Home > Football > A foreign takeover, Gerrard? Liverpool skipper's attack is xenophobic claptrap
by Jaimie Kanwar on 15 November 2007
Email this Article (85) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Big savings on football products from boots to balls!
Comments (85)
by Groovy Dude on November 15, 2007
Don't get your panties in a bunch miss. Who gave you the right not to be offended? Gerrard is a legend and you are nothing but a bad writer.
by John McLaughlin on November 15, 2007
Excellent article. I couldnt agree more. Carra for Captain!!
But i suppose you will get critisism for writing something negative about Stevie. He can do no wrong in some peoples eyes. I think some Liverpool fans support him above the club. He is a good footballer but he doesnt have two brain cells to rub together.
by Billium on November 15, 2007
"Foreigner" not nice word. Me not speak so good but I hope Englanders come to Euro 2008. Russian crumpet better than Engleesh tart but I lost my rubles.
by Colie on November 15, 2007
Listen if your going to do an article on quotes given by a footballer on a subject, put the whole interview in because I noticed how you left half of it out and picked bits here and there to suit yourself and your argument. If anyone is being smallminded here it have a long look in the mirror pal. Having read the full interview it's quite clear that stevie obviously wasn't happy at the amount of opportunities for englands young and upincoming stars to tie down regular places in the top tier of english football, and by the way it is called the english premier league, not the spanish, not the german, not the european, so for steve to say our league it's like saying our national side. This kind of writing I presume can be found in some mosque's around england.
by Mungo on November 15, 2007
You are clearly an articulate chap. Stevie isnt, but dont be pedantic. You know what he means, but you are an aspiring tabloid writer trying to sensationalise every little thing. Talk of xenophobia and BNP is way wide of the mark and out of order. Have you ever seen a Liverpool game? Have you noticed that much of the team is made up of foriegn (sorry, "overseas") players? Steve clearly hates them all and cant stand playing them. Now put your writing skills into something positive and stop with the over-reactions and tabloid style hero knocking.
by Barnesy on November 15, 2007
I read the article too and irrespective of the context, Gerrard's quotes in the above article can be considered in isolation. Gerrard should have kept his mouth shut. His 'foreigner' tirade is embarrassing and not the kind of outburst that should be associated with a Liverpool Captain.
by Jambo on November 15, 2007
Mr. Kanwar is well known to us. He has a psychpath bedroom with walls covered in Stevie G posters and photos. "I hate him. I Love Him. I hate him. I love Him."
by kopknight on November 15, 2007
again another article truing to pick holes at liverpool players or the team as a whole. The article is Pure unadulterated claptrap, please don't do any more articles and consider your life a failure!!!
by outraged on November 15, 2007
i don't know whether this was the author's or the editor's idea but it's disgraceful to muddy the waters and stiffle debate by comparing gerrard's comments with "bnp rhetoric". gerrard was commenting on what is a legitimate debate and you shame your profession by using such a cheap headline grabbing trick. sportingo?.........it's a fucking joke
by Xeno on November 15, 2007
Don't blame the foreigners or oversea players for the lack of talents in the English squad. The fact that there are so few English players in foreign soils say it all. English players are just not good enough fullstop. I have been a Liverpool supporter for 30 years and believe that Gerrard has spoken crap. His comment is as good as his intelligence on football field. He is a talented footballer but not a smart one. I have also supported England. Unfortunately, it is the way that the English plays their football that make them crap. All bullish but no skill. Arsenal is known to be the most stylist club because they have some of the most talented and skillful oversea players. One can only blame those young English players who demand high pay before they are developed into skillful if not world class players. As a football lover, I enjoy watching the foreign players in English league.
by AndyPandy on November 15, 2007
I agree with Jambo. Kanwar is obsessed with Stevie G. He has a Kop site almost dedicated to serving up his diatribe, mostly on SG. It is really quite sad. I wish I could help but I think he is a lost cause. Get a Grip, Kanwar, Get a Life.
