Home > Football > Edwards, Rowley, Law, Best, Cantona, Ronaldo - how do you pick Man United's greatest team?
by Philip Smith on 09 June 2007
Email this Article (32) Comments
Free £25 bet when you register at
Comments (32)
by Kevin on June 09, 2007
Not so sure about Ronaldo or Cantona how about both?
by Alan Holden on June 09, 2007
Only it's ROGER Byrne and JIMMY Delaney! Regards fellow old git.
by Gordon Stokes on June 09, 2007
I would have Roger Byrne, not Johnny Byrne who I've never heard of, at left back. Sorry to be so pedantic.
by lovecr717 on June 09, 2007
cristiano!!!
by Author Phil on June 09, 2007
Johnny Byrne - wow! Had so many names to conjure with I dropped a couple. Must have been thinking about Johnny "Budgeie" Byrne who played for some unfashionable London club! Sorry.
by Sportingo editing team on June 09, 2007
Thanks to everyone who pointed out Phil's brainstorm - or should that be name-storm?! Roger Byrne and Jimmy Delaney have now been given their rightful status in the article.
From the 2-3-5 era, well how about, Jack Crompton (penalty saver king, John Aston (snr)Henry Cockburn,Johny Morris. From the later eras how could you miss out Billy (Liam) Whelan, David Herd, Arthur Albiston, Gordon Hill, Johnny Berry, Paul Ince, Alex Dawson, Jimmy Greenhoff, Shay Brennan, Johnny Downie, Arnie Muhren and Albert Quixhall. I know difficult when you are only picking three teams but we have have had a magnificent footballers playing for a magnificent team since WW2. Alan Holden
by katty on June 09, 2007
just *cristiano ronaldo*.
by Fred on June 09, 2007
Ronaldo? not in same class as the Greatest ever CANTONA and that includes Best.
by Sagar on June 10, 2007
I don't think our dear king eric will take too kindly to being on the bench!! but your right it is just so tough to come up with a team. I guess whoever you ask will probably reel off names of players they most enjoyed watching, which in most of the older supporters would be the likes of best charlton etc with probably a few players from the SAF era whereas the younger fan like myself will probably choose from the SAF era. here comes my list Smeichel G. Neville, Bruce, Staam, Irwin Beckham,Keane,Scholes,Giggs Cantona, Rooney Subs Van der Sar Vidic Ferdinand Heinze Ronaldo Solskjaer Nis telroy I have chosen 7 subs as used in europe and some national leagues around europe. Obviously I will have missed out a name or two but this is what reels off my head atm. Sagar
by jordan on June 10, 2007
cristiano ronaldo is the best. he is the magical player
by craig on June 10, 2007
Ronaldo has the potential to be the greatest player ever at the old trafford faithful, cantona was probably the most entertaining but best has the medel that neither of these two have, the european, to me the one that standsout as the greatest player of all times is giggs. he has won everything and beat the best, he has made fools of juventus, single handedly destroyed arsenal (on more then one occasion) man city, liverpool, barca real you name it he has done everything and has been doing it for neally two decades. giggs for me
by kevin anderson on June 10, 2007
eric cantona was very good certainly,but cristiano is an incredible player. and my favorite man united is including: cristiano ronaldo-paul scholes-eric cantona-ryan giggs-roy keane-wayne rooney-garry neville-edvin van der sar-patrick evra-denis law and ferdinand
by brian on June 10, 2007
How on earth you can exclude Peter Schmeichel and replace him in United's top xi with Edwin Van Der Saar is beyond me and millions of other United fans and even neutrals! Fair enough that there is a case for their comparison but only when Edwin was maybe with Ajax, and that doesn't even count obviously, as the idea is to pick eleven top performing UNITED players!
by jennifer on June 11, 2007
cris-cris-cris-cris-cris-cris-cris-cris-cris-cris and cris.
by johnny on June 11, 2007
i agree with jennifer,CRIS is the best for man united.
by victoria on June 11, 2007
in my opinion,RONALDO is a different player. he is unpredictable and his play excites me!!!
by Linda on June 12, 2007
George was a beautiful man who could play the beautiful game and nobody can ever take that away from him.There will only be one George Best ever. Nobody will ever be as great as him, just out and out magic.
by *cmj* on June 12, 2007
Not a chance in hell wud Rooney b in my team; u cn av Ronaldo n Giggs on the wings wit Cantona playin jus behind Van Nistelrooy, problem of Ronaldo/Cantona solved (they can even swap n change)
by madeleine on June 13, 2007
He is a stupendous phenomenon for footy world...!
