Home > Cricket > Andrew Symonds, Ricky Ponting and Harbhajan Singh - cricket's disreputable crew
by Hamish McBrearty on 08 January 2008
Email this Article (17) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Australia's players and officials have stood behind their tactics and on-field behaviour, but others have said that it just wasn't cricket. Former England captain Tony Greig has gone on record pointing out Ricky Ponting's double standards, both in his attitude to incorrect decisions in the first innings, and insisting "what happens on the field, stays on the field" but then running to the umpire after the Andrew Symonds-Harbhajan Singh incident.
Sydney Morning Herald writer Peter Roebuck went even further, calling for Ponting to be sacked as captain, as he and the players around him seem to be the only ones who do not realise their behaviour is damaging to cricket's image. "It was a match that will have been relished only by rabid nationalists and others for whom victory and vengeance are the sole reasons for playing sport," Roebuck wrote.
India's post-match behaviour was not much better. While most fans can understand their demand for umpire Steve Bucknor's removal from the third Test, their threat to boycott the rest of the tour over Harbhajan's suspension is just childish. Quite what happened and what was said on the field is still up for speculation, but the Indians' claim that several Australian players are making up allegations is unbelievable.
Greig has also asked what exactly Symonds said to Harbhajan before the alleged slur took place, Symonds admits to "having a crack" at Harbhajan but this could mean a great deal of things. Regardless of provocation, racism has no place in sport and should be dealt with severely.
The most controversial sporting incident of 2006 was Zinedine Zidane head-butting Italian defender Marco Materazzi, during the World Cup final, for which Zidane received a three-match ban, while Materazzi got a two-match ban. Maybe Symonds should be asked to account for his role in the incident.
Lost in the storm of controversy whipped up in the aftermath of this game is the fact that Australian spinner Brad Hogg has been charged with using offensive language and will have a hearing with match referee Mike Procter before the third Test in Perth. Perhaps the behaviour of the Australian players is not as angelic as they would have us believe.
Bucknor has since been removed from the Perth test, replaced by New Zealander Billy Bowden, and Harbhajan has appealed his ban, likely averting a boycott by India. But the aftermath of this match will have long lasting effects on both teams and the game in general.
Comments (17)
by G on January 08, 2008
on another note HAMISH MCBREARTY tell us your credentials, seeing that you must be a scotsman , and we all know how crap you scots are in any sport, in fact do you even play cricket and what makes you an EXPERT ? you think typing a few e;eloquent lines makes you feel all warm and fuzzy? this forum should be renamed "arm chair non expert loser writers full of wan***s"
i just read your "bio" NZ .............hmmm need i say more
heres a SMALL list of cricketers BANNED for match fixing.....wheres the uproar compared to this storm in a tea cup? 1.SALEEM MALIK/PAKISTAN LIFE BAN 2.ATA-UR-REHMAN/PAKISTAN LIFE BAN 3. MOHHAMED AZHARUDDIN/INDIA <<< LIFE BAN .4.AJAY SHARMA/INDIA <<< LIFE BAN 5.MANOJ PRABHAKAR/INDIA <<< 5 YEAR BAN 6.AJAY JADEJA/INDIA <<< 5 YEAR BAN 7.HANSIE CRONJE/SOUTH AFRICA LIFE BAN 8.HERSCHELLE GIBBS/SOUTH AFRICA 6 MONTHS <<<< STILL PLAYING !! 9.HENRY WILLIAMS/SOUTH AFRICA LIFE BAN 10.MAURICE ODUMBE/KENYA 5 YEARS........no Aussies here i see........wheres the OUTRAGE ? how much did the world shake when these losers were caught? the GAME STILL GOES ON........don't beat yourself up about "bringing the game into disrepute" you're on a losing subject here
by Ajeeth Xavier Parapullil on January 08, 2008
The whole incident looks well preplanned. I saw Kumble patting Symonds on the back after the win. Even Symonds himself patted Buchnor on the back after being gifted Dravid's wicket. Nobody said anything. It was much beyond patting. It looks like that the Australian team wanted to get back on the Indians for standing up to them. They might also have been thinking that sledging is their patent and no other team should be allowed to give it back to them. Maybe they were also a bit jealous that the Indians were making a lot of money when Australia is being trumpted as the world champions. The Australian team knew that the only Harbhajan and Sreesanth reacted to taunts. Maybe they had planned all this for Sreesanth for antics in India. As Sreesanth didn't turn up, they turned to the next possible candidate. The rest, as they say, is history.
