divisions...
by Madhusudan Rao on 23 November 2008
Email this Article (6) Comments
Free £25 bet when you register at
The recent one-sided results in international cricket have showed that the game at top level has to be reorganised so that interest remains, let it be in Test matches, ODI or even Twenty20.
Sri Lanka defeated Zimbabwe by nine wickets after dismissing them for a sub-70 score, while Bangladesh were defeated by South Africa by an innings and more than 100 runs. And Pakistan thumped West Indies 3-0 in their recent ODI series.
These matches do nothing more than inflate the statistics of the higher-ranked countries. Ajantha Mendis proved to be more than a handful for even a country like India (well-known for their spin-playing talents). Imagine what would happen when he plays against lower-ranked Zimbabwe.
Is an Indian victim for him the same as a Zimbabwe wicket? On paper, obviously it is. But the value of the wickets is definitely not the same. The effort that goes into getting those wickets is also incomparable.
Similarly, the century Graeme Smith scored against Bangladesh would not give him the same satisfaction as if he had scored it against Australia in the upcoming tour.
The presence of these lesser countries will inflate the figures of the bowlers/batsmen to such an extent that they look very impressive, especially when compared to the greats who had to contend with high-quality opposition in their times. So why are these countries still playing? Obviously, it has to do with ICC politics - that is complicated enough for discussions on another rainy day.
Bangladesh, Zimbabwe and West Indies should be made to play in a second division for the next year. Based on the performances and results in these matches, a decision could then be made on whether they could play the other countries.
Of course, a quantative framework has to be arrived at, to ensure that there is no bias in the assessment. International cricket definitely cannot go on the way it exists today.
Comments (6)
by Greg Smith on November 23, 2008
Nooooo... I lived through Apartheid and think you're wrong... the Banga's are on a GREAT learning curve ! Scoring a hundred against them is as satisfying as ANY because it's our DUTY to give a hand UP to these boys... I love the Banga's and respect them very, very much... they've taken a lot of time and effort to support the Protea's... I don't think the Protea's would be the GREATEST TEST side without them and what they've done ! All Test teams need to compete... you learn on the job !
by Brad on November 25, 2008
Your right, but the south africans use the average teams to boost there stats.
by Greg Smith on November 25, 2008
It balances out for Australia when you play New Zealand etc...
AND... its a documented FACT, they Australia 'sit on their hands' or sit on their lead and are very shy to play the amount of cricket South Africa plays every season... Ricky Ponting like to hide Down Under, play ONE or TWO series (preferably at home) and groom himself and Australia's title as the GREATEST ! Such self-indulgent, neglectful of cricketing duties people, you Aussies !
by Mani Thangadurai on November 26, 2008
True, you learn on the job, but how much longer can you keep 'learning'? The difference between the Sri Lanka and New Zealand teams who themselves took a lot of time to win their first matches is that they at least showed some consistent signs that they were improving and becoming competitive, and their journeys were not merely littered with infrequent 'upsets' over the big boys. Bangladesh since their inception have only sporadically shown signs of being competitive, and have failed to back up their impressive 2007 World Cup showing with consistent performances. Zimbabwe were once upon a time a fine and competitive side who were one point away from making the Semifinals of the 1999 World Cup, but we all know their problems and since then they have not so much deteriorated as disintegrated and decayed. They even lost to Canada recently! So if anything, a demotion to the lower leagues as it were will do these teams no harm; they will get some confidence back and learn more from victories than defeats. It also goes without saying that they need to get their houses in order. They should also be able to find their level and live up to it, and not be like these football teams in England who may win their lower league at a canter but can't cut the mustard in a higher division. Sure, people will say that Bangladesh have beaten the likes of Australia, South Africa and India and talk about Zimbabwe's moment of joy against the Aussies in the Twenty20 World Cup, but I'll put it this way-last season Barnsley played out of their skins to reach the semifinals of the FA Cup with wins over Liverpool and Chelsea, with the victory over the Reds being at Anfield. But they weren't rewarded with an immediate non-relegation ticket to the Premiership now were they?
by Brad on November 28, 2008
I see boucher scored a 100 against bangladesh probabaly the only team he could score one against...
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Owen's no gamble - Liverpool's former goal-den boy could be a Manchester United bargain
Galaxies apart: Why David Beckham is NOT the pride of Landon (Landon Donovan, that is)
TEN reasons why South Africa's Peter de Villiers is rugby union's greatest
Arsenal Champions League Chelsea Cricket news Euroleague Fantasy football Football news Formula 1 Liverpool Manchester United NBA Newcastle United Premier League Sports news Tottenham Hotspur Transfer rumours Twenty20 UEFA UEFA Champions League
© SportBuzz All rights reserved 2008 Sportingo- Sports News & Sports Articles site. Sportingo delivers fresh sports news and analysis by fans-Football News, Tennis News, Rugby Union News, Rugby League, Cricket News, Cycling News, Basketball News and other Sports TV. XML Sitemap 2008.