by benny on June 14, 2007
Why are Charlton and Best not in both 60's team? You don't seem to have a clue as t what you're talking about here in my opinion.
by stephy rock on June 14, 2007
Cris is the best for Man United.
by Dave on June 15, 2007
Schmeichel-Neville, Byrne, Edwards, Stam-Keane, Scholes, Best Giggs-Cantona Law. Subs: Stepney, Irwin, Crerand, Pallister, Robson, Charton, Beckham, Meredith, Taylor, Rowley. well well naming an all-time united side is one of the toughest exercises in football. what i have tried to do is get some of the best players of different eras according to my extensive reading of the history of the club. I dont think Cristiano or Rooney can yet qualify to form part of this team.. Ronaldo is yet to prove that he can deliver in big games, and this many times over. Rooney has not had the best of season, and though we all know he's supremely talented, i dont think he has done enuff to overhaul either Cantona or Law or even Tommy Taylor, whom many apecialists still regard as the greatest centre forwards ever to pull on a red shirt.
by Eddy Moore on June 15, 2007
He is better than others. He plays very pretty.
by Essexian76 on June 18, 2007
You can apply the same formula with any prem/championship side cant you?, they'd all be great...even Arsenal's
by Redrose on June 19, 2007
Nice article ! As with the other teams, it is, indeed, a tough call for the 40s/50s team. Personally, I would have Liam Whelan in there instead of Stan Pearson. I saw Billy play and considered him a more complete player than Bobby Charlton - admitedly he was older. As to the 60s/70s team, I was never a big fan of Ian Ure at United. By his own admission, his knees were shot before he signed. Even with HIS dodgy kness, I'd have Paul McGrath any day.
by Dave on June 20, 2007
ur lucky to have seen the days of the busby babes...so in ur opinion u'd have Whelan over Taylor and Viollet? what about Eddy Colman versus Scholes? i know we cant generally compare eras but what do u think?
by hussein on December 08, 2007
its really sth unbeliveble to put the king eric on the bench, i knoe its hard to make a formation for the greatest player of red devils but i think this one is the perfect 4-4-2:schmeicel(GK), edwards, stam, irwin, gary neville, roy keane, david beckham, george best, bobby charlton, cantona, rooney subs: C.ronaldo, van nistelroy, dennis law, ferdinand, van der sar.
by Harry Wragg on January 08, 2008
What a horrible bunch of rags that would have been.
by Tim Hoosiers on April 13, 2008
Ok, as to the Ferguson era: Schmeichel out, vd Sar in; Ronaldo OUT (not even a sub!) v Nistelrooy in and you'll have you fav team!
by Scott Mc-C on April 30, 2008
With the old style 4-2-4 formation, how does this sound? Schmeichel in goal, G.Neville, Stam, Ferdinand and Irwin at the back Hargreaves and Keane in the middle and at the front have Cantona and Ronaldo sitting just behind Rooney and Van Nistelrooy. 7 on the bench would be Van Der Sar, Heinze, Evra, Beckham, Giggs, Solkjaer and either Tevez or Scholes. This is obviously just for the Fergie era.. There have been so many other top players as well which makes this task impossible! Notably Bruce, Pallister, Ince, Kanchelskis and lets not forget Brian McClair as well as many others!!
by hurvind seewoodin on May 04, 2008
david beckham ahead of ronaldo, cantona on the bench n van nistelroy??? u r mad !! my team wud be, schmeichel,gary neville,stam, vidic, irwin, keane, scholes, giggs, ronaldo, nistelroy, cantona
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Owen's no gamble - Liverpool's former goal-den boy could be a Manchester United bargain
Galaxies apart: Why David Beckham is NOT the pride of Landon (Landon Donovan, that is)
TEN reasons why South Africa's Peter de Villiers is rugby union's greatest
Arsenal Champions League Chelsea Cricket news Euroleague Fantasy football Football news Formula 1 Liverpool Manchester United NBA Newcastle United Premier League Sports news Tottenham Hotspur Transfer rumours Twenty20 UEFA UEFA Champions League
© SportBuzz All rights reserved 2008 Sportingo- Sports News & Sports Articles site. Sportingo delivers fresh sports news and analysis by fans-Football News, Tennis News, Rugby Union News, Rugby League, Cricket News, Cycling News, Basketball News and other Sports TV. XML Sitemap 2008.