heres ONE MORE.....INDIA V SOUTH AFRICA 16-20 NOV 2001 PORT ELIZABETH, SACHIN TENDULKAR -ball tampering charges I MATCH SUSPENDED BAN <<<< YOU SEE THAT!!hes not such a good boy after all.....VIRENDER SEHWAG excessive appealing 1 MATCH BAN and subsequently BANNED for bowling off breaks .......SOURAV GANGULY inability to control his players behavior 1 TEST AND 2 ODI suspended BAN ....SHIV SUNDER DAS excessive appealing 1 TEST MATCH suspended BAN DEEP DASGUPTA excessive appealing 1 TEST MATCH suspended BAN ..............and lastly..........HELLO.......HARBHAJAN SINGH excessive appealing 1 TEST MATCH suspended BAN.........YOU SEE THERE ARE TOO MANY PLAYERS THAT HAVE BROUGHT THE GAME INTO DISREPUTE, we need to name the players who are clean of controversy to get an idea how bad this has been in time memorial.............BAD TOPIC/BAD HEADING you're just sensationalizing a story thats a BEAT UP
by Shane Robinson on January 08, 2008
Wearing those stupid leg guards and actually playing this waste of time sport is bringing the sporting world into disrepute!!!
by A u r without brains on January 08, 2008
Now by the look of what you are writing it seems that no Australian cricketer has got caught what he is doing ...BUT.......that does not mean they dont do it you jughhead........and use your brain a bit more and see who gave those contentious decisions that you are talkng about against sachin tendulkar / virendra sehwag ......a racist ............and for you kind information ........that charge was "REMOVED" after a hearing !!!! and dont forget what happened to darly lehman ---"Australia's Lehman, the first player banned for racial abuse" ....... SHOUTING on the top of your mouth does not make a lie into a truth.
by Stephen on January 08, 2008
I think Harbajan got off lightly. How DARE he use the Australian tactics against Australians in Australia?? I think, Harbajan should be banned for life for not paying the royalties for the Australian patented playing tactics. Heck, he should be deported from Australia for potentially violating Australian policy of -- we can dish it out, but we can not take it. I also think that the series should go on as long as Australia can guarantee that Canberra has enough supply of pacifiers, after all, India would be playing against a team of cry babies.
by beau Peep on January 08, 2008
All wrongly interpreted and understood in the ongoing racial controversy. I have the <a href"http://gurubeaupeep.blogspot.com/2008/01/ek-banda r-maidan-ke-andar.html">answers here mate</a>.
by Krishna Routhu on January 09, 2008
To everyone's dismay - the true term 'Gentlemen' whileplaying cricket has been forgotten. Time the Aussies go back o school and learn etiquette 'on field' as well. Aussies were a TEAM once upon a time - respecting the rules of 'Cricket', but what we are witnessing is shameful.
by Wayne Jones on January 09, 2008
As an aussie I think the appalling behaviour by racist indian supporters during the aussie tour there recently was disgraceful and that its no wonder that a complaint was lodged for comments made towards Symonds. Australia should have packed up and come home when those racists continually taunted Symonds. Just imagine an aussie cricketer making racial remarks to an Indian player the team would pack up and go home. The Indian team have staved off singhs suspension and i can see exactly what will happen in Perth, singh in and Hogg out what a joke, who needs the pacifiers Steve ? Just look at the way the indian team have carried on and as a cricket lover I say let them go home if they are going to whinge about every aspect of Australian cricket, they swear they celebrate too much for goodness sake. Play hard or go home
by eddie on January 09, 2008
If you could bat, there would be no problem,geeeeeeeeeeeeez.
by GREG on January 09, 2008
u must have forgotten shane warn , mark waugh, derren leh man , dean jones to name a few .u must be an "AUSTRALION" no woder for ur views
by Slashmunger on January 11, 2008
India are the most unsportsman-like country in professional cricket and their history of bannings and attempts to hold the game to ransom only proves it. Aussies won't put up with crap on the pitch and they will always stand up for a mate. Suck it up India and take your losses like men not children.
by Christina on January 12, 2008
It's a sad day for cricket when a team can throw a tantrum and get an umpire fired!!! Poor decisions are part of the game - harden up and get over it. And why is it that the Australian cricket team must apologise for being the best in the world? I thought we played to win, otherwise why bother to play at all?
by RISHI on January 15, 2008
The Australians are hypocrits, they always want to give it to the opponents but we Indians know how to give it back to them, the aussies do not play the game ibn the right spirit, i mean who the hell was ricky pointing to give sourav out. Ricky pointing is a cheater.
by ady on June 05, 2008
symonds ,why do you poke your nose to others others issue,if it is not your cup of tea don't go to taste it ,be like lee, jonson,don't listen to ricky.your fans know what you are,so try to be the one whom everone likes.i am an indian but i am one of your's best fan in the whole univers..............:0) :) :) :)
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Best team on the planet - but without the World Cup the All Blacks can't be GREAT