Home > Football > Rafa Benitez outfoxes Ferguson in the battle over Gabriel Heinze
by Tom Harness on 25 July 2007
Email this Article (45) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Comments (45)
by Razor on July 25, 2007
It wont be Liverpool and Man Utd in court over Heinze, it will be Man Utd and Heinze's representatives. Thats the beauty of the move by Liverpool, they don't need to get their hands dirty. I would prefer Chiellini over Heinze, but anything to rattle Fergies cage.
winds them up no end.
by Carl on July 25, 2007
Last time i checked Heinze said he will only leave United if Fergie tell's him to his face that he is not wanted anymore. Since Fergie made it clear this week that he doesn't want Heinze to leave, surely that is the end of the matter. And for your information, United will NOT be going to court for Tevez. It's between West Ham and MSI, it's got nothing to do with us. We just want to know who we have to pay.
by ap on July 25, 2007
An interesting sideshow but frankly there's a good reason why Heinze isn't first choice at Old Trafford and that should be enough to rule him out of a transfer anyway.
by Red Rupert on July 25, 2007
What an utter crock of shite. Benitez: "oh we'll just try a bid for a laugh eh"? Shyeaah right. wtf gives them the idea they have the slightest chance when he's under contract? Oh yeah, forgot - Gill wrote a little promise on a bit of paper - what he didn't tell you though, was that he had his fingers crossed. jeez, there's some knobs about. Don't know who's worse, journos or the idiots that believe them.
by magnumopus on July 25, 2007
How erudite a comment from such a class club's fan. At least mr. shitonastick! Get a life, you must be at least 12 now are you? I wish the best for Heinze now matter how this situation turns out...
by FiveTimes on July 25, 2007
Its funny how This guy calls himself SHITONASTICK! the difference between the language use by the fans says it all...
by mal on July 25, 2007
how sad you are, lets see what the courts have to say before you start spewing all the crap. 18 league championships, 5 european cups, 3 uefa cups, 7 fa cups, 7 league cups,15 charity shields, 3 european super cups. add to that what will be the biggest league ground in the country, 80,000 seater. contrary to what all man u fans think, football didn't start in 1992, it was going for 100 years before that.
by SHITONASTICK on July 25, 2007
[quote]How erudite a comment from such a class club's fan. At least mr. shitonastick! Get a life, you must be at least 12 now are you? I may be 12 but your MA was screaming for more last night. I wish the best for Heinze now matter how this situation turns out...[/quote]
by Franco Mizzi on July 25, 2007
This guy must be living in Dreamland. 1.A letter, if any exist, is not a contract. Heinze contract runs out in 2 years time. He could have bought out the reamining two years but he did not do so in the appropiate time frame. 2. We are now a privately owned club and have no obligation to any shareholders, maybe Benitez forgot this. 3. As a privately owned company we reserve the right to choose who to do business with. 4. Liverpool and Benitez have found some money at their disposal and like any average person winning the national lottery it has gon up to their heads. They still have not realised that for the 3 new players they bought in Manchester United, Chelsea, Arsenal & Spurs did likewise and in the case of Manchester United one should add Tevez and that makes it 4. I do not think I am being biased when I say that the 4 we have bought in are of a much higher pedigree then the scousers 3. Scousers you are 20 light years behind us. So enjoy a bit of limelight and check again come Christmas then
by Henry on July 25, 2007
how come man utd think they should be allowed to refuse heinze's move, but they don't think west ham should be allowed to refuse tevez's move? maybe they should see that it's a bit inconsistent.
