Home > Football > Portsmouth beat Manchester United fair and square, Sir Alex, so stop moaning!
Portsmouth beat Manchester United fair and square, Sir Alex, so stop moaning!
Did frustration get the better of Fergie? He was certainly out of order with his bad sportsmanship after his team's FA Cup exit.
by Lennard Pearce on 09 March 2008
Email this Article (22) Comments
Free £25 bet when you register at
Whatever happened to being gracious? Yesterday was a great day for the underdog but the special celebrations for Pompey were tempered by the show of bad sportsmanship displayed by Sir Alex Ferguson.
Now I have all the respect in the world for the Man United boss. He is probably one of the most important managers in the modern game. However, his comments post match were simply outrageous and an example of the petulance that tends to exude from the Scot on the off chance his side is beaten, which is indeed very rarely.
He claimed his players were the victims of scandalous refereeing decisions and dangerous tackles. Hang on Fergie, the worst challenge of the entire match was unquestionably the two-footed lunge from Wayne Rooney that would have caused Niko Kranjcarserious damage had he not moved swiftly to avoid the barbaric attempt to remove his legs!
Even a fair-minded United fan must have seen how horrible that tackle was. He received a yellow card but, quite frankly, if intent to injure an opponent is enough to get someone a red card (and apparently it is according to the rule book) then Rooney deserved a red.
For Sir Alex then to ponder how Cristiano Ronaldo may end up like Eduardo due to the close attention he gets during match days and then to conveniently forget his own striker’s incredibly bad challenge stinks of double standards.
Let’s get this straight: The Old Trafford side probably shouldn’t have lost yesterday. However they weren’t cheated out of the Cup, they were simply unlucky and Portsmouth ended up winners. The penalty Pompey were awarded was a correct decision, the claims for a penalty at the other end were far from clear cut.
Portsmouth, in my view, deserved the win. It wasn’t just a case of United failing to score. A succession of fantastic defensive displays secured the victory for the Harry Redknapp's side. Glen Johnson must have done his chances of an England call-up no harm with his clearance off the line. Sylvain Distin and Sol Campbell could lay claim to being one of the best centre-back pairings in the Premier League, and the save that David James made when he tipped Partice Evra’s stinging drive on to the post, was superb.
The game isn’t all about goalscorers and yesterday proved that. Portsmouth defended far better than United. This was never more evident than when, on the break, Kranjcar and Milan Baros scythed through the back line to gain the penalty that won them the game.
Why can’t some managers take losing respectfully? Harry Redknapp generally has the class to take a defeat on the chin. Sir Alex, I suggest you should take a leaf out of his book!
Comments (22)
by Peter on March 09, 2008
I am afraid even United fans would have to agree. Enough of the moaning. United failed to convert their chances and Sir Alex's moaning just stinks of hypocrisy, that attempted tackle on Niko should have been a red card!
by Aziz Jalil on March 09, 2008
Pompey came to defend their goal and kick oponent legs and got away with their fauls. Poor refreering aided to their panelty kick which was what they look forward to happen.Both Refree and Portmouths shouldnt be allowed to be in this football game if they dont have the quality to play and the refree should be sacked as early in the 6th mins when he denied the stone block by Dustin on Ronaldo.Which culprit will ever admit their fault. For England sake please dont ever select him as defender because England will loose out to panelties given away by him (dirty rat - made by dirty Hary)
by Craig on March 09, 2008
I bet not one United fan will admit that Rooney's challenge was awful. They will avoid the issue, Pompey won deal with it!
by Ron Burgundy on March 09, 2008
It was just one of those days and if it was still being played now United would still not have scored. Makes me think that Portsmouth's name is on the cup judging by how lucky they were against Preston and again yesterday. Ferguson di however have cause for complaint as Distin did not even try to win the ball he just took the man and anywhere else on the pitch a foul would have been given and Anderson would have got a challenge in on Baros and Rooney was on the line,so sending off - Me thinks not. People just like to see United lose and take more pleasure in it than their own teams winning - Truth is that Portsmouth got lucky yesterday and anyone who actually knows anything about football will appreciate that. Fergie moaning was a bit much but the two decisions I have mentioned the ref got wrong simple as. Anyway Portsmouth go through and good luck to them.
by Number_7 on March 09, 2008
I am flabbergasted that people wont say that was a stonewall penalty, Disitn purposefully run into Ronaldo, he made his run in order to obstruct him, and not to play the ball. Those who keep on saying it wasn't a penalty need to have their eye checked.
by Brian on March 09, 2008
This writer has got it totally correct. No one is arguing that United deserved to win, the point is Sir Alex has some rather paranoid delusion that his side was 'cheated' or 'bullied' out of the cup. Neither is true. They were unlucky yes, but as the author so correctly pointed out, the worst challenge in the game, the one tackle that warranted a red card, even more than the Kuszczak, came from Rooney, it's time Sir Alex exercised some fairness and held his hand up for that blatant foul. If Fergie came out and said "Rooney should have been sent off, but hang on Pompey also fouled us off the park" then i would have some respect for him, but the fact he decides to not mention Wayne's challenge is typical of the man!
