Home > Football > Can't speak English, negative thinking - Fabio Capello is NOT the man for England
by John Lyon on 13 December 2007
Email this Article (13) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Big savings on football products from boots to balls!
He has won titles with AC Milan, Juventus, Roma and Real Madrid; this sentence alone makes him a front runner for the England job. His calm, almost ice-like stature in the dugout is world renowned, as is his uncompromising way of dealing with players and press alike. All good qualities in a man who is being touted as the favourite for the toughest job in world football.
I'm not convinced, though, not even in the slightest. Undoubtedly, this man will win further trophies with a very successful team who are prepared to pay him at lot of money (the FA are apparently willing to stump up an astronomical £5million a season contract for him). But I really can't see what he will bring to the table which will develop the national team into a world-beating force.
For starters, the guy doesn't speak much English - this has been a topic of hot debate recently, as many see this as only a minor chink in the great man's armour. Personally, I see it as a major reason for not hiring the guy. He may have all the tactical nous that is required to compete at such a high level, as well as the ability to make game-changing decisions and the guts that go with it. But without the ability to communicate and relate his ideas to the people who will actually be charged with carrying out his well-thought out and detailed tactical plans, this point of fact becomes completely null and void.
This leads me on to my main argument; can anyone actually tell me the last time you saw a team prepared by Capello that didn't operate with a 4-5-1 and included two sitting midfielders? Why do you think the Real Madrid management gave him the boot after winning the league? I can tell you it wasn't because they didn't like the look of him, it was solely down to the fact that even with the highly-entertaining and grossly-overpaid gaggle of footballers that Madrid posess, they played like a typical Italian team and only ever beat the Getafes and the Recreativos (no disrespect) 1-0 or 2-1.
Surely after the Sven saga, who was berated for playing such negative tactics (in hindsight, bring back the balding Swede, no?) we will have even less patience with a manager who insists on enforcing such negative and dull tactics, thus further wasting the talents of the likes of Steven Gerrard, Frank Lampard, Wayne Rooney, SWP and so on.
My point is that obviously Capello is a world-class manager, and has the trophies and track record to prove it. However, if we were to employ him as the manager of England, he will only bring a negative style of play that will instantly attract media criticism, and therefore produce another McClaren situation all over again.
We need a manager, English or not, who will create a system of play that fits around the players, and which doesn't just incorporate high-profile players because they earn £120,000 a week at their clubs (**cough**Lampard **cough**).
If Brian Barwick and his team of minions had a few brain cells to rub together, they could see that employing a non-speaking, negative-thinking manager would be the final nail in all of their long overdue coffins.
Comments (13)
by Denver on December 13, 2007
Actually i disagree.he would be a good choice.look at it this way.real madrid hadn won the league for 4 years or around there.capello delivered it.england havent won a trophy for what 40 years?england already play sh** football.i mean rooney is being wasted as it is.capello will not be afraid to drop lampard.if 4 5 1 gets you trophies then he should use it.england never plays good football anyway
by Shane Robinson on December 13, 2007
J*sus he has has only been interviewed for the job and already you are having a go. He shouldn't bother because the English are never happy no matter what manager they have.
by mark on December 13, 2007
He didn't speak spanish but learnt it very quickly and won the league with Real Madrid. He'll pick English no problem. Also, at 61 he will not be swayed by the media. You want a manager who will pick a system to suit the players. This is what has been the problem in English football for too long. Capello will pick the players to suit the system and if they don't like it they can get lost. If Hargreaves gets injured, for example, he will pick the next best defensive midfielder, not bring in Lampard and change formation. Under Cappello there will be no more squre pegs into round holes. Remember scholes on the left wing under Sven and Andy Johnson on the right wing under McLaren.
by Mark on December 13, 2007
And unike McLaren and Sven he will not idolize the players, and inflate ther egos even further. Having managed the likes of Gullit, Maldini and Van Basten, he will have a more realistic assessment of the squad. And there will be no more wags on tour or senior player consultations etc etc. Bring it on.
by Deepak on December 13, 2007
English fans only want the likes of Mourinho or Wenger or Lippi. Well, you are'nt gonna get them. You have to ask if they want you. On the other hand, of the people who do want you, Capello is probably the best. So instead of wanting what you won't get (deserve), embrace someone who is a proven performer and before he comes to his senses.
by JonW 007 on December 13, 2007
I don't think not being completely fluent in English is as big of a concern as you think. About his tactics.. well.. I hate to say it but Italy won under the same sort of defensive, gritty play and well.. thats what got them to the final in 06'. They shut down Germany, who at the time, were creative, fluent, and highly favored to go to the final with Klinsi. I don't think the two factors you pointed out were big enough to discredit Capello. However, I think there are a few better candidates out there for the job and the FA should sit down and talk with all of them before making any big decisions.
by lee churchman on December 13, 2007
in one sentence, the man is a winner.
by Nasser on December 13, 2007
Just a thought is there an English manager that has even won 1 league title, never mind a Inter Toto Cup. Capello is argubly the best manager around, forget the likes of Ferguson and Wenger. Their achievments fail by the side of Fabio. Can we now close this article and archive it as there is no relevance ?
by MuthaHubbardIsGay on December 13, 2007
Fabio is a great manager - england first want to win some trophies, then that will encourage the younger generation to take up the game - they can be taught how to play beautifully but this team is too far gone. All it needs is a trophy.
by John Lyon on December 13, 2007
Most of you seem to be missing my point; I start the article by saying the man's CV is unrivalled as he is clearly a worldclass manager. My point was that if you play negative tactics and have an obvious language weakness, this will leave him wildly open to criticism from the ever-impatient media and public. When we start playing poorly, the first thing the critics will say is 'the formation is wrong' or 'we can only beat the worst teams 2-1.' Hiring Capello looks amazing on paper, but in my mind, terrible in reality
by fdas on December 13, 2007
I think the language problem is bigger than most people realise. Apart from Hargreaves, none of the other players have played in a foreign environment, with a manager and back-room which speak another language. Capello's probably got methods and manners that are completely different to what England players expect, and that'll throw them. I suspect there'll be a adjustment period. But then again, what manager doesn't have that problem? And the six months or so before the World Cup Qualifiers will be plently of time to adapt.
by Football Transfer on December 14, 2007
don't understand English, no worry because i think the assistant would be an Englishman.
by Blue bell on December 20, 2007
They should have begged borrowed or stealed Ferguson at whatever it would take.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Jelena Jankovic v Ana Ivanovic - Serbian tennis rivals for the world No.1 spot
Is Colin Calderwood the man to re-light the Nottingham Forest fire?
Spurs go one better than Barcelona in Krakow – now bring on Hull City!