Why Manchester United will never see the real Wayne Rooney

Tue, Mar 25, 08 15:33
Rank it:
RSS  Digg  del.icio.us
What`s Online:



Wayne Rooney: Will United ever see the best of him? (Gettgyimages.com)

He's not the same player who won the hearts of every Everton fan. Sir Alex Ferguson has changed him - and not necessarily for the better.

'Sir Alex got it very right when trying to coach out Cristiano Ronaldo’s showboating flair, but he got it wrong with Wayne'

This week it was announced that the libel writ issued by Everton boss David Moyes, against Harper Collins (publishers of Wayne Rooney's autobiography My Story So Far), Wayne Rooney himself, and his ghost writer, Hunter Davies, has resulted in victory for the Toffees gaffer.

Moyes will receive up to £150,000 himself with Harper Collins footing the bill, which could be in excess of half a million pounds.

The controversial passage involves the suggestion that after Wayne Rooney told Moyes he wanted to move to Manchester United after the Roon-prostitute story broke, Moyes then hot-footed it to the Liverpool Echo and told them everything.

This has since been proven to be total fabricated tripe and I am glad that Moyes won his showdown with his former student Wayne. But it saddens me that this could be Wayne Rooney’s final off-field dealings with his boyhood club.

Although this was a deserved victory for the Moyesiah, it is tinged with regret and disappointment; regret that my former idol and the manager of my team had to lock horns through litigation, and disappointment that Wayne Rooney’s employers are now Manchester United and not Everton.

No matter how much dirt emerges about Wayne Rooney, no matter how much the Scouse genius runs roughshod over his “once a Blue, always a Blue” oath of fealty with obnoxious and hypocritical badge kissing, I will always regard him as a footballing God.

To get over Rooney’s departure to Old Trafford, I treated the new version of him as almost a different player – and it wasn’t too hard.  Sir Alex Ferguson has straitjacketed some of his wilder tendencies, turning his feral flair and atavistic aggression into the player he wanted him to be.

Watching Wayne now you see an awe-inspiring and excellent player. But I think that he could have become even better. The early Rooney - bursting past defenders, ruthlessly direct and blinkered, known to taunt defenders by putting his hands on his hips in mock boredom, who like a belligerent matchmaker never ceased introducing the ball to the back of the net – won’t be seen at Old Trafford.

Say what you want about your Wayne, but OUR Wayne had it all and in many ways was uncoachable. The glorious trajectory predicted by many hasn’t quite panned out, and although Rooney is the jewel in England’s crown he is overshadowed by others such as Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo, and Kaka.

Sir Alex got it very right when trying to coach out Cristiano Ronaldo’s showboating flair, but he got it wrong with Wayne, as his direct early self was more akin to the Brazilian Ronaldo at Barcelona – selfish, but only as any good single-minded striker has to be.

Manchester United’s millions bought a star, but by separating him from his boyhood club they never got the legend.

