Home > Cricket > The REAL reason Indian cricket fans turned on Andrew Symonds
by Sports Freak on 24 October 2007
Email this Article (14) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
According to Peter Roebuck, in a stunningly sanctimonious piece in this weekend’s Sydney Morning Herald, cricket is facing ”The Race of our Lives.” This is all to do with the monkey-calls that overshadowed the just completed ODI series between India and Australia.
With jaw-dropping pomposity, he claims this is all on a par with the fact that West Indian captains were all white until the 1960s as a continuation of racism signifying an ongoing obstacle to the beauty and purity of cricket.
“Racism is the plague of the world. Every truly great man of history has stood against it, and all have failed to eradicate it. Still it endures, hateful, loveless, limiting. Like all diseases, it comes and goes but never entirely disappears, eating away at immature brains, unsettling nations, creating divisions founded upon suspicion and superficiality."
Wow, forget ball-tampering, dodgy actions, the rise of Twenty20 rebel tours, the Zimbabwe situation, how Kenya can be nurtured, declining playing numbers in the West Indies, modernising Test cricket into a coherent competition; Roebuck thinks he’s identified the biggest blight on the game. And by God, Australia is going to fight this head-on.
While Sportsfreak does not condone racial discrimination in any form, it is only right to look at this from the boundary. Oh, and let's get one thing straight, Symonds did not get taunted with monkey calls because he is black. Countless West Indian teams have passed through India without hint of abuse. And black members of South African and England teams have never been singled out.
Symonds was abused because he is a knob. Take your pick for the specific reason. He had an on-field run-in with Sri Sreesanth in the first game, he has a ridiculous hair-do, everything he has ever done in the field is over-theatrical, and then there’s the outrageous lip-gloss clown make-up mask. Where do you start?
It is pathetic lip paint that probably leads to the racial abuse. Being English, Symonds should realise that the white monkey lips is straight out of the Black and White Minstrel show. So a monkey call, while unpleasant, has some inevitability about it. Focusing on the show-pony fielding, for example, is not so straight-forward. And is it really that much more offensive than the time-honoured approach of 20,000 Darrens and Darryls standing and chanting “Hadlee is a w**ker”? All this tends to get overlooked in Australia, but the next few months are going to be fascinating. First of all it’s Sri Lanka’s turn, in a tour likely to be dominated by Murali’s push to surpass local hero Shane Warne as Test cricket’s leading wicket taker. This is Murali’s first Test series in the Lucky Country since he was no-balled out of the series in 1996 by local umpire Darryl Hair. He missed the last trip. That was the series where Darren Lehman received a small token suspension for racially abusing the Sri Lankans in their dressing room. And then it’s the Indian rematch. Clearly Sreesanth will get the attention of the Australian crowds. That is fair enough, he is reviving the sadly fading tradition of mad fast bowlers, and he has come out in the media predicting a 4-0 whitewash to the tourists. But all eyes will be how it is done. Because if there are signs of the hateful, loveless, limiting nature of the abuse that ruins the world then this outrage will be exposed for what it has the appearance of. The bullies do not like the taste of their own medicine.
Comments (14)
by Dazza on October 24, 2007
What is "show-pony fielding"? What are "white monkey lips"? I don't think its inevitable that Symonds should get monkey chants for wearing zinc, being of West Indian descent, or having braided hair. Sreesanth is the theatrical one who gets the crowd involved -he screamed in Symonds' face after running him out in one of the games. No wonder he keeps getting fined. Maybe Indian crowds are getting more boisterous in response to their 20/20 win. I agree that Darrell Hare is an embarassment to Australia. Roebuck, Ponting and others are probably shit-scared that fans here will retaliate. I think we both know the real reason for Symonds treatment -who did you say was the "Player of the ODI Series"?
by Partha Rajagopal on October 24, 2007
I want to point out that the player of the series award is always given at the end of the series. Symonds was ridiculed during the series. There are many other players who have done well on the Indian soil and were never booed.
by satboy on October 25, 2007
Dazza, EVERYTHING Symonds does in the field has an element of theatrics about it. The exaggerated look to the skies when missing a run-out etc.. You say "monkey chants for wearing zinc, being of West Indian descent, or having braided hair" Don't lump the West Indian descent with the other two.
by Dave on October 25, 2007
The monkey calls did happen to the West Indians, as well. On their 2002 tour they said they faced the most racist abuse they ever had ever heard. It was in India see the link http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,2 5197,22604344-5001505,00.html "......In 2002, the West Indies suffered racial abuse from ignorant crowds and one player privately admitted it was the worst he had received in the world. The Indian board and the Indian media want this issue to go away and so does everybody else, but it won't go away until the locals accept it is a serious issue and something that needs to be dealt with....."