by ManU Diehard on March 09, 2008
Man U defeated by unqualified poor refreering. Pompey has nothing to show but only defended -what a stupid and dull Harry kind of football game.Surely Harry knows that if they play real football game Harry would have conceeded 5-0 or not more.As ManU fan I also blame Alex for not allowing Garrick to partner Hargreve in midfield and replace Hargreve with Anderson if things didnt work out in the first half. Why must he insisted on having Paul Scholes who is old and had no pace at all to play throughout the entire game.Anyway poor team choice secondly Fletcher and Pak should come in to replace Ronaldo and Nani because too often they were badly faoul but stupid refree just ignored and play on.The game ended with the extra man in the middle in favour of Pompey.The Dirty Harry game plan of the year.
by Abdulaziz on March 09, 2008
ManUtd 0-1 Atkinson(The Ref)
by Jeremy on March 09, 2008
Man Utd 0-1 Portsmouth - i think you got confused
by Man United on March 09, 2008
Look here Craig that challenge by Rooney did even touch the player at all.Did you see before that incident Rooney was fauled but refree just ignored the incident.
Yes i saw that Rooney was fouled before he lunged two footed like a maniac, does that make it any fairer a challenge? Yes he didn't touch the player, but that was more luck than judgement, do you think that challenge was the worst in the match?
by ManU Jaze on March 09, 2008
MU 0 - 1 Portmouth/Atkinson (share holder)
Rooney did that just to attract the refree attention and the refree did wake up and saw that it was no as bad has what it may seen.Its not a fair tackle but it didnt touch the player at all so why the fuss about.
Sylvian Distant clearly stoneblock Ronaldo from getting the ball thru and it is a panelty call. Atkinson you got it all wrong and should take the responsibility.England please watchout dont ever select him or loose out to panelty which world class refree would not tolerate this type of player.
by Dom jones on March 09, 2008
I'm sorry, but how is fergie being a 'sore loser'? he gave credit to pompey, and he admitted that we have ourselves to blame for missing about 20 chances. but what fergie slam the ref, but that was a culmination of a lot of bad refereeing in manutd matches. off the top of my head, pompey away with steve bennet sending of ronaldo, the spurs away when we should of had a penalty just before half time. the bolton match where we were literally kicked off the park, the city derby at old trafford where we should of had a penalty, hamman should have been sent off for two, two footed fouls, when petrov crossed for benjani petrov was offside. in the arsenal match flamini(intent),eboue(he was), gallas and ironicly eduardo should have been sent off for a two footed lunge on nani, and then the pompey match, but no one mentions any of these, why? because we aren't arsenal. we aren't useing these as excuses, but they are actual fact. for instance, a few years ago van nistle rooy had a little kick at ashley cole, wenger moaned and ruud got banned for 3 matches even though he wasnt booked, but when gallas does it, nothing happens, why? because the FA are so biased its unreal, as are the BBC, look at the pundits, all of them used to play for a rival team. so again, we arent claiming that all of these refs have stopped us being top, but we have been very unlucky with bad reffing decisions, if we were arsenal then everyone would highligh this. its a culmination of bad refs which set fergie off.
by ian enness on March 09, 2008
Sir Alex praised pompey but moved on to the standard of refs in our game .Each week there is another decision or mistake that English refs make. Newcastle lost at Chelsea to a goal that was yards offside. Two players lift there hands only one is sent off.Kyut of Liverpool jumps two footed head high against Everton, no booking nothing from the review panel. In business if a department is failing changes are made. This was the point Sir Alex was making. Our refs show no improvement they just fumble from one mistake to another. On and on they go, mistake after mistake.
by n n on March 09, 2008
both 'Man United' and 'Aziz Jalil' who i suspect are the same person say they hope that Distin is never picked for England, and here i was thinking that Distin is a Frenchman. Typical United idiot.
by Jorgen Roed on March 09, 2008
The author have some good points and some bad ones. Lets get it clear, United didnt deserve to lose the match, we had a very clear penalty rebuffed and were laying siege to their box for most of the match. So to claim that we deserved to lose the match is just not right. The penalty against us (United) was correct and sadly due to a not very good descision by Kuschack, he should have seen that Rooney was on the goalline and could have saved it. Instead we went one nil down and lost the keeper. Not good, and I have a feeling that VDS would have had enough awareness to let him go through. And I really dont understand why Tevez and VDS was taken off. The way this game went along, it was a typical Solskjaer/Tevez kind of game. Bad managing by Fergie. Apart from that we had soooo many clear goalchances and we should have killed this off in the first half.
I admit that it was a stupid tackle by Rooney but I dont agree that it was anywhere near hiting the itended "target". It was halfhearted and aimless, but nonetheless very stupid. Rooney is sadly not playing well at the moment.
by danny on March 09, 2008
Man united you are totally deluded to say that as rooney missed the player it made the challenge ok - rooney deserved a straight red card and a lengthy ban for his thuggery. If I was to get a gun and shoot at you would it be ok if I missed?
by Thomas Tomney on March 10, 2008
Portsmouth really rode their luck against a far superior team in Man utd.I think with the luck that Portsmouth have shown in recent weeks and with the refs somewhat favouring them I think they can go on and win the FA Cup.Freaks of nature happen and this would be a freak of nature if they do win it.