So has the best been coached out of Wayne Rooney? Post your comments below or submit an article to Sportingo.
Rank it:
RSS  Digg  del.icio.us
Comments
Giorgi kavsadze (25/03/2008 18:11)
your are so damn right. No more raw power. No more aggression. No more.... ranged shots!! everyone is expecting him to shoot and tear the net to hell and he is passing. thats can be taken to notice and NO ONE WILL FEAR HIS ANIMAL SHOT anymore. and its all alexs blame. now to look at the bright side. wazza is becoming the key player not only for United. for England too. The silent maestro. the kind of scholes. thinking... moving and knowing when what to do. assists... mutirity... dedication... to me... its the best a player can have in modern football BUT its a shame to have LION CAGED
Christovski (25/03/2008 18:15)
I doubt it. More than anything, it's been the injuries that have kept Rooney from reaching his utmost potential so far, not the coaching at United. 9 goals in 9 games earlier this season testifies to that. Against Liverpool at the weekend he was the best player on the pitch but for his finishing letting him down. A good title run-in and an injury free summer should see him back to his very best, but you have to remember that he is still only 22 and has years left in him. Ultimately, if anything, the coaching at United has probably prolonged his genius, as surely he probably would have self-destructed if left to his own devices.
Giorgi Kavsadze (25/03/2008 18:22)
I agree with the injuries. thats a huge impact on his form. but its unaccaptible to watch him breathing like a galloping horse every week.
Darren Neal (25/03/2008 19:10)
ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha,ha. Two injuries this season has interupted his game, but what a player he is now. The amount of assist, his goals and performances in europe, and yet ANOTHER man of the match display at the w/e. We have taken away the petulance that he had in his early days. He will be world footballer of the year in the next 2 years (barring inuries). United can play without Ronaldo, but we cant play without Rooney.....
Dave C (25/03/2008 19:16)
What aload of Bollocks mate
The knower of all things (25/03/2008 21:25)
We are all glad that Moyes won thats for sure,the ghost writer was an amatuer and incapale of proper writing.Howevr to say that Roney is not a better player than back in his Toffee days is just lowering your judgement to that of Rooneys ghost writer.....shite!
Alex I (25/03/2008 22:28)
I agree with Christovski, Darren Neal and ESPECIALLY Dave C. Rooney hasn't lost his flair, he's turned it into his deadliest weapon. 90% of the time, he doesn't even need to turn it on - Rooney is THAT good. But like you saw last season against Milan at OT (in a game billed as the battle between C. Ronaldo and Kaka), Rooney stole the show and won the game for United. You will live to regret this article.
Simmo M (25/03/2008 22:37)
Are you sure your not just still bitter because he left Everton? The OUR Wayne comment made me laugh!! Rooney's a much better player than when he was at Everton. If you watched Rooney in every game you would see that. If he stayed at Everton his game would have stagnated. Carrying a whole team on his own at 18yrs of age would have destroyed his talent. In future please put aside your bitterness before you subject innocent readers to such nonsense. P S. OUR Wayne, OUR Wayne!! lol.
we agree with simmo M but for us Rooney is still better than Ronaldo .
Adwait Apte (26/03/2008 06:33)
I completely agree wid what Simmo M has written there. The OUR Wayne comment is something that completely tells the reader what Everton are sorely missing. Wayne rooney is no longer the player he was at Everton. He is much better now. His game is now multi-dimensional & he is able to lift the entire team just by playing! I think Sir Alex has made him a great player..He just needs an injury-free season & then we'll show you scousers that OUR Wayne is so much better than YOURS.!!! " ONCE A BLUE, ALWAYS A RED!!!!!!!"
Steve Smith (26/03/2008 09:22)
Have to agree with the author, Rooney doesnt excite like he did at Everton. Just another player at United,
(26/03/2008 09:59)
Rooney has become a great player at United than he was at Everton.
MINDLOS GUMEDE (26/03/2008 10:09)
i wonderwhat u really want from wazza?the boy i s only 22 and already withall the signs of a class act.when he scores those brilliant goals orsets up his team-mates u critics dont say that much.my advice to u stop dragging the boy down
Danny Salford Red (26/03/2008 11:02)
That is simply priceless my friend and has amused me so much i don't even mind being back at work. The whole article is written through rose tinted spectacles if you believe the tosh you have written to be true. What absolute sentimental crap. It's like saying Ian Wright was a better player in non league and at Crystal Palace before he came tro Arsenal. Simply not true.He is a far superior player technically now. If he had carried on the way he was going with his feral flair he would be sent off once every 2 matches so how is that better? Don't get me wrong I fully understand the need of passion and spirit and yes some players wouldn't be the same with it Cantona etc etc etc but Wayne is so much better now it's untrue and to say he has lost his feral flair sticks in the throat a bit when all the media etc etc etc do their best to make him out to be a agressive maniac who can't control himself whenever he plays for England.
Danny Salford Red (26/03/2008 11:02)