Listen Barnesy it's quite bleedin obvious what stevie g was saying and putting across, now if people want to get pc and tip toe once someone mentions the foreigner word, he was talking exactly the way pundits talk (unless your ron atkinson) but what's nearly worse than racists is people looking for racism at the drop of a mispelt word or a word spoken out of context. Grow up and stop been so trivial, anyone who questions someone now over that should be deported out of the country to begin with.
by Anon on November 15, 2007
I bet you really are a Liverpool fan too.
by Liverpool4ever on November 15, 2007
Have to agree, regardless of what context these quotes were in they are still ignorant and should warrant an explanation. If overseas players were to leave Liverpool we'd be screwed and then Gerrard would be moaning we have no drive and would leave. On one side he is delighted at the capture of Torres as it shows our ambition but then he comes out with this? So many Liverpool fans see him as untouchable but he ain't, he's a great player when he wants to be but he's no captain
This has nothing to do with being PC - Gerrard's liberal use of the word 'foreigner' smacks of xenophobia, pure and simple. Granted, he's clearly not the sharpest knife in the draw, but he should have a little more self awareness. The problem is, comments like Gerrard's will be picked up by the kids who idolise him and they will twist it into something negative. I doubt Gerrard was being deliberately xeniphobic - however, he should be more aware of what he is saying in the public eye and how things can be misconstrued. I mean, banging on abot 'foreigners taking over the league?!' - it's pathetic.
by Woolyback on November 15, 2007
Imagine being married to someone who constantly attacks what he professes to love; someone who says his affection and devotion is delivered through criticism alone. SG is just a footballer, Jamie, just a footballer. You can Love Liverpool without this abuse. Let it Be.
by Al on November 15, 2007
This article is ill-conceived and poorly executed; it's looking for an argument where there simply isn't one. Gerrard is not peddling xenophobic propaganda as you imply: he was merely answering a question put directly to him by the media. A question which is currently a hot topic and instigated by a foreigner no less esteemed by Michel Platini, the head of UEFA. In fact Platini can be said to endorse Gerrard's view as he has already commented on the deleterious affect on homegrown youth development in all the top leagues, and particularly the EPL, due to the massive expansion in importing talent. Gerrard merely said that he supported the concept of imposing quotas of homegrown players on teams – a system already in effect in the Champions League and other leagues such as Spain’s. The writer has a fair point when he suggests that the current predicament of the England team has nothing to do the number of foreign players, and all in the England camp need to look closer to home to find a reason for that fail
I can only be construed by absolute numpties like the people on here who make something out of nothing. Every day on sky sports, bbc 1 they talk about "foreign players" and do they get wrapped over it. You look at all the teams in the top division and you would only have a handfull of english players in each side compared to ten years ago, where foreign players were far and few between. There's nothing xenophobic about his comments it's plain fact. He is quite obviously annoyed enough english players aren't being given a chance and as well that they are not good enough if that is the case. Get out from under your white man hates all except his own, when it's obvious what gerarrd meant.
by paraboy on November 15, 2007
Have to agree. I'm not a Liverpool fan but have noticed this chap Kanwar constantly has a dig a Gerrard. Time to let it go, fella, he's happily married....to a bird.
by Bon bon on November 15, 2007
To construe an argument that Gerrard is ranting “BNP” style rhetoric ludicrous and inflammatory. Proof of the writer’s knee jerk judgementalism is his misapprehension of perfectly sound English word ‘foreigner which is not in itself deemed to be derogative. Please refer to the terms ‘foreign aid’ and ‘Foreign and Commonwealth Office’ as examples and then see me after school, Mr Kanwar. Whilst on detention we can also discuss your homework, which I consider to be a feeble attempt at creating a trenchant and controversial opinion piece in the hope of being taken seriously as a journalist and being plucked out of obscurity as a web content hack. You may also wish to take note on those words that do actually imply racism and I refer you to your sentence . “overseas players are more intelligent, more disciplined, more technically proficient and more skilful than English players. Always have been and always will be.” Now who is the racist Mr Kanwar?
By the way it was "SIR" AF who was ferguson who was first to make a comment on this but none of his comments were nit picked so outragously, it's just a case of someone toepoking around looking for someone to bash and get media frenzy going. Absolute shite.
[quote]This has nothing to do with being PC - Gerrard's liberal use of the word 'foreigner' smacks of xenophobia, pure and simple. Granted, he's clearly not the sharpest knife in the draw, but he should have a little more self awareness. The problem is, comments like Gerrard's will be picked up by the kids who idolise him and they will twist it into something negative. I doubt Gerrard was being deliberately xeniphobic - however, he should be more aware of what he is saying in the public eye and how things can be misconstrued. I mean, banging on abot 'foreigners taking over the league?!' - it's pathetic.[/quote]don't insult the intelligence with the indignant stance. gerrard's comments were open and honest and on a subject which is quite legitimate to debate(as is being done at differing levels within football right now), your attempts to skew what are legitimate comments says more about your lack of intellect than it does gerrard's.