Home > Football > Xabi Alonso for Samuel Eto'o? A Liverpool deal with Barcelona makes sense
by Tom Harness on 07 May 2007
Email this Article (89) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Comments (89)
by Robert Phillips on May 07, 2007
first of all...let's get the formation right. i really think that a 4-5-1 formation suites Liverpool really well. by doing this, you accomadate Gerrard, Xabi and Sisoko/Mascherano. You also get to play our natural wingers in Pennant and Gonzalez and play Kuyt and as attacking midfielder-cum-striker. Gerrard could always replace Gonzalez wchich would allow Kuyt to fall into deeper midfield to accomadate Crouch/Bellamy or Bellamy could come in for Gonzalez to attack from midfeild. either way, this formation is the way international football is heading. for next season, we need to get Simoa and Daniel Alves and we definetley need a striker. going for Eto, Torres or Villa will be a mistake as we could use that money to focus on bringing in two strikers like Tevez and Saviola. we also getting Voronin on a free transfer which clearly means the end of Fowler. Hypia will definetly leave with Dudek. We have to let go of Zenden and Kewel. yes Kewel is very good but he only gives us 7 games out of a possible 50. so in
by magnumopus on May 07, 2007
Gone will be... Zenden, Dudek,Paletta,Bellamy, Pongolle, Le Tellec. Coming in will be from this group: Simao, Nani, Quaresma, Pedersen, Alves, Carlos, Tevez, Villa, Eto'o.
by Ray on May 07, 2007
Finally a piece of sports writing that rings true to our situation at Liverpool. However, I would love to keep Alonso and still get Eto'o. Alonso is a red and will be needed next season just as much as Mascherano. If only there were 12 places available in a startng line-up
by Peter on May 07, 2007
You need a big squad to compete in all competitions. You don't let a player like Alonso leave if you want to win the premier. Mascherano could get injured and Rafa works best with different options. Strengthen up front, but not at the cost of our pass master.
by Sonny on May 07, 2007
Bellamy defiantly out I'd say. I would keep Alonso, but spend big on Eto'o!
by ghaith on May 07, 2007
ahhh i think rafa will bring qauglairella and voronin and tevez in the forword, simao, alves, fernandez and in the back i think he will try to bring woodgate and zapata.
by Jurgen on May 07, 2007
pls keep xabi he is a key player for us and a big player
by Waino on May 07, 2007
Liverpool don't need to sell anyone, let alone the brilliant Alonso. Sissoko is the most vulnerable should Rafa decide to move any central midfielder on. Mascher can do Momo's job but doesn't have the finesse of Xabi. Gerrard, Mascher and Xabi offer fantastic combinations. None will play every game next season, but all three will be needed.
by neil on May 07, 2007
I don't think Liverpool should be looking to sell Alonso he is a world class player. Sissoko at the moment is going through a bad spell, but he is still young and learning, but i think in a couple of years he will be world class. Am still not sure about Mascherano don't get me wrong he is a good player but i would like to see him in a full season with Liverpool. Because i think lazy at times. Players i think should be shown the door are Bellamy, Paletta, Arbeloa, Pennant and Fowler should stay and given a coaching role
by Gab on May 07, 2007
I agree. Alonso is a class midfielder, however I feel Mascherano is far more suited to the English game. Alonso was absolutely awesome in his first season here, however I feel that his distribution has been affected because he isnt allowed enough time on the ball in nowadays in the Premiership. Mascherano is a better tackler and allows Gerrard the freedom to attack.
by jonte on May 07, 2007
I hope Rafa signs Pedersen and Eto'o in the summer we defenitly need a new left winger and Pedersen can use both right and left foot!!
by valon on May 07, 2007
i would go with the deal i hate to se alonso go but but its a sacrifice thats worth it.everytime i hear on the news that other teams are trying to seize eto im about to brake my tv dont let this chance go away
by tonny on May 07, 2007
it will be good if eto'o villa , simao , richards , tevez and cisse join liverpool next season but Im sure that we can win the premiership with these players zenden have to leave together with hyppia
by Bridgie on May 07, 2007
I think Gonzalez, Fowler, Dudek and Bellamy will go, I definitely hope Alonso stays and if Rafa get's it as he wants, I think he will. Hopefully they'll be able to sign David Villa (although not for £45m because that's just insane), Eto'o or possibly Fernando Torres.