That is simply priceless my friend and has amused me so much i don't even mind being back at work. The whole article is written through rose tinted spectacles if you believe the tosh you have written to be true. What absolute sentimental crap. It's like saying Ian Wright was a better player in non league and at Crystal Palace before he came tro Arsenal. Simply not true.He is a far superior player technically now. If he had carried on the way he was going with his feral flair he would be sent off once every 2 matches so how is that better? Don't get me wrong I fully understand the need of passion and spirit and yes some players wouldn't be the same with it Cantona etc etc etc but Wayne is so much better now it's untrue and to say he has lost his feral flair sticks in the throat a bit when all the media etc etc etc do their best to make him out to be a agressive maniac who can't control himself whenever he plays for England.
Danny Salford Red (26/03/2008 11:02)
That is simply priceless my friend and has amused me so much i don't even mind being back at work. The whole article is written through rose tinted spectacles if you believe the tosh you have written to be true. What absolute sentimental crap. It's like saying Ian Wright was a better player in non league and at Crystal Palace before he came tro Arsenal. Simply not true.He is a far superior player technically now. If he had carried on the way he was going with his feral flair he would be sent off once every 2 matches so how is that better? Don't get me wrong I fully understand the need of passion and spirit and yes some players wouldn't be the same with it Cantona etc etc etc but Wayne is so much better now it's untrue and to say he has lost his feral flair sticks in the throat a bit when all the media etc etc etc do their best to make him out to be a agressive maniac who can't control himself whenever he plays for England.
franco mizzi (26/03/2008 11:15)
Dear Ed and that is why Rooney wanted to leave Everton for Manchester United. I dont know from which planet you are watching Rooney but believe me the one we watch week in week out is a much better and complete player then he ever was or would have been had he stayed at Everton.
tgm maria (26/03/2008 11:22)
tgm
That someone who wrote this comments, for me he knew nothing about football and was just born yesterday. Rooney is a very complete player, he can strike, create and defent as well, maybe be a goally too. Jealousy can make you do or say anything you dream of. For you to judge another anyone, you have to be in his shoes, then you will experiance the real things before criticising.
Jim Doherty (26/03/2008 12:58)
Wayne Rooney would never have become a CHAMPION at Everton, he is now a pivotal Manchester United player, playing in the big competitions against the biggest teams in the world. I know where Id rather be! also Rooney still has the aggression - you wanna see him from pitch side, he is soooo passionate and so intent on winning its great to watch!
(26/03/2008 13:50)
Ed Bottemley, quite an apt name.
spence hall (26/03/2008 14:28)
This has been an area of concern for many United fans the last couple of seasons - has Rooney really developed as well as he should? IMHO I dont think he has, his team game is great and I wouldn't knock him for that but he really has to start scoring a few more goals and knock off the petulance because its going to land him in a heap of trouble with the way that the game is going.
Shahidull Islam (26/03/2008 15:18)
Everyone goes through a rurf time in this case he was was always going to get citisizes, because of his lack of goals like any other striker would.As soon as he starts scoring this matter will fade away.
(26/03/2008 16:51)
Do u always talk sh*t?
(26/03/2008 16:53)
Didnt he jst get Man Of The Match against Liverpool by the way?
Chris W (27/03/2008 02:39)
Of course Rooney had to leave Everton if he was ever going to win anything and have the chance of playing with great players every week. But let's compare his performances for England at Euro 2004, when people compared him to Pele, with his performances for United. I love Rooney, he's a wonderful player for us but is he really fulfilling his potential? I don't think so. I really think he has far more natural skill than Ronaldo but he's never got close to challenging for a world or European footballer of the year award. He should have been a truly great player, up there with Best and Maradona, but it seems he'll only be a very good one, on a par with Scholes or Giggs. That's hardly a criticism, but its a shame. Ferguson seems to have coached the genius out of him.
watife solomon (27/03/2008 11:14)
Yes thyere is still a lot more from the united's point man. It seems he is not getting the goals but tstill he has established himself aqs an integral part of the first team. No Rooney NO WIN that is what we have come to realise. I'm not bothered he is not scoring he gives his best and that is it
helge blystad (27/03/2008 11:18)
rooney goal ratio at everton: every 4,5 game rooneys goal ratio at united: every 2,4 game!
David R (08/04/2008 19:54)
Rooney should have stayed at everton a couple more years he could have moved any time or any age, he should have stayed as everton nurtured him for years he was the talk of the town in Liverpool for around 4 years, then he makes it and united snap him up, He could have spent 2 years at everton to say thank you to the fans and maybe just maybe win them a trophy, Hey maradona done it at napoli and there players were crap. Rooney was an animal at everton something really special now he is just another Corporate player playing in front of fans that would never appreciate him the way fans on merseyside do! such a shame
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED







*
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team




Adobe Flash Plug-in Needed

This website requires a Adobe Flash plug-in. Please download the latest version of the Flash plug-in by clicking here

Daily Poll

Who will win the Champions League?