Liverpool short of manpower to cover for superman Steven Gerrard

Sun, Aug 12, 07 11:02
Rank it:
RSS  Digg  del.icio.us
What`s Online:


Steven Gerrard: Have Liverpool got cover for him? (Gettyimages.com)
Despite spending millions in the summer, Saturday's win at Villa showed again how much Benitez and Co depend on their brilliant skipper.
'Gerrard was dynamic and influential, driving the team forward to get the result'
It’s been an exciting summer for Liverpool fans. Rafa Benitez has been on a £40m spending spree the like of which Anfield has never seen before, a magnificent huge new stadium has been proposed and expectations are higher than they have been in a while. But after the first game of the season, despite the massive spend, one thing remains the same: Steven Gerrard is the key to their success.

There is no doubt that Benitez has made some exciting signings. Fernando Torres is a magnificent player with much skill and a great scoring record in Spain. Ryan Babel has shown a lot of potential in his time at Ajax and Andrei Veronin, Yossi Benyoun and young Brazilian Leiva Lucas all look like excellent acquisitions, but once again it was Gerrard who provided Liverpool’s spark and inspiration against Aston Villa in the opening game of the season.

As ever, he was dynamic and influential, driving the team forward to get the result after Jamie Carragher gave away a penalty.  Gerrard's never-say-die attitude is infectious towards those around him, and his free kick that ensured the three points for the reds was fantastic.

This is all well and good, but you worry for Liverpool if their talisman was to get injured or suspended. You look at the rest of their midfield and there is no-one who could take on Gerrard’s mantle, in a couple of years Javier Mascherano maybe, but for the time being Gerrard is untouchable. This could prove to be a problem for their championship aspirations.

You compare the depth of Liverpool’s squad to that of Manchester United or Chelsea and it seems this summer’s massive spending spree may not have been enough. Man for man Liverpool are probably still weaker than Chelsea, and definitely inferior to United. A midfield line up of Paul Scholes, Ryan Giggs, Cristiano Ronaldo and Owen Hargreaves is streets ahead of Liverpool. If Ronaldo was to have an off-day then any of the other three can take hold of the game in a way which Harry Kewell, Xabi Alonso or Momo Sissoko could not if Gerrard was out.

I’m sure the gap between Liverpool and the champions will be less than the 21 points this time round, but I think they will fall short once again until they sign midfield players who are nearer the calibre of their captain.

