When I wrote recently that Liverpool were out of the Premier League title race, I received hate mail and death threats from Reds fans. And those were the positive responses.

The negative ones were a lot worse. Now that this has effectively become a reality (though somewhere I'm sure some loyal Liverpool supporters insist their team are still in it) their pain must be very great indeed. The truth hurts, lads. No denying that. But it gets better if you accept it. Now repeat after me: We are not going to win the Premier League this year. See? Feels better already doesn't it?

OK, now in all seriousness I will concede that Wigan are playing a lot better than, um, ever. In fact, I made the point on Boxing Day that Steve Bruce's men were looking like a real Premier League side for once. Bruce has actually never even lost a league match against Rafa Benitez so you might have figured Latics to perhaps pick up a point at Anfield last night. Their previous 20 matches against Top Four teams had seen 20 defeats.

'If there is still a Big Four then the Reds are the quartet's ugly red-headed stepchild, the only one that has never won a Premier League title'


The Big Four? Aye, there's the rub.  Such a concept may no longer exist - if indeed it ever did. Since their best-ever (and only) runners up spot in 2002, Liverpool have twice finished fifth in the Premier League. They  have spent most of this season struggling for fourth place.

They still have that game in hand and may still make the Champions League spots. I will also grant Liverpool  fans the argument that their team was the better one for most of the game at Manchester City. But if there is still a Big Four then the Reds are the quartet's ugly red-headed stepchild, the only one that has never won a Premier League title.

Will this be the end for Benitez? Unlikely, if only because the American owners don't want to turn the manager  him into a martyr, and themselves into pariahs. But the team don't inspire on the pitch.

They have many good players, but no great ones. Even Fernando Torres, skillful as he is, does not dominate like a Cristiano Ronaldo, Cesc Fabregas, or Didier Drogba. Liverpool have neither Mancheter United's guile, nor Arsenal's pace, nor Chelsea's strength. Rafa can cry for new acquisitions, but unless it's a Kaka or Ronaldinho or Zlatan that Tom Hicks is buying, it will not fix the Reds. The team's problems go deeper than that.