I am a Tottenham fan, I love the club, but it’s time to be honest. Michael Dawson has been fooling a lot of people for a long time now and he really isn’t good enough to wear the shirt. Watching the young England defender struggle to deal with the simplest of clearances has become embarrassing.

The moment Ledley King comes back from injury it should be Dawson, and not Younes Kaboul, who makes way. The former Nottingham Forest lad has flattered to deceive for far too long and he, much like Paul Robinson, needs to be dropped. I see little or no merit in picking a player simply because he has a reputation.

Anyone who thinks the 23-year-old is a solid, dependable centre-back needs their head tested. The guy couldn’t trap a bag of cement, he is positionally inept and only gets away with his misdemeanors by putting in the most obvious of challenges or clearing into row Z.

‘Anyone who thinks the 23-year-old is a solid, dependable centre-back needs their head tested. The guy couldn’t trap a bag of cement.’


There is no doubting his commitment and his determination but we are in the Premier League and having a never-say-die attitude is not enough to warrant a starting place. A player at this level needs some semblance of talent and right now, and for at least the last nine months, the Yorkshireman has in the main been a very poor part of the first team.

There will be many Spurs fans who, like me, sit and watch these guys week in, week out, travelling long distances to show their support for the cause, who may feel that I am over exaggerating and that I should give the guy a break, but I would ask them to watch that performance last night again and then think carefully about what I have said here.

OK, he is nowhere near as bad as Anthony Gardner, whose ineptitude is well documented, but the worse thing about Dawson is the fact that so many people seem to think he should have a place in the England set-up. That is ridiculous. You could not even compare the guy to John Terry, Rio Ferdinand or Sol Campbell – he simply doesn’t come close.

Again, maybe all he needs is a reality check, some time out of the first team so that he knows he won’t get a place simply off the back of ill-deserved media hype. What he does have at least is heart, and that is more than can be said for at least half of the Spurs side that played at St James’ Park last night. But heart alone is not a good enough reason to keep handing him a beloved Tottenham shirt.

Should Michael Dawson be dropped? Have your say below or write your own Sportingo article