Are Liverpool too reliant on Gerrard? Post a comment below or submit an article to Sportingo.
Rank it:
RSS  Digg  del.icio.us
Comments
Mark (12/08/2007 11:55)
Why do I always get the feeling that Liverpool fans should have to apologise because Gerrard is our best player. Especially if he scores a winning goal. Yes he is our best player, he is also considered one of the best players in the world, so don't talk about finding cover 'of the same calibre' as him as if it were as simple as switching on a light. It's not easy to find a like for like replacement for Gerrard. You might not have noticed but slowly the players around him are improving. The likes of Baros, Biscan and Zenden have been replaced by Torres, Mascherano and Benayoun. Of course we would miss him if he were out. Just as Chelsea would be struggling without Drogba's goals and United of two seasons ago were miles away from last years team without Scholes organising in midfield for much of the season. As for United's midfield of Giggs, Scholes, Hargeaves and Ronaldo being streets ahead of say Gerrard, Mascherano, Babel and Benayoun, I'm not sure the difference is a stark as you suggest. It'll be interest
Farg (12/08/2007 11:58)
You are wrong. It was Ronaldo that actually won the league to United. It seems you did not see the game vs Milan in the semi final. Once Ronaldo played bad, the others were not able to 'take hold of the game'. One should first see games before talking nonsense
Mark Hanson (12/08/2007 12:00)
Shock horror. Liverpool haven't got two Gerrards in the team. We're shocking!! Chelsea are half the team without Lampard or Drogba. Man United never replaced Keane. But both have gone on to win the title. There's no replacing Gerrard, and why should we. We've got a host of midfielders and we can win games without Gerrard. Half of out CL run in 2005 was without Gerrard. We had Biscan, Diao and Le Tallec playing for us. You don't replace Gerrard. You find another way of playing.
Keith Morris (12/08/2007 12:01)
REally do not think you give enough credit to the quality of Alonso and Mascherano. I detect the bias of a red devil there!
Argish (12/08/2007 12:04)
You seem to forget when Alonso was decisive with his goals. You seem to forget that players such as Benayoun, Leiva and Mascherano were missing against villa, with Babel being reserve. It is a shame that certain 'writers' such as yourself write before making adequate research about the subject.
Thomas Norgaard (12/08/2007 12:09)
Of course there are no replacement for Gerrard in Liverpool's team - or in any other team for that matter. Because he's the most complete footballer the world have ever seen. Besides that, I believe that the depth of Liverpool's midfield is superior to United. Darren Fletcher? Hmmm, I think I would go for Sissoko if I had the choice.
Max (12/08/2007 12:09)
When Liverpool wins, the other supporters try to minimize it. Gerrard scored, so they say that Liverpool is so dependent on Gerrard. If Liverpool won but Gerrard did not score, they would say that Gerrard is rubbish, that he is not good! Go get a life and see your team other than seeing other teams!
chris (12/08/2007 12:16)
yes gerrards are best player but you may have noticed he'd already had 3 relatively easier chances while it was still 1-0 which he didn't put away. if he'd have made it 2-0 20 minutes earlier what would you have written about then? not really dramatic enough for you that is it? it's cliched journalism to the point of embarrassing.
302 (12/08/2007 12:17)
I think it's an obvious concern that you have noted but it's not unusual for top teams to be dependent on their star players, all of whom are not easily replaced and who are in short supply. Gerrard offers his team something special, that little bit extra but should he get injured, I suspect that his direct replacement will compliment a change of style and strategy. And as for challenging for the title, it is worth noting Aston Villa’s great home record and that Liverpool are now three points closer to achieving what has to be their primary target for the season.
bg (12/08/2007 13:18)
gerrard didnt actually have much of the ball yesterday but won the game with a piece of brilliance. yesterday showed we have other players who can inflict damage. villa will be good this year they are very tough. no one can take over agame single handedly and win a gme by himslef like gerrard. i have never soon rooney or ronaldo take over a game and win a trophy when the chips are down they can be marked out of games, you cant mark gerrard when he is in the mood
Paul (12/08/2007 13:22)
Same old tired article. Yawn. Sissoko, Alonso, Mascherano, the latter two especially, are WORLD CLASS midfielders. Gerrard is the best one we have. So why do we need to sign another Steven Gerrard? EVERY team has a 'best' midfielder. Gerrard is ours. Alonso, Mascherano and Gerrard are world class. Also, 'Gerrard provided the spark'? Really? Anyone watching the game would also tell you Kuyt and Torres were excellent and created the first goal between them, not Gerrard. So if Gerrard scores it's now 'all down to him'? Write something new please....
Paul (12/08/2007 13:26)
