Home > Football > Give racist players the boot - for life
by Donna Gee on 24 October 2006
Email this Article (5) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Racism, the biggest scourge of all in football, is rearing its ugly head again. And it stinks.
Blackburn Rovers’ South African striker Benni McCarthy was the victim of ugly abuse during Rovers’ 2-1 UEFA Cup win over Wisla Krakow in Poland on Thursday. However, it’s highly unlikely McCarthy or anyone else will be able to prove that defender Nikola Mijailovic committed what I regard as the most obscene offence in the game.
Of course, the Serbian is almost certainly guilty as alleged - why on earth would McCarthy make up such a claim if it didn’t happen? But proving the abuse is the problem. Just as no-one was able to prove that Italian ‘hero’ Marco Matarazzi hurled racist obsecenities at Zinadine Zidane in the World Cup Final. Hero? For me, Matarazzi is a scumbag -- even though the world’s best lip readers couldn’t establish exactly what the Azzurri defender said that so incensed Zizou.
I mean, Zidane launched that notorious chest-butt purely because he was an innately nasty man, didn’t he? Believe that and you probably think Watford are going to win the Premiership this season.
The racist taunts often come from crowds and players from East European countries - regions where there is little ethnic diversity and almost no blacks. Having little personal knowledge of non-whites, they apparently regard the barracking as an acceptable form of behaviour. In the West, the whole ethos of the game is to stamp racism out, yet we are still besieged by mindless idiots who feel that anybody of different ethnicity -- and blacks in particular -- are acceptable targets for their abuse.
In 2004, Spanish fans taunted black England players Ashley Cole and Shaun Wright-Phillips in a friendly match in Madrid, while Spain’s coach Luis Aragones reportedly made racist comments about Arsenal’s Thierry Henry. The Spanish Football Association was subsequently fined £44,750 by FIFA -- a pittance which will in no way deter the Iberian racists. Aragones, meanwhile, got away with a 3,000-euro fine. How pathetic!
Carlos Ferreyra Nunez, co-ordinator of Spain's United Against Racism group, said at the time that the problem was widespread in his country. "Racism is a cancer that has touched every aspect of football," he claimed, adding that racist behaviour could be seen "every week and all over the country".
If things are that bad, why on earth did FIFA take such a soft line? What they should have done was to boot Spain out of the European Championships or World Cup. Now that would have had an effect on everyone in the country … and taught the racists a lesson they clearly need.
Of course, racism in football is nothing new. Back in the 1930s, the late, great Dixie Dean - who was dark-skinned - had comments aimed at him as he left the pitch at half-time during an Everton match in London. Dean reportedly punched the offender before disappearing into the players’ tunnel - and was promptly congratulated by a policeman who saw the incident. That was long before I was born, and indeed non-white players were such a rarity in my childhood that they were a fascinating addition to any team - with no semblance of any prejudice.
The first black player I saw in the flesh was a little South African inside forward called Steve Mokone, who joined Cardiff City for the start of the 1959-60 season. Although he played only three games for the first team, he was the catalyst for the Bluebirds winning promotion to the old First Division that year - he scored after five minutes on his debut in the season’s opener against Liverpool and Cardiff went on to win 3-2.
Black players at other clubs - guys like Lindy Delaphena at Middlesbrough and Albert Johanneson at Leeds - were such a rarity that they were huge celebrities in the game, better known than almost any white player. Delaphena, a Jamaican, was in fact the first non-white ever to play in the English First Division (for Portsmouth in the late 1940s) and any prejudice against him was reportedly limited to his performances. If he played well, the fans loved him - if he had a bad game, then he became ‘‘that f***ing n***er’’.
John Barnes, who had bananas thrown at him at Highbury early in his Liverpool career - reckons that when black players retire, their chances of getting jobs in management are few and far between. Even if they do manage to get a job, he says, they aren’t given a second chance.
So how can we stop the racism, both on and off the field? Easy - just kick offending clubs out of whatever competition they are taking part in at the time of the incident. And any player proven to have made racist comments to or about an opponent should be banned for a very long time -- maybe even for life.
I know we’d be running the risk of players making up claims to get opponents they regarded as particularly obnoxious into trouble. But then, would anyone want a fellow player kicked out of the game for something he didn’t do, however much he disliked him?
Discrimination in management is something far more difficult to deal with. It’s the same as a high-street employer who rejects a black applicant for a job -- he’ll always find another reason to cover up his prejudice. But if it is ever proven that a football club has rejected a black managerial applicant because of his ethnicity, then the authorities must hit the offenders with a ton of bricks.
One thing is abundantly clear. If the Let’s Kick Racism Out Of Football campaign is to succeed, then the football authorities must make the penalties fit the crime.
They’ve had long enough to sort it out, for God’s sake.
Comments (5)
by Zack on October 23, 2006
you are right on as sport should not tolerate racism. The one thing sport has tought us is to look at the merit of the player and not his skin color or background. Fans should get a place to voice their opinion but race should not be part of it
by Matthew Campbell on October 23, 2006
I think you will find that the ground at which bananas were most conistently thrown at John Barnes early in his Liverpool career was not Highbury but in fact Anfield. Racism starts at home, as they say.
by Donna Gee on October 23, 2006
John Barnes did have bananas thrown at him at Anfield - and suffered a considerable amount of prejudice during his career. These are his own recollections, as told to the BBC: "I remember as far back as 1981 playing at places like Millwall and West Ham when you'd get the usual monkey noises and bananas being thrown onto the pitch. It was almost an accepted part of society so not very much was made of it. I considered them to be ignorant, so I never responded to it because I thought they'd have won if it had affected my game. I suppose the most famous incident was in 1987 or 1988 when I was playing for Liverpool against Everton and I back-heeled a banana off the pitch. Because Liverpool v Everton was a very high-profile game a lot was made of it, but that sort of thing had been going on for years and years. We will know we have made great strides when we see more black and Asian supporters going to football matches, because while football can protect you for 90 minutes from overt racism - slogans and chan
slogans and chanting - those fans still have to walk away from the stadiums and onto the bus and that's where they don't feel safe. I don't think footballers get the abuse they once did, but I don't think anything's changed in terms of the racism that exists in this country generally.''
on April 29, 2008 on April 29, 2008
leeds 4 league 1 title
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
England must scrape the bottom and turn to Spurs for wide-left salvation
Spurs go one better than Barcelona in Krakow – now bring on Hull City!
Ouch! The TOP TEN freak sports injuries
Arsenal Champions League Chelsea Cricket news Euroleague Fantasy football Football news Formula 1 Liverpool Manchester United NBA Newcastle United Premier League Sports news Tottenham Hotspur Transfer rumours Twenty20 UEFA UEFA Champions League
© SportBuzz All rights reserved 2008 Sportingo- Sports News & Sports Articles site. Sportingo delivers fresh sports news and analysis by fans-Football News, Tennis News, Rugby Union News, Rugby League, Cricket News, Cycling News, Basketball News and other Sports TV. XML Sitemap 2008.