Home > Football > Manchester United, Chelsea, Arsenal, Liverpool and the lost art of tackling
Manchester United, Chelsea, Arsenal, Liverpool and the lost art of tackling
The Top Four seem to get away with tackles that are penalised in the rest of the Premier League. Is it clever tactics or biased refereeing?
by Kenny Harper on 25 March 2008
Email this Article (5) Comments
It’s hard to find the “dirtiest” footballer in the Premier League today. In my honest opinion, under the rules that regulate the game, you can’t really describe players as dirty; they’re more just plain bad tacklers. The art of tackling is being taken out the game and the game is slowly but surely becoming a non-contact sport for a few reasons.Firstly the governing body of the game in Europe don’t know how to manage the game properly and as a result have brought in bad rule after bad rule. We are now in a situation were someone might commit to a tackle in the Premier League on a Saturday and not even get a talking to, but on Tuesday, Wednesday or Thursday in Europe he could well be sent off for the same tackle. And there does seem to be one rule for the majority of the Premier League and a completely different rule for the so-called Top Four. And herein lies a problem.Players with Manchester United, Chelsea, Arsenal and Liverpool do seem to be given more leeway by referees when it comes to foul play. Referees appear less prone to pulling out a yellow card for fear that they will be on the Sky Sports news every 15 minutes for daring to book, send off or give a penalty against one of the clubs who are “trying to do well in Europe” for us.This has produced a generation of footballers who now don’t really know how to tackle; the pace of the game is such that sometimes tackles can be mistimed but the fact remains that a good tackle is now a forgotten art. The last player I can recall who could actually do it was David Batty, who finished playing some five or six years ago.Nowadays the game has become more like a game of basketball. Players make a challenge on each other in an attempt to shoulder them off the ball, but this is now more like a defensive block in a half-court press in basketball. If you watch a team like Liverpool who use the zonal system of marking, it really is a case of four or five men standing on the edge of the six-yard box and blocking anyone who tries to time a run into the box to meet a corner or a free-kick.On top of that they employ two defensive midfielders whose sole task it is to sit in front of the back four and tackle, attack or block any player with or without the ball going anywhere near their back four.The worst exponents of this are Lucas Leiva and Javier Mascherano who have plenty of ability but none of it involves tackling as we know it, but more like what they would want us to know it as - a basketball block, or trip.
Comments (5)
by Herman on March 25, 2008
Mascherano statistically speaking is the best tackler in the league. The stats speak for tghemselves.... go to the Premier League site! Do some research before writing drivel please?
by dan on March 25, 2008
you write the most annoying articles ever - we have some of the best tacklers in the world in our team - you havnt a clue what you are on about.
by Kenny Harper on March 25, 2008
Read my article again... Right do the stats say he is the best tackler... well no actually they dont they say he tackles the most the number of succsesful tackles puts him about 4th, and as I say at the end its not ackling as we know it its tackling how they will want us to know it, and that includes him getting alladairre(sp) sent off at anfield.... Dan feel free to name who you think are the best tacklers in the world that we apparently have in our League, I would be very interested to know who they are.
by Mark Ash on March 26, 2008
With regard to your reference to David Batty it is often overlooked that he was also an excellent passer of the ball and rarely gave it away. In the early days of the O'Leary era he and Stephen McPhail formed a very classy midfield duo as did Batty with Oliver Dacourt later. His name escapes me but the current bearded Italian "stopper" gets rave reports for basically not being able to play!
by Kenny Harper on March 27, 2008
Batty was agreat player, lacked a bit of pace but had plenty of passion and skill and could tackle all day, I only wish England had someone of his type now, actually saying that they would probably be sent off every week if they did.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Last Name
Sport
Email
League
Heading
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Cardiff City must stick to the rules in all this Hasselbaink hassle
Arsenal fans can relax - with Wenger in charge the future is red and white!
Fedrinator v Nadambo: The keys to Roger Federer retaining his Wimbledon title - or a Rafael Nadal takeover
Arsenal Aston Villa Barcelona Chelsea Everton Football Liverpool Manchester City Manchester United Newcastle United Portsmouth Real Madrid Sunderland Tottenham Hotspur West Ham United
© SportBuzz All rights reserved 2008 Sportingo- Sports News & Sports Articles site. Sportingo delivers fresh sports news and analysis by fans-Football News, Tennis News, Rugby Union News, Rugby League, Cricket News, Cycling News, Basketball News and other Online Sports. XML Sitemap 2008.