80,000 seater stadium?? Where is it? still a bloody pipedream. And oh yes magnumopus, i may be 12 but your MA was screaming for more last night. And we all know which team is referred to as SHITONASTICK, don't we?? Dont't worry scousers, theres always next year.
by Glen on July 25, 2007
hey mal... what about 18 years without a premiership title?? and a double on u last season... made you look shite HAHa
by Henrik on July 25, 2007
i think you are an idiot
by Relaistic Fan on July 25, 2007
Having never ever commented on a fan site before I felt compelled to after reading some of the most thoughtless drivel above. As a Man Utd fan, some of the above comments have been a disgrace, shit on a stick? What are you talking about? Likewise there has been some rubbish talk from the Liverpool supporters. Heinze may end up at Anfield, however the ball does seem to be in Man Ut's court and my gut feeling is he will stay or move abroad. IF he did go, I would be irritated to see him go to Anfield or anywhere for that matter, but he is arguably past his best and 6.8m would be shrewd business considering he costs that 3 years ago. As for the atricle in the first place, it's just the type of short cited journalism you get on any site, irrelevant of whether it’s a Man Utd, Liverpool or Arsenal Forum. It's designed to stir up the exact kind of debate which it has seemingly caused! Over and out
hey glen, what a short memory man u fans seem to have, didn't your team go errrrmmmmmmmmm 25 years without a league title, and the small mater of getting relegated seems to have slipped your memory too.
by Fitzmaurice on July 25, 2007
The article is a joke. The author needs an education to comprehend the law. Tom Harness, you're a waste of time and space. If you want to be a genuine writer, try being impartial in your analysis
And Mal, did you actually watch the games last season. Made us look stupid??? Maybe you and Shiteonastick should shack up...
Sorry I meant Glen Not Mal
by Frank Mac on July 25, 2007
Nice to hear sense from Realistic Fan, and to know that not all ManU fans are utter dickheads. Ferguson's comments about illegal approaces would be taken seriously if it didnt come from someone who arranged a medical last tuesday for another clubs player
by BobbyBoy on July 25, 2007
What a perfectly chosen title that was. That's where you must be living if you believe what you've just written. 1. A letter, if any exist, is not a contract but IS legally binding. The letter doesn't need to be a contract, if it makes the statements that are claimed, then it acts as a "statement of intent". It is illegal to make a statement of intent and then withdraw any statements made there-in. 2. Benitez forgot nothing. The fact that you are privately owned is irrelevant once Heinze has been given leave to represent himself (or be represented by his agents). 3. Once a statement of intent with no provisos has been made, you have given Heinze permission to represent himself and the club must abide by any agreement he reaches that meet the terms of the letter. 4. Out new-found wealth has got to do with this. And if you followed pre-season and signings properly you'll find that Anriy Voronin has been the pick of out signings, yet you haven't counted him. You also seem to have neglected the
by Lynne on July 25, 2007
Red nose Fergie true to form - ageing bully boy who's passed it and lost some of his marbles. He's made it obvious that Heinze won't feature in his first team and then he has the temerity to try to dictate who Heinze can and can't play for! Ferguson's arrogance is becoming an embarrassment.
by BobbyBot on July 25, 2007
signings of Brazilian footballer of the year Lucas Leiva. Surely no mean feat considering he's just taken Kaka's record (4 years ago) as the youngest player ever to do so. Also, throw in a spattering of players from winning the FA youth cup 2 years in a row and signing a dozen of the most promising youth players in Europe and South American (1 or 2 of whom are bound to make some worthwhile impact on the first team). To assume that the only players that impact on a team are their high profile signings is incredibly obtuse.
by Tevez on July 25, 2007
I would like to inform Frank Mac and Henry that there has not been any illegal approach for me by Sir Alex Ferguson. Unless you read the press upside down, my ownership is the subject of a wrangle and as such Westham cannot claim ownership of me until the Arbitrator's (Courts) say so. For your own information, as far as am concerned, I only contracted to play for them for only a year as my reps have asserted. The battle they are fighting is an attempt to cover up their lies to the premier league, which if not, would have costed them a premiership place. i agreed to do a medical at Carrington because my understanding is that my commercial rights are held by my agent who gave the go ahead to Man Utd to deal with me. Afterall, I could be a free agent at the end of the saga.
by Disinterested on July 25, 2007
Relaistic Fan, I'm a Liverpool fan and I have to say I completely agree with all you just said. Bravo!
by Bouncer on July 25, 2007
from Manure freinds ... and you're rarely disappointed. Some of the most septic, vituperative, myopic and moronic fans outside Fulham (ie Chelsea). Notice I said 'some'. No more flukes for the Mancs - one season wonders.