The writer would also find that if he researched the subject he would find that when Gerrard has been injured or not playing for Liverpool, they have also won a high % of their games and have had good results. A modern day myth that Liverpool won't win games if Gerrard isn't playing. Don't believe me? Look it up.
Paul (12/08/2007 13:26)
The writer would also find that if he researched the subject he would find that when Gerrard has been injured or not playing for Liverpool, they have also won a high % of their games and have had good results. A modern day myth that Liverpool won't win games if Gerrard isn't playing. Don't believe me? Look it up.
RedLester (12/08/2007 13:26)
The only comments lazy journalist have to make about Liverpool are the following: Gerrard shouldn't play on the right (every time we don't win a game and he's on the right). Despite the fact that he does so because it brings balance to the team. Our performances improved substantially when he was first moved out there. Zonal marking doesn't work in this country (every time we concede a goal from a corner) Despite our outstanding defensive record using zonal marking Liverpool without Gerrard are nothing (every time he scores a cracker to win the game.) Again, despite achieving an equal or better number of points in games he hasn't played over the last two years Rafa rotates too much (every time we don't win a game or the team looks tired). This is despite making exactly the same number of changes in the Premier League as Ferguson and Mourinho over the last two seasons. As you can see each of the above tired old cliche arguments that are dragged out by Andy Gray, analysts, ex-players and journos like your
RedLester (12/08/2007 13:28)
self and for the most part totally untrue or irrelevant. How about you start a trend of interesting, original journalism and see if you can get any of your fellow hacks to follow suit.
ABBEY (12/08/2007 13:34)
He can never be replaced. He is the most outstanding player in the world. But i dont think we can have two GERRARDS. I am still wondering why he hasnt yet won the award of WOELD'S BEST FOOTBALLER.
Amal Simothy (12/08/2007 13:42)
It's fair to say SG is a great player and second to none but everyone is replaceable .There are other equally very good players the likes of Alonso and Mascherano who can make a difference and lead the team to success. But Gerard also missed clear cut chances as well. I think the writers need to be less prejudice and more realsitic in their comments and get their facts right. Well Liverpool will prove you wrong in due course by lifting the premiership this year.
Crazy Wolf, Norway (12/08/2007 14:31)
Next season I would love to see us sign Everton`s Arteta and offloading Sissoko. A central midfield consisting of Alonso, Mascherano, Arteta and Gerrard would be absolutely fantastic - and it would give the team a better overall balance. If we could add a top-class winger and a goal predator, well, we`ll win the league every year!
William (12/08/2007 15:16)
Are to opologize for having the best central midfielder in the work within our ranks? Stupid. Gerrard has a lot of "cover" in Alonso, Sissoko, Masch, and now Lucas.
IstanKop05 (12/08/2007 15:18)
Don't know man, I can't understand why I keep reading this rubbish. I read that Liverpool's midfield is inferior to the mancs. I think he is referring to the age ratio. I heard that they are building a new pention home for some of their players.
IstanKop05 (12/08/2007 15:19)
Don't know man, I can't understand why I keep reading this rubbish. I read that Liverpool's midfield is inferior to the mancs. I think he is referring to the age ratio. I heard that they are building a new pention home for some of their players.
Bill M (12/08/2007 15:29)
I found the article very interesting. I agree that Gerrard is a fantastic player. Indeed he is a truly world class player. My definition of being world class is the ability to be able to take the game by the scruff of its neck and change its outcome. When the chips are down Gerrard is there. Remember the Olympiacos champions league match, Istanbul and the Fa cup against West Ham? Who else is there in the premiership or indeed anywhere who can match that? The suggestion that Liverpool have an inferior midfield to United and Chelsea is nonsense. It is liverpool who have the strongest midfield in the league. Apart from Gerrard, Mascherano is a monster. Before the champions league final all I heard was Kaka this and Kaka that. Mascherano took him out of the game (it was only when mascherano was substituted that Kaka made that all important assist). Alonso is sheer class and is second to none when it comes to passing the ball. Add to that the energetic and combative Sisoko. He reminds me of a young Viera but w
Supgogg (12/08/2007 15:49)
If we had someone as good as Gerrard or someone who was marginally weaker than him, your article would be twice as bad. Then we would have lacked two sufficient covers. It's just puberty football talk you're presenting. Gogg
Yogi (12/08/2007 16:56)
Sorry waht's your point? Do Milan have a replacement for Kaka NO, however we can replace with quality in the fact that we have Mascharano, Xabi Alonso, Sissoko and it is believed that Lucas will be a bit of a player. So if you believe that we need more midfield quality then I believe you need either new glasses or a brain transplant you numpty