by khan on May 07, 2007
as a liverpool fan the signing ever make by Rafa is macherano coz he is tybe of player who can play alongside steven G
by Pongpat on May 07, 2007
In my opinion, the following are possible to signe in this summer: Teves, Eto'o or Torres Gamst Pedensen, Simao Sabroza Daniel Alves, Mika Richards, Alex and the following are possible to sell or loan: Fowler, Bellamy Gonzales, Zenden Dudek, Hypia, Paletta, Carson
by Ian on May 07, 2007
Rafa chops and changes his side all the time, and in his own words picks the best players for that particular game. You honestly think Alonso should go ? The only midfielder player that will suffer from mascheranos arrival if sissoko, and really your article should be about him and not Xabi. Plus why sell one of your best players to fund the purchase of another ? We should be able to buy him out right
by ryan on May 07, 2007
Benni mcarthy as he has proven himself as etto would still have to adapt to the premiership.
by MAX on May 07, 2007
Its about time Alonso should leave. For me he is an overated player. I still cant figure out what type of player he is. Is he a an attacking midfielder or a defensive midfielder? He rarely assists to any goals, he rarely scores and cannot defend apart from clumsy challenges in critical moments.Yes, he has a beautiful pass but its meaningless if you cant you use it positively.To be fair to him he started off quite well but faded gradually. I hate Lampard and think he is another over rated player but at least he scores. I dont see anything positive about Alonso. I cant believe Benitez rates him more as a central midfielder than Gerrard. You can see that Benitez is biased towards Alonso but I was really happy to see when he was dropped against Chelsea and you saw the difference it made, but when he came on and we seemed to lost our shape and balance.
by fitzy on May 07, 2007
We need to keep Xabi as he and Mascherano are similiar and can cover for each other. Sell Sissoko and buy Kaka, perfect to rotate with Stevie. Of course Eto upfront with Tevez and keep crouch and Kuyt. Then we just have the wings to sort and a centre back as Palletta just isn't good enough yet! Come on G n' T show us the MONEY!!
by Wigestål on May 07, 2007
Following players I think will leave: Fowler, Bolo Zenden, Bellamy, Dudek, Sinama-Pongolle, Paletta (loan deal), Insua (loan deal) and Gonzalez. Following players I think (hope) will arrive: Simao Sambrosa, Samuel Eto`o, Voronin, Gamst Pedersen and Dani Alves In Athens we won it six times...
by shuan on May 07, 2007
If any manager understand a little bit of football wouldn't think of selling Xabi Alonso. i dont need to mention Xabi's quality and the kind of player he is. and we should't expect to Steven Gerrard to play all 60-70 games next season.Who will fill his boots when Gerrard is rested. And even when when we need to play a bit more attacking football i dont see a better pair in the midfield than number 8 and 14. matches we need to play compact, Gerrard and Mascherano can or Gerrard and Sissoko can start. Now "the left wing" dont forget about Fabio Aurelio,as no one mentioned him, he just started to show what hes capeable to do just before his injuiry. if any one can recall the arsenal game. but i think we should still buy Morten Gamst Pederson. As he is one of the best left winger in the premiership. Mark Gonzalez, dont get impatient with him its only his first season in EPL and hes only 22. i think within next 2-3 years he will be one of best left winger. on the right wing Daniel Alves would be the right solutio
by james T Quinn on May 07, 2007
Agree with most of what was written.,especially about Sissoko. Re xabi leaving,no chance!More likely to find room for the three of Masch Sg and xabi. Would love to see Eto'o in the red shirt as our big problem this season has been lack of an an out an out goal scorer. Thats not to denigrate Kuyt Crouch or bellamy but they are not "natural" scorers a la Michael or a young Robbie.If we had had a natural this season perhaps Pennant would have got the credit he deserves. He has done everything asked of him but has to read every day that simao is coming!
by Squiddy on May 07, 2007
'nuff said...
by Tellen on May 07, 2007
I'm Tellen from Cameroon and would have love to see Eto'o in the best club in the world reasons why i prefer his staying at Barcelona. No matter howmuch Liverpool pays,i strongly believe any club that needs the services of Samuel Eto'o who no doubt is the World's best attacker,then the said club should be ready to make Eto'o the highest paid player in the world.Without that,then Liverpool should forget it. I say theu should forget about Eto'o cuz i'm not sure they would meet up to the task. Anyway,i think Trezegue would also fit somehow though not as Eto'o but Liverpoll can afford his fee.