Ryan Giggs' 100th league goal for United, County's first Premier League away goal of the season and their fans singing, "We're Derby, we're crap" ...

Were Manchester United that good – and Derby that awful? You have had time to think things over and watch the replays on TV so now it's your turn to be the pundit and tell us what went right and what went wrong?

For Derby, is there any hope that new boss Paul Jewell can help you fight off an instant return to the Championship? Were there any signs of life in your seemingly doomed side?

‘... what about Giggsy's contribution on Saturday and over the years – and was Ronaldo right to take the penalty which would have given Carlos Tevez a deserved hat-trick?’


For United, what about Giggsy's contribution on Saturday and over the years – and was Ronaldo right to take the penalty which would have given Carlos Tevez a deserved hat-trick?

Let us know your thoughts – it’s your chance to be the pundit. Just post your verdict in the space below.