Home > Football > Why Liverpool's Academy system has been a failure
by Tom Harness on 09 February 2007
Email this Article (18) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Comments (18)
by Yozza on February 09, 2007
Rooney wasn't rejected by LFC - he turned up for his 'trial' (which he attended as a joke) in an Everton shirt. There's no way he was ever going to sign for the Reds, coming from a long line of Bitters
by Dave on February 09, 2007
David Thompson Jamie Carragher Steven Warnock Steven Gerrard Michael Owen Steve Macmanaman Robbie Fowler... The list goes on. These are premiership standard players, that not only have been drafted in by Liverpool acadamy, but they are local. and If anyone can name me a much established local youth side than the aforementioned aside from man utd in 98', then i will shake their hand.
by I on February 09, 2007
You are naming players who came through prior to establishing the academy. Its about now not ten years ago. PS Warnock was never good enough
by andrew on February 09, 2007
The last players from Liverpool academy = Gerrard Carra of which gerrard is 26, still young. MU's last batch = long long ago. eg neville/beckham = 30 years old. Since then, they had no one. And dont ever say rooney and ronaldo were part of MU's academy cos thats bulls. Arsenal - is so misleading. They buy youth at expensive prices( eg. walcott, bapista) but who actually came from the academy that is born local? Frabegas was bought after he got best player award. So WHO is actually Local from London? no one? Chelsea? oh i wouldnt even want to go there. FACT: english youth stars are rare because, english players are just never technically good enough.
by Dan on February 09, 2007
Carragher signed pro deal in 1996 Gerrard made full debut in 1998 the same year as the academy was opened, the point here is liverpool opened the academy at a huge expense. tomorrow at newcastle not one player from it will start or even be on the bench against Newcastle, it costs over 3 million a year to run..so is that a good return on Liverpools money
by james brown on February 09, 2007
i think what you said about liverpools academy is true this is the same academy that rejected david nugent after all the only way we won the fa youth cup 2005/6 is because of foreign imports such as godwin antwi mik roque and english players from different teams paul anderson and jack hobbs
by Andy on February 09, 2007
How easily you pass the buck on to Steve Heighway! Funny how you fail to mention ONCE in your article how he was responsible for bringing in McManaman, Fowler, Carra & Stevie G - to name but a few. Players of their calibre don't come along every day. Ok, so Rooney slipped through the net but he turned up for his Liverpool trial wearing a blueshite shirt so maybe you need to check your facts before writing your comments in future. Also, to give your article ANY substance you might have looked at the recent graduates from the academies of the other top 4 clubs. Other than The Arse, what world class players have the mancs or the rent boys produced recently???
Steve Heighway! has been in charge of the liverpool youth set up since 1989 so its he has now been in charge for nearly 18 years, in that 18 years he has been lucky enough to have a hand in the 4 players named above, but as one of the previous commentaters said Steven Gerrard is the last player to graduate from the youth set up to the first team and that was in 1998, thats nearly 9 years without getting a player from our youth set up to make the grade in the first team. I remember reading that Heighway did not actually rate Gerrard, Heighway asked Houlier to check out an up and coming left back Warnock but when Houlier seen Gerrard in that game he took him straight to melwood the next day, so now maybe we can see why Heighway missed out on seeing Rooneys potential no matter what jersey he was wearing.
by Kopite on February 09, 2007
thats possible that all those youngsters are useless expensive signings coz if u look at the results from the reserve team, they always draw or lose against teams made of homegrown players.. so whats the use of getting players from abroad if once the get in the academy the forget or lose their football techniques or great skills for which they have been bought!!! No players from the academy since Gerrard and Carragher, the Academy SUCKS!!!!
Kopite, calling yourself that name is a disgrace as you know f*** all about football. You've probably supported LFC since Istanbul - after you jumped ship from the chavs. Dan, no players since Stevie G? The same Stevie who the chavs wanted for 35 mill? A pretty good ROI (Return On Investment for the mentally challenged like 'koppite') for the Academy. How many world class players do you want? If you're expecting a Gerrard every season then you're delusional. If an academy produces a world class player every 5 years then they're doing bloody well. The academy HAS averaged that - ie: carra & stevie. Do you disagree? then give me bloody statistics that prove otherwise!!! And by the way, you're actually wrong about the whole Houllier/Stevie G issue but you no doubt 'believe' the tabloid spin...!
by You are a plonker! on February 10, 2007
The so called "failing" Liverpool youth academy won the Fa youth cup last year! How can you say it is a failing system? Steve Heighway is a legend and he has been responsible for bringing through Gerrard, Macca, Carra, Owen. You need some research skills Tom Harness because your article is full of flaws and it shows you are an utter plonker!
by Simon on February 10, 2007
...As the George Benson song goes... Since the academy opened I think the back end of the 90's there hasn't been a first team regular come through. The one's who have made a few appearance's, Guthrie for example, were picked up late. Guthrie was at MUFC PLC. However, we did win the Youth Cup last year and this current crop may produce a couple of regulars. There is one youngster who has caught my eye, Jay Spearing, who is only about 5'4'' but can play centre half. He has great passing ability and is a right terrier. He's a pocket Gerrard. A broken leg held him back but he'll be 19 in November so the next year is vital for him. Astrit Ajdarevic who is 17 looks the business. Very Alonso like in the way he plays but Patrick Berger in looks and hairband!! And we can't forget Adam Hamill who has just turned 19 and has gone on loan to Dunfermline and has been doing fantastic. He set up the winner last week against Hearts. He has immense talent and if he really wants it, he'll make it. I am bit surprise however, th
Had to put another comment after reading everyone else's. I am quite surprise by the lack of knowledge from the comments made so far. The academy was opened about 99 give or take a year. It cost about 10million and has so far no produced one first team regular. Carra and Stevie G didn't come through the academy as it is now. If we bring through one player who we sell form 20m then all the outlay and costs would cover it. But so far, I agree, it hasn't been a success. Hopefuly that will change as we 'poached' the coach who spotted Walcott and Bale at Southampton so that may bear some fruit.
by Phil on February 10, 2007
sounds like you made up a load of stuff so u had something to print
by OAFC Tom on February 16, 2007
I do not support Liverpool but was talking to fan the other day saying it has been years since a kid broke through the Liverpool youth ranks. With Stevie Gerrard being the last big one.
by steven on February 19, 2007
are u forgetting the youth team that won the youth fa cup last year.gerrard and carra came through the academy so ge told
by You're mad!! on May 25, 2007
rubbish!!!
by robert on August 13, 2007
Hi,i am 15, i play strike and was top goal scorer last season. i am a strong and fast player,does any one know wher i can get a trial for a proffesional club.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *