Home > Football > Lay off Keegan, the Newcastle boss is no failure
Lay off Keegan, the Newcastle boss is no failure
King Kev's comeback has been distorted by the media - and it hasn't been the total disaster they have made it out to be.
by Ed Bottomley on 22 March 2008
Email this Article (8) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
There has been lots of press reaction to Kevin Keegan's appointment as Newcastle United manager.
We have heard sneering criticisms and snide asides similar to the snooty responses when Avram Grant took over, mutterings that still occasionally come to the surface when the Israeli slips up.
The shrill media's constant cooing around St James' Park started from the moment Keegan put his 'King Kev' crown back on. The legend that they built up around his first tenure was that of an idyllic citadel of courageous attacking in the north east, they played football the right way, they were everyone's second team, and when they were pipped to the post by Manchester United, a nation wept.
The press have taken a different tone with Keegan's return, and after the wall to wall coverage of Keegan-mania the day he returned, they have been nothing but hostile. The papers portrayed Keegan as a bumbling oaf, washed up, out of touch and completely unable to manage, and made a huge story out of the fact that he had been working at a "soccer circus" - a cheap shot that was too easy to pass up in countless columns up and down the land.
Rumours did the rounds about his pre-match team talks which supposedly involved reading the opposition's team sheet, ostentatiously crumpling said sheet into a ball and tossing it in the bin, and then exclaiming "we can beat this lot!!"
A similar criticism was levelled at Avram Grant when he apparently started a team chat by outlining a "4-4-1" formation that he planned to use. Such rumours violently surge through the porous football media, and soon solidify into becoming perceived truth. Because Newcastle United was the media's pet project, whenever there was dead air that needed filling or spare unfilled column inches, they were devoted to Keegan and his beached whale of a club.
Everybody assumed that Geordie fans, so ecstatic with Keegan's return would change their minds as the defeats and losses rolled in without a solitary victory.
And when the transfer window slammed shut without any big name signings, Keegan was derided as having no knowledge of the game, someone so cut adrift from the footballing zeitgeist that he couldn't even drum up any decent suggestions for players to sign.
It is interesting that Sven-Goran Eriksson was also criticised this summer for buying signings too quickly and for acting in too cavalier a manner - signing players on the back of watching some DVDs.
Presumably Keegan would have received the same treatment if he had come in and quickly signed players.
I can see the headlines now: "Keegan in £20m panic buy”, "King Kev; spend spend spend!” These two managers share a filial bond of course, and that could be why the knives were out from the day they started at their latest jobs.
Both Keegan and Sven managed England, they drank from the poisoned chalice that now effectively guarantees that they are public enemy number one. Keegan, Sven, McClaren, Glenn Hoddle - they are all unmitigated disgraces in the media's eyes. And so here we are, Toon fans don't seem to care that Keegan's results haven't been good, they still claim that they are light years from the funeral march of having Sam Allardyce in charge.
And yet everyone still persists in telling the fans to be unhappy, willing them to reach the end of the tether. When are we going to leave them alone?
Comments (8)
by THE GREATEST on March 22, 2008
If keegan hasnt been a failure i dont know who has. Woeful record, by all accounts tactically inept and has won nothing of any substance as a manager. As for the way geordies talk about being a big club again- when were you ever a big club? Wise up people
on March 22, 2008 on March 22, 2008
Blatantly just bandwaggoning with the toon army that have slated the influx of anti-kev articles.
by MiMo on March 22, 2008
Man Utd the biggest collection of egos in Europe. Only a massive ego would name himself the greatest when the truth is completely different. Just where are Man Utd the greatest? not in Europe thats for sure. In the English game? no thats Liverpool. For a while in the 90s The Toon were bigger than Man Utd and were more popular than them too only an ego tripping Muppet who has "the greatest" as his moniker would fail to realize. Also just were do you come from? not Manchester I'd guess.
by DOG on March 22, 2008
This site trying to get onside with Newcastle fans now after all the flak you,ve received?? Guess what ? It doesn't wash
There are no fans more deluded than you newcastle fans. 1) United are the best in England regardless of what liverpool did in the 70's- we're champions and on course to do so again, liverpool are battling it out for 4th- again. 2) Newcastle have NEVER been bigger than United. In the 90's United were by far the dominant force. What title's did Newcastle win? thats right sfa. You call a man who has won nothing you're saviour which highlights what newcastle are; A big club in terms of fans (its an uncontested city) and a laughing stock to the big boys. Get back to the Alan Shearer dvd's and dream away
by Archie Brand on March 22, 2008
WHy does this article appear on the day that Keegan finally wins a game? I agree Keegan isnt the duffer that the papers make him out to be, but I think your timing on the article sucks. If you'd printed it a couple of days ago - OK, but once the Toon have won and are borderline safe? Wheres the journalism in that?
on March 23, 2008 on March 23, 2008
A home win against the mighty Fulham who have been in such dominant away form this season, talk about proving the critics wrong, how stupid of us all to doubt the tactical genius known as Keegan! another great article from the other genius known as Ed Bottomspeakingley, got your ipod yet mate?
by JD Geordie on April 11, 2008
Oh how original....a Man United fan thinking they are amazing. Only difference between Alex Ferguson and Kevin Keegan is that Keegan didnt get money when he needed it and also Keegan doesn't throw football shoes at his captain when Newcastle loses. Man United have been given everything they own in present day by the referees who are either payed off by Alex or scared of the thugs Man United call fans. If I see Ronaldo dive just one more time I think I might top myself because I have been to school nativity plays with better acting.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
US Open crunch: Roger Federer survives - now can Andy Murray finish off Rafael Nadal?
Toulouse, Stade Francais or maybe Dan Carter's Perpignan - who's hot for French rugby's Top 14?
Andorra a doddle, Croatia the BIG test - but are England up to it without Newcastle's Owen?
Arsenal Aston Villa Barcelona Chelsea Everton Football Liverpool Manchester City Manchester United Newcastle United Portsmouth Real Madrid Sunderland Tottenham Hotspur West Ham United
© SportBuzz All rights reserved 2008 Sportingo- Sports News & Sports Articles site. Sportingo delivers fresh sports news and analysis by fans-Football News, Tennis News, Rugby Union News, Rugby League, Cricket News, Cycling News, Basketball News and other Sports TV. XML Sitemap 2008.