Home > Football > Refs must nail the football scrumbags
by Donna Gee on 22 October 2006
Email this Article (2) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
So Thierry Henry reckons football referees should be more like rugby officials…and talk to the players. The Arsenal striker’s rant came after Spanish official Manuel Gonzales ruled out a legitimate equaliser in the dying minutes of his team’s 1-0 Champions League defeat by CSKA Moscow.
‘’I would like the game to come a bit more like rugby, because in football you cannot speak to the referee,’’ said Henry. ‘’If you try, they won’t even give you and answer. You don’t want to have a go at them – just ask them what they saw at crucial times in the game. But you’re not allowed to do that. ‘’People say that footballers should be more like rugby players and accept every decision. But they can talk with the referee. We can’t do that.’’
Let’s take Henry’s last point first. In football, if players don’t agree with a decision, they don’t so much TALK to referees as swear at and abuse them – even when they’ve got the decision 100 per cent right. You can put it down to soccer players’ comparative lack of education if you like – but I blame it on the fact that football does not give referees sufficient authority.
The football authorities must make it abundantly clear that the referee’s decision is final – and if they don’t like it, then take an early bath. It’s not only refs who can learn from rugby – it’s the entire antagonistic, bickering, moaning, foul-mouthed, spitting round-ball game that needs to learn a lesson from its vastly-more-cultured neighbour.
How FIFA and the FA continue to tolerate the disgraceful behaviour of so many so-called ’stars’ I will never know. If any form of dissent were immediately penalised with a free-kick ten yards nearer to their own goal (a la rugby), the game could be cleaned up virtually overnight. If a player continues to complain, then move the free kick another ten yards – and if that takes it into the penalty area, then award a spot-kick. A penalty for telling the ref to f*** off on the half-way line? Yes, it really could happen – but I guarantee it would clean the game up.
It’s so easy, so logical…yet the authorities just stand by and let players abuse officials willy-nilly. OK, the ref does have the option of booking dissenters, swearers etc, even sending him off if the offence is persistent. But in a game where players harangue and fire obscenities at officials as a matter of course, referees’ powers are pathetically weak. There is no way behaviour will improve until players are either sent off immediately they step out of line – or automatically receive the 10-yard penalty treatment for any form of dissent.
Rugby has another great law – the referee’s power to REVERSE a free kick or penalty. Imagine what a furore that would cause. He awards a fouled player a penalty, the player gets up and rants at the ref that he should send the perpetrator off – and the official immediately awards the spot-kick to the other side! Now that would perhaps be a bit TOO stringent – but boy would it make a difference to players’ behaviour!
So the ref did get it wrong over Henry. The answer to that would be to introduce video technology to ensure all important decisions are correct. A quick video playback would have confirmed to the referee that Henry did not handle the ball…but bringing the game into the 21st century – as rugby did years ago – would be too simple for Sepp Blatter and his antiquated Fifa pals.
Comments (2)
by Bluebird007 on October 24, 2006
Personally, I think we need rugby 'style' ref's (male or female)! Argue and you move back ten yards, carry on and you're in the sin bin! Couldn't something like this be introduced at a youth level so by the time players get into first teams they have a bit more respect?!
by Chenz on May 05, 2007
Rugby and football are not equal
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Tendulkar, Ganguly, Dravid and Laxman - why are Indian cricket fans so tough on the Fab Four?
Andy Roddick still has time to turn yesterday's tennis hatred into one final hurrah
Spurs go one better than Barcelona in Krakow – now bring on Hull City!
Arsenal Champions League Chelsea Cricket news Euroleague Fantasy football Football news Formula 1 Liverpool Manchester United NBA Newcastle United Premier League Sports news Tottenham Hotspur Transfer rumours Twenty20 UEFA UEFA Champions League
© SportBuzz All rights reserved 2008 Sportingo- Sports News & Sports Articles site. Sportingo delivers fresh sports news and analysis by fans-Football News, Tennis News, Rugby Union News, Rugby League, Cricket News, Cycling News, Basketball News and other Sports TV. XML Sitemap 2008.