Scouse Billy (12/08/2007 17:04)
Yes, Numpty look what your team just did. Even after 70 mins at 0 - 0 Andy Gay was talking about it being a training session. If it had been Liverpool he's have been going on and on about profligacy and why we aren't up to the clinical lethal efficiency of Chesea and Manure. Ha bloody ha sob into your ManU hanky.
rowan Blades (12/08/2007 19:45)
This is absolute drivvel, one game in and you are already saying such bull. Having not seen everyone play yet, or how we will develop, this is unfounded. Gerrard is obviously going to have an inspired season now he has more good players around him. Central mf is our strongest position, we have 5 of the best for 2 places. You'll be eating your words soon.
Gary King (12/08/2007 20:43)
I would be extremely embarassed putting my name to this article. Every team has a 'Star player', it does not mean without them the team suffers. I think you need to re-evaluate your thoughts on the strength of our midfield, it is the strongest in the premier league. Maybe people are a little bit more scared of Liverpool this season eh? Are you one of the 'top two'... ha ha ha
RED SAM (12/08/2007 21:13)
Knob head
wambam (12/08/2007 22:10)
he only scored a freekick
Taffy (13/08/2007 03:29)
What a complete load of b0110cks! Would Barca be able to find someone to 'take on the mantle' of Ronaldihno? Chelsea for Drogba? Would Nani 'take on the mantle' of Ronaldo? "No!" is the answer to all of those questions! ....and now we'll see who takes on the mantle of Rooney, won't we?! World-class players are, by definition, irreplaceable.
Gary (13/08/2007 03:37)
It's unbelievable how inept your knowledge of football is. I wouldn't dare publicly write an article like this about another team without researching first. Obviously we've not got a direct replacement for Gerrard, the mans world class. However look at who can play alongside him or fill in when he's out. We will be the envy of any team in Europe with these midfield players. You said our midfield is in inferior to Utd's. write down our midfielders and compare it theirs, or after writing that load of rubbish don't you know who we have in our squad?
ahmed (13/08/2007 04:59)
i would just laugh at you.... do you know? right now in this world there is no other midfield line stronger than LIVERPOOL.... hehe... Stevie..Xabi..Masch...Momo..Leiva... you must be mad to say united is better in that departmen... is it why they fail to win against a weaker READING than $ backed VILLA... go wash your mouth...utd is no better team even last term..they only won the championship because of ronaldo...Michael Duberry marked ronaldo so well and United loss 2 points.... united is Sh*t.. Liverpool rules... oh! Graham Smith...just wait and see....
4 ever reds fan (13/08/2007 06:49)
hi
he he every team in this world has to warry about liverpool cuz they are the best side in this world specialy man utd and arsenal chelsea has no history in egland that doesnt make sense .....
paul (13/08/2007 08:37)
arsenal struggle to beat fulham at home and it could be their biggest game of the season(andy gray).No Henry. manure struggle to a draw at home to Reading.No Rooney. Chelsea struggle to beat birmingham at home.(bad goalkeeping for 2 goals)No fit Drogba . Liverpool win at villa and they have problems without SG. Surely u should have written this piece about the other teams shortcomings. Lazy, ill informed, anti liverpool dross.
Obi Adumekwe (13/08/2007 11:42)
Well done fellow Reds for slating this poor piece of journalism. I had so much to say, but you've all said it!
Brian Boitano (13/08/2007 16:51)
Very poor article, everyone knows Gerrard is a class act and would be missed in any team if he was injured, but thats why you have a squad in football. I think Liverpool would miss a number of players if they we're injured such as Carragher & Agger to name but 2, however they along with all the 11 players on the pitch contribute just as much in securing victories. Funny how no ones done an article to say how Man U are going to lose the premiership title now Rooney's out injured, which would be just as stupid
BRAND_0 (14/08/2007 09:33)
Had Ronaldo got injured for UTD last season and Drogba got injured for Chelsea last season, we could have seen Liverpool and Arsenal battling for top spot. It's that simple. Of course we have cover for Gerrard, but that cover isn't as good as Gerrard. Who should we buy as cover for Gerrard? Kaka? Scholes? Essien? Xavi? Come on mate, you've been given the chance to have your say - next time have a good think before your hit 'send'.
Malaysia LFC (14/08/2007 11:29)
Gerrard had an average game in that match. If he has a good game, he would had scored a few goals in open play. U have to have some luck if u are to score in free kick. Look at the last kick Ronaldo took in the game between Man U and Reading, off target. If Gerrard got injured or suspended, somebody will repalce him and Rafa will have a solution to this problem. This is his job. Is up to the team and strategy to deliver the result. Everybody in the team will have to perform the job for the team.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED







*
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team




Daily Poll

Who will win the Champions League?