Home > Cricket > Indian cricket ... from the sublime to the ridiculous
Indian cricket ... from the sublime to the ridiculous
South Africa won the second Test in Ahmedabad by an innings and 90 runs – are India just suffering from burn-out?
by Madhusudan Rao on 07 April 2008
Email this Article (9) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
The Indians performed two unbelievable acts in the space of two weeks. The first one was an individual feat – Viru Sehwag scored 319 in the first innings of the Chennai Test against South Africa. The second one was a team effort – in the first innnings of the second Test in Ahmedabad, the Indian team could not last beyond the 20th over on day one! What a come down for team that gave the Aussies a good run for their money.
The South Africans played well in every department and totally overshadowed their Indian counterparts. Even their batting, which was supposed to be suspect against the Indian spin twins, performed better than the Indian stars. All this contributed to a huge innings win for the Proteas.
India looked tired on the field and their mind seemed to be somewhere else. The BCCI, in their efforts to milk the golden goose that is the Indian team, has filled the schedule with so many tours (overseas and home) that for the next year, they don't seem to have any breathing time at all. Even the one month they had left between this tour and the Sri Lankan visit, is now taken up with the IPL concept.
This means that the players have no time to recuperate. One has to look at the on-field efforts to gauge the fitness levels of the players. Sachin Tendulkar and Anil Kumble are fighting against time to play the Test matches on this tour. These are two of the most committed players of the Indian team – the fact that they are missing matches is a reflection of how badly the schedule has been planned by the BCCI.
India's overseas record is now better than their domestic record. It is so surprising to hear about it, when a few years back it was exactly the opposite. The home tracks do not support the spinners as much as they used to. So, as it is in other countries, the home advantage is no longer present. Players are much more confident of playing the Indians on their own soil.
South Africa have come prepared and that is because they had more time after their series against Bangladesh. They even went to the extent of playing the first drawn Test of the series without any warm-up matches. So much for confidence!
Back to the game – the Indians must start phasing out their senior members in the batting line-up. Wasim Jaffer can play only on featherbeds – that is not good news for him. It is time Gautam Gambhir is brought into the Test eleven. Over the next 6-9 months, Sourav Ganguly first and VVS Laxman next should be replaced by younger stars like Yuvraj Singh and Rohit Sharma. Same time next year, Rahul Dravid and then, after another six months, Tendulkar should be replaced. Of course, all this should be done in consultation with them. But, will the BCCI do it? Going by their past record, I doubt it.
Comments (9)
by Fred on April 07, 2008
I'm so tired of constantly hearing how bad India performed and of all the excuses cropping up. Has anyone actually considered that South Africa, through talent, hard work and heart totally outplayed India. On the day South Africa were just better than India and thats why india lost...evryone keeps under rating the Saffers but they keep 'surprizing' everyone by winning consistantly! C'mon guys give credit where it is due...Well Done South Africa for doing the 'unthinkable' and beating india 'against' all the odds!! Wake up!! Could SA actually be a better team the India???
by Sachin Tendulkar on April 07, 2008
Tendulkar will be too old and weak and not good enough to play in the 2011 world cup he is already gone past his best ever form and i dont think it will return.
he is shit
by Partha Rajagopal on April 07, 2008
While India is struggling with its fast bowlers, who seem to be falling apart every second game, SA is blessed with a steady pack of fast bowlers who get time to settle down and bowl long spells without breaking down. Even the heat in Chennai did not break their backs. Bowlers win matches. Between SA and India, the batting is evenly matched. It is the bowling where SA has a huge advantage. Fast bowlers always thrive on all conditions. Spinners need special conditions. Therefore when the pitch offered some life, the SA fast bowlers did what they are expected to do. And it was a blunder of a decision to bat after winning the toss. That decided the match right there. There is no point over analyzing what happened. The better team won.
on April 07, 2008 on April 07, 2008
Past Record huh!!!! If it wasnt for Ganguly's fighting 87, india would have suffered even worse defeat.. Yuvraj singh replacing sourav?? You may wanna check his record and over rated dhoni's record in test series against Australia.. they were less than what Anil Kumble and Harbhajan scored.. They will get a chance when they deserve to play test cricket. They dont deserver it yet..