by Ronnie on October 25, 2007
and you believe what 'The Australian' says....well, we regular reader know how credible their sources are, they are the aussie version of the Guardian...Nehow, if one of our players getting some ignorant stick from a few ppl make such a big issue, wouldn't a whole side being racially abuse make a bigger one. 25% of the Windies team is of Indian origin neways... so wakeup..
by Partha Rajagopal on October 25, 2007
Dave quotes the Australian for West Indian players suffering the worst racial harassment in India. Please check cricinfo's archives of past series. West Indies toured Sri Lanka and Pakistan and then England in the entire 2001-2002 season. This now brings into question the credibility of the Australian newspaper and the writer who quotes it. Please double check your sources before you put it into a public forum. Lies told a 1000 times can turn into truth.
by rose maitland on October 25, 2007
Your comment that WI team was never heckled during their tour in India, is not true. Courtney Walsh was called monkey, banana thrown on the field in India, in the late 80s or early 90s But what is ironic, that this is happening in India, and not the Caucasian countries - where they suffered as much from Colonialism and racism as the Africans.
Rose, Can you please quote the sources of your statement? I'll definitely accept it if it is from an authentic source. And I can change my opinion based on it. I wonder why Walsh's treatment never got the highlights that Symonds got. Indian media loves spicy news. People like Viv Richards would have written about it for sure. He was very sensitive about Colin Croft's treatment in SA when they went as rebels. I lived in India during the glory days of WI cricket. I have watched the games on TV and never once saw monkey calls or racial chants on WI players. I used to be glued to the TV as a teenager watching those legends play. All I have heard all these years is about the behavior of Aussie players in the field. I remember how Holding broke down during the 5-1 drubbing his team received from Greg Chappell's team.
by Darryl on October 26, 2007
This has got to be the most ridiculous so called sports article i have ever read on the web! so personal abuse will not be tolerated in my comment yet you can gloss over a sensitive issue like racism and claim it happened because symonds is a knob? do you know the man personally to make that claim? i would like to point out that just because black people havent been racially abused on previous tours is not a defence or an excuse for this behaviour, being an australian im not claiming that australian crowds arent very racist in certain sections and i condemn this, but unlike you i am willing to admit it that it happens,and no player of whatever colour deserves to experience it in australia or anywhere else. In my opinion all the so called reasons that you claim makes symonds a knob are infact what makes him one of the most unique and exciting players in world cricket. now if i was of west indian descent i might find my dreadlocks being called ridiculous a bit offensive as it is a cultural thing, i wonder if i
by Matt Page on October 26, 2007
for the abuse directed at Symonds, the form in which it was displayed was wrong. Because you think someone is a 'knob' does not give you any right to taunt them for or make allusions to their race. Indian fans are by and large knowledgeable and sensible people, and they should have known better.
by Alma Atta on October 26, 2007
[quote]This has got to be the most ridiculous so called sports article i have ever read on the web! so personal abuse will not be tolerated in my comment yet you can gloss over a sensitive issue like racism and claim it happened because symonds is a knob? do you know the man personally to make that claim? i would like to point out that just because black people havent been racially abused on previous tours is not a defence or an excuse for this behaviour, being an australian im not claiming that australian crowds arent very racist in certain sections and i condemn this, but unlike you i am willing to admit it that it happens,and no player of whatever colour deserves to experience it in australia or anywhere else. In my opinion all the so called reasons that you claim makes symonds a knob are infact what makes him one of the most unique and exciting players in world cricket. now if i was of west indian descent i might find my dreadlocks being called ridiculous a bit offensive as it is a cultural thing, i wond
Darryl, with all due respect, if you think being a knob is the making of a great cricketer, then i wouldn't be suprised if were pretty good at cricket yourself (TIC). You'd go really well at www.sportsfreak.co.nz
by Marsh on November 05, 2007
dude this is a bunch of crap. really it is.And im not an aussie.
by Vinit Kumar Mathur on November 08, 2007
I would just like to mention that the so called "racial abuse" hurled at Andrew Symonds does not in any way represent the whole of India. Andrew Symonds is an accomplished cricket player and is highlly respected for his cricket expertise throughout India. His performance in India speaks of the person he really is. I think Andrew Symonds should not give much thought to what happened here and it should suffice that he has considerable fan following here
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Best team on the planet - but without the World Cup the All Blacks can't be GREAT
More teeny toppers join the march of Britain's new generation of tennis stars
New Zealand's cricketers no match for Australia - but can South Africa topple the world's best?