Manchester United - the definitive 11-man TEAM

Mon, Mar 24, 08 07:38
Rank it:
RSS  Digg  del.icio.us
What`s Online:




Rio Ferdinand: Imperious at the centre of defence (Gettyimages.com)

Cristiano Ronaldo is said by many to be the driving force behind United's success - but aren't they really a team of all-stars?

'They can boast the best wide player in the world, and Cristiano Ronaldo’s goals have propelled United to another plane'

There is no way that anyone could possibly claim that Manchester United are a one-man team. They are a side flooded with stars, swamped with skilful players, and proliferated with genius.

I don’t think that it would be possible for a team such as United, who have been there or thereabouts in the Premier League for well over a decade, to have the levels of success that they have achieved without a good team.

One-man teams are to be found at the bottom of the League, teams that rely on one star to pull them out of the mire. Manchester United have a large dynasty of success, something that couldn’t be formed on the back of one good player.

They can boast the best wide player in the world, and Cristiano Ronaldo’s goals have propelled United to another plane. But when you focus the spotlight on each individual area of the Old Trafford side you realise that they are littered with glittering players; players who might well have started out as a so-called one-man band.

Look at Rio Ferdinand, a glorious defender who, when he keeps his concentration, is easily one of the best defenders in the world with his imperious style and impressive technique. Carlos Tevez, at the other end of the pitch is a South American phenomenon – commonly regarded as the future of the Argentine team – and from last year’s display at West Ham, he was the jewel in their crown.

Wayne Rooney is still a bullish man-boy with a wealth of skills at his disposal, who could forget his hat-trick debut for Man Utd against Fenerbache in the Champions League – even now there is much moaning and wailing when Rooney is absent from the United team.

Paul Scholes and Ryan Giggs, the two supreme elder statesmen of the United team, are also glorious players with Scholes’ touch and legendary knack for getting in the box just at the right time, and Giggs' supreme dribbling skills, superior – in my opinion – to even the worshipped Ronaldo.

My point is that United could never be described as simply a one man team. That is the jealous knee-jerk response to Ronaldo’s brilliance – an attempt to belittle a wonderful and fluid team.

Just look at their interchangeable striking trio and you see that they aren’t reliant on one player alone. Manchester United are a team of stars, not a one trick pony.

 