by sanjeev sharma on April 08, 2008
I am an indian , and i totally beleive in greg smith's openion , india had got stars , except , tendulkar and yuvraj , u can see with an closed eyes that , other indina stars don't hav , fight , tecnique , courege to face straight bowling at 140+ on true pich (forget about green top) After kumbe , india will struggle to bowl out teams twice in a test . soooo called allrounders like irfan , can't penetrate thew bat , ,people like steeshanth are overactor , then hard workers . india won't had manage to win odi series in aus , if indian media , won't had put tremendous pressure to calve down aussies killing instinct giving excuses of moral and cricketing spirits. on the otherhand , SA is hardest fighters like gladiator once they enter the ground , they are ready to get killed for each run . there fighting spirits is inmatched in world , on flat track too there they can produce something , by shoulder effort and ability to keep coming at u (makahya nitini) fielding -- india's fielding is not even better than bangladesh IT IS TOTAL INJUSTICE THAT AT AUCTION LIKE IPL PEOPLE LIKE DHONI , IRFAN , SREESHANT ,HARBHAJAN WERE SOLD OUT BETTER THAN GILCRIST, KALLIS,STEYN ,MURLI. THE MEDIA IN INDIA IS PTHATIC , CHANNELS WANT TO SHOW THERE PETROTIASM BY HIDING REALITY ,EXAMPLES ARE LIKE AS 1) REMOVAL OF BUCKNOR - PRESSURE OF MONEY OF BCCI 2)HARBHAN GOT AWAY , WITH SUCH A BIG CRIME - JUST BY MEDIA PRESSURE , SOME CHANNEL SUD REALY THINK ABOUT THEMSELVES , WHEN THEY CALL HIS MOTHER ON TV TO JUSTIFY HER CUTE CHILD'S BIG CRIME , FOR THE LOVE OF GOD , PLEASE TELL ME ANY MOTHER WILL SAY THAT MY CHILD HAS COMMMITTED CRIME , ABILITY WISE , DHONE IS PTHATIC ON TRUE WICKET ,HIS TECNIQUE IS JUST LIKE TAILENDER , People like shreeshanth , i don't know what is wrong with this guy , execp in one test he has't produce scare in any country's mind , still shows agression and gives a glare after every delivery as if he is akthar , stey, lee , see steyn lee , its is the agression that's lies in mind which produce results , not ur eye agression Come on india , its time to wake up , see the truth and it is unfortunately bitter , they are not our shoillders of country , but are over actor of bollywood DON'T DESERVE TREATED LIKE GOD! yaa, u are absolutely right man if sa bowlers can keep themselves fit and their batsman plays aggressively then they are going to really overcome aussies bec. they r only team which can giv aus equal fight in field and hunger to win . forget about ind and eng , they can't match sa's agression and intensity , IN END. IN SEAMING CONDITION , SA ATTACK WILL BURRY ENG BATSMAN'S IN THERE OWN DEN , INDIA CAN'T WIN FROM SA IN FUTURE WITHOUT SACHIN, KUMBLE ON GOOD CRICKET PITCH (NOT DUST BOWLS)
by Greg Smith on April 08, 2008
Cricket fans should take heart, cricket is a great leveler - it's just a silly game to show how equal we all are... However Protea's fans will insist their team is more equal !
by Chandr on April 14, 2008
Ok Saffers lost the second test and can go home happy. Saffers must recall that they almost lost the series at home last year and in fact score 84 at the wanderers test. I guess this is close to India's tally of 78. As far as i can see both the teams are on par. Please ignore the rants of my fellow countryman Mr. Sanjeev Sharma, he is probably one of those illegal immigrants you find in many of the boats and trucks you find in Europe,,,,
by chndra sharma on May 09, 2008
MR C..F..NDRA hve u ever been to any country outside INDIA if u do then u r just tellin abt ur failed self come to the US canada uk and u know what! mostr of the immigrants have courage thats why they left the shit hole.Even to buy an airline tivket it costs and to come illegally it is aroun 10 to 15 lakh.I AM A canadian citizen and legally enterd to CANADA iT IS JUST PEOPLE LIKE U FAILURES WHO ARE GOOD FOR NOTHIN BUT TO SPECULATE ..most of you so called Patriotic inidians are wanna be AMERICANS with ur funny english accent pathetic loosers IN teh west people just work and mind their own bussiness but 300 millions may be more of you are just good for one thing gossiping speculating,and finding faults in others just to satisfy ur own failed selfs Comin to the poin INDIA IS DIVIDED LANGUAGE WISE RELIGIONWISE,REGION ETS.EVENIN SOME SMALL COUNTRIES THE AVERAGE LIVING STANDARD IS BATTER THAN OF AN INDIA MILLINAIRE IN INDIA WESTERN KINDDA LIVING IS ALUXURY.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Best team on the planet - but without the World Cup the All Blacks can't be GREAT
More teeny toppers join the march of Britain's new generation of tennis stars
New Zealand's cricketers no match for Australia - but can South Africa topple the world's best?
Arsenal Champions League Chelsea Cricket news Euroleague Fantasy football Football news Formula 1 Liverpool Manchester United NBA Newcastle United Premier League Sports news Tottenham Hotspur Transfer rumours Twenty20 UEFA UEFA Champions League