Home > Football > Non, Monsieur Wenger, we're not racists
by Donna Gee on 19 September 2006
Email this Article (6) Comments
Free £25 bet when you register at
If I were an Arsenal supporter, I’d be hanging my head in shame. And it has nothing to do with results…just personnel. How can any English fan possibly identify with a club side recently took the field without a single Brit in their 16-man squad. Manager Arsene Wenger reckons such criticism smacks of racism. What rubbish; it smells more of deprivation to me. The Gunners and Chelsea, in particular, are depriving their loyal fans of the pleasure of seeing London lads in Gunners' shirts. And the FA are depriving home-grown players of the chance to play Premiership football by accepting the massive influx of overseas stars greedy to achieve their multi million-pound dreams.
This joke of a policy has to stop or they might as well change Arsenal’s name to Les Wengers and Chelsea’s to Jose’s Jokers. Granted, both teams are full of superstars but – with the exception of John Terry and Frank Lampard at Stamford Bridge – few have a genuine connection to the area they are supposed to represent. I’m not saying foreign players should be banned from English football. Far from it – soccer needs the biggest names in the game. But if Premiership clubs are not to lose their identity altogether, the luxury element has to be balanced by a quota of home-reared players.
When I started following football four decades ago, there were fewer than a handful of non-British players in the Football League, as it was then called. At my club, Cardiff City, we regularly fielded five locally-born players – and the team that won promotion to the First Division in 1961 contained six Welshmen, three Englishmen and two Scots. The only time we ever saw foreign players was in European competition, a regular treat in the Principality in those days since the winners of the Welsh Cup qualified for the now defunct European Cup Winners’ Cup alongside their English counterparts. How times have changed. But whatever Wenger says about picking a player for his quality, not his nationality, clubs like Manchester United are at least trying to keep the lid on the overseas contingent. The majority of Sir Alex Ferguson’s sides are invariably British - and I don’t see much difference in quality between his Red Devils and the Arsenal and Chelsea monsieurs and senors.
The answer is simple. The FA has to adopt cricket’s policy on overseas players - and limit the number of non-Brits a Premiership manager can in any squad. Personally, I’d impose a maximum of five foreign players - ensuring the predominantly British flavour of the side. It’s a flexible idea but one thing is certain. Let things go any further, and we’ll soon reach a point where it will be hard to spot the Brit. They used to have them at Arsenal, Monsieur Wenger. Remember?
Comments (6)
by Ali G on September 20, 2006
We shouldn't have opened our football to so many foreigners. That's why we keep failing over and over in the Mnodial...
by shweet on October 01, 2006
Why mention Chelsea in an article which so evidently points directly at Arsenal. You'll find that Chelsea have plenty of English talent in the side. Many more than numerous other of the supposed big clubs.
by Vinnie C on October 30, 2006
Ah a comment on England falling standards - but how so the foreigners fault? The reason that english players are not competing in th epremiership is simply there are too few with the necessary talent - the world cup should have demonstrated the sheer ordinariness of the average english footballer
by Arun on November 04, 2006
Telling a player he can't play on a team because he is a certain nationality should go a long way for FIFA's Anti-Racism campaign. *sarcastic*
by adam on November 16, 2006
if english players are good enough they will make it. if not they won't. this would destroy the premier league and all other comps.but especially in england, where the players are not good enough at the moment, and this would not help.
by shooy on April 15, 2007
Are you really so stupid. Wenger's English language limitations are as obvious as they are understandable, but your crassness is unfathomable avoidable and unforgiveable. I cannot speak for Wenger but suggest he probably meant you were xenophobes rather than racists and that sentiment would not fall short of the mark.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Ipswich Volz into town as Watford seek to close the gap
Houston lift-off: Will Ron Artest and Yao Ming combine to fire up the Rockets?
Roddick serves up a US Open treat to wrap up the first round
Arsenal Aston Villa Barcelona Chelsea Everton Football Liverpool Manchester City Manchester United Newcastle United Portsmouth Real Madrid Sunderland Tottenham Hotspur West Ham United