Do you think United are a one-man team? Post your comments below.
Rank it:
RSS  Digg  del.icio.us
Comments
Rams Abbey (24/03/2008 10:41)
There's no way a good soccer annalyst would describe united as one-man team with their fantastic style of play..United to my opinion are currently the best club with all stars of good players in the world..Micheal Carick a fantastic player, vidic, Anderson now the heart of united's midfield, Tevez, Amlmeida Nani, not metion the heros...Giggs, Scholes, Vander sar, CHRISTIANO RONALDO the best player in the world even without the crown i see him to be the best..
AndrewUnited (24/03/2008 13:07)
since someone has come out and said that. Whilst i totally and utterly agree that united are, by no means, a one-man team i feel that journalists wants to pile us down, because we have the best player, and the best team in the world. Who can deny that? It's roaring flair, pace and goals from every player on the pitch! Just look at browns goal yesterday, and rio and vida chip in occassionally. We just miss that from Anderson. When he starts scoring, he'll be reckoned as the best midfielder in the world. He's amazing! And Rooney, for me he's still the best all-round player for United. He's the best, i just hope he'll get his goals coming, coz he is truly one of the best in the world.
darrell johnson (24/03/2008 13:14)
rio
can i ask when in the last 2 seasons has rio lost concentration? who is a better cback than rio? come on now? who? last ditch carragher? body on the line terry? if there is honestly any1 who can name me a better c back than rio then you dont no football.
AndrewUnited (24/03/2008 15:25)
Hmm, i too, think Rio is one of the best c halfs in the world, but only when it comes to composure, concentration and flair. vida is a better defender by a mile, but cannot do the same things up field. And to answer your question about his concentration. I remember a certain trip to pompey where he scored the winning goal - own goal that is. And to there advantage!
AndrewUnited (24/03/2008 15:28)
Their
fozzy flagship (24/03/2008 19:25)
i know a better cback than rio who plays in the prem but he's not english......richard dunne. why? simple, they took 6 points off us this season, and he plays for an unfashionable club. any man who wouldn't rio for dunney is a twit. thanks.
peter pocket (24/03/2008 21:09)
i remember rio holding us to ransom over his wages so for that reason alone i'm saying he's shat. ronaldo is without doubt a good player but he's an even better cheat and he never really gets credit for it....know what i mean...wink wink nudge nudge, eh where's he gone? oh he's fell over again thinking someone was going to tackle him, NO not like the one at boro. there is a secret doing the rounds in my local pub about wayne rooney and its nowt to do with that fat talentless bird of his, the old slapper! aparently he's actually a scouser who are despised by us true mancunions, not just that though he once scored a goal for another football team and pulled up his jersy to reveal a t-shirt saying "once a blue always a blue". well bugger me i thought, i can believe the bit about him being a scouser but never a lying scouser!
lil greenman (24/03/2008 21:16)
hello i am an alien from outa space. can somone tell me where i can get a right nice prawn butty?
han solo (24/03/2008 21:28)
hi lil, you can get a really nice prawn sandwhich at old trafford. us manchester lads love em, if not a prawn sarnie then try a pukka pie they're lovely too. once you have your food pal take your place in the stand, nobody will notice your an alien but just remember to keep quiet while we all watch ronaldos gymnastic routines. hope this helps and good luck on your trip back to space or alien planet where aliens come from.
j t kirk (24/03/2008 22:15)
i can't believe some people only come on this site to take the pizz. for god sake we are man utd so you are not allowed to have a laugh and joke at our expence. fozzy flagship, peter pocket and han solo you do not belong here in this part of the forum especially han solo, telling that alien to have a pukka pie is totally wrong and naughty, everybody knows aliens don't like pukka pies. so i'll apologise on behalf of the fans of man utd to lil greenman. we're sorry for nearly letting you think that you like pukka pies when you know only full well that you do not. so please remember not to eat a pukka pie because you will have forgotten that you do not like pukka pies. hope that helps you lil and have a pleasant journey back to your mystic but beautiful alien planet were aliens come from xx
lil greenman (24/03/2008 22:32)
thanks jt kirk. you have saved my life because i had forgotten that i don't like pukka pies but now thanks to you i know that i've never liked them all along. although pukka pies are opening a shop back home on my planet where aliens come from, it will be right next door to a greggs the bakery shop who do a fantastic steak bake that nobody likes, so it'll be nice for greggs to have some competition. the next time the bandwagon picks me up for a match i will leave a post to let you know who has not sold the most. kind regards lil.
lil greenman (24/03/2008 23:49)
hi everybody its me, lil greenman, i've come back from space to let you know that greggs have sold no fantastic steak bakes as yet and pukka pies are right behind them having sold slightly less pies. i'm hoping that somebody will come up with the idea of opening a prawn sandwhich shop because that's what us space people from outa space can only eat. ok thats enough from me now i'm going back home to you know where, i'll try to make it back for tomoz when i will give you another up-date on pukka pies vs greggs fantastic steak bakes that nobody likes. thankyou, lil x.
The A (25/03/2008 08:51)
can i ask when in the last 2 seasons has rio lost concentration? who is a better cback than rio? come on now? who? last ditch carragher? body on the line terry? if there is honestly any1 who can name me a better c back than rio then you dont no football.
vidic
mike Alley (25/03/2008 09:52)
manchester is the best team of all time fool of devoted players
Jimmy Mcroy (25/03/2008 19:25)
Didnt he play for the dodgers last season?
billy knutlicker (25/03/2008 21:33)
i've been a man utd fan for about 15 years. they're great. we always get a full house not like the time we managed about 19800 at home against wimbledon.
Billy Styles (26/03/2008 09:05)
Gk: Foster Rb:Simpson Cb:Vidic Cb:Ferdinand Lb: Evra Rm:Ronaldo Cm:Hargreaves Cm:Anderson Lm:Nani St:Rooney St:Tevez.. Subs: Kuszczak, Pique, Scholes, Carrick, F.Campbell.
Joe Public (26/03/2008 18:41)
Problem with a lot of footballing commentators is that they see the game as played by individuals and not as a team game. Cristiano Ronaldo may be a gifted individual but he is not a 1-man team. Sir Alex Ferguson has built a few Manyoo teams over the years and he certainly does not subscribed to the Galacticos system pioneered by Real Madrid. He was glad to jettison David Beckham to them to sell more Real Madrid No: 23 shirts! He used part of Beckham's transfer fee to buy Ronaldo from Sporting in 2003. Even SAF got it wrong when he bought Juan Sebastien Veron for the Champions League challenge - he sucked! Although Ruud Van Nisterooy was a success on paper but he made Manyoo very 1-dimensional ie. dependent on him for goals. As with Beckham, he was smart to palm him off to Real. Basically, Manyoo's midfield engine sputtered between 2002 - 2006 when Becks thought he was bigger than Manyoo, Juan Veron couldn't hack it in the premiership & Roy Keano slowed down tremendously with his injuries. On top of that, SAF bought in a lot of crap during that period - Kleberson, Eric Djemba-Djemba, David Bellion, Alan Smith, Liam Miller except for Ronaldo & Rooney. Things improved after SAF cleared that lot & then bought in Michael Carrick with Paul Scholes recovering from his eye problems, Manyoo started to turn things around. SAF started his excellent buying streak starting with Edwin Van Der Sar in 2005, then with Evra & Vidic in 2006, Carrick in 2007 & Anderson, Nani & Owen Hargreaves in 2008. SAF is getting the team right & hopefully, will dominate for a few years before having to strip & rebuilt.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED







*
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team




Adobe Flash Plug-in Needed

This website requires a Adobe Flash plug-in. Please download the latest version of the Flash plug-in by clicking here

Daily Poll

Who will win the Champions League?