Sin bins and heavy fines? Perhaps Chelsea's Cole and Liverpool's Mascherano might learn respect

Thu, Mar 27, 08 13:45
Rank it:
RSS  Digg  del.icio.us
What`s Online:



Javier Mascherano mouthing off at referee Steve bennett (Gettyimages.com)

If you act like a child then you should be treated like a child. It's certainly time the FA took a stand against petulant behaviour.

'Portsmouth and England goalkeeper David James has voiced his opinion on the need for professional footballers to set an example to youngsters. Good!'

Referees have a job that is, to say the least, unenviable. They have got to have extremely thick skins, eyes in the back of their heads and an unfaltering love/passion for the game.

Now it’s been brought to media attention and scrutinised recently thanks to the misdemeanours of Ashley Cole and Javier Mascherano. But this is the world today. This is the media today. It will be highlighted for a week or so and every pundit in the land will offer their opinion. Opinion is what its all about after all isn’t it? Or is it interpretation? They kind of fall into the same category.

Interpretation in turn builds the basis of opinion. What makes it even more frustrating for the referees is that whatever their interpretation of an isolated event is, there are the studio panels and newspaper columnists having theirs. A split second is the time the ref has to make a decision while the rest of us can watch replays and make our minds up 24 hours later, having digested everything comfortably.

Respect for referees is currently the major talking point. Portsmouth and England goalkeeper David James has voiced his opinion on the need for professional footballers to set an example to youngsters. Good!

As with everything in life, something has to happen first for us to take any action. Cole and Mascherano will be wishing they had the gift of hindsight. Both have made utter fools of themselves and I’m sure it has been mirrored in the playground and public parks. Cole made a mockery of the referee.

It was childish and arrogant and completely undermined the man who controls the ebb and flow of the game. Mascherano simply showed us what a stupid loose cannon he can be, and both deserve hefty punishments. The strange thing is that none of these events are new. These incidents have been going on for years. The FA have been musing and muttering over protracted changes like forever.

The fact that footballers are now like pop stars means that it hits the front as well as the back pages, and unfortunately some of these players are acting like they are pop stars, movie stars, whatever. It’s a changed world in football.

It has also changed the job of referees. No longer can they simply concentrate on getting their footballing decisions right but they have to deal with a bunch of arrogant, rich and big-headed prima donnas. Yes, there were always a few, but now it’s almost half of the 22 players on the pitch. It must be like pre-school for the refs.

Many people can be blamed. There are managers who wind their players up so much before a match that they are running on to that pitch looking like crazed maniacs. A sin bin could work but may make the game even more of a stop-start affair. However, if handled properly by the referee and his assistants I really believe it could add an extra edge and dimension to the game.

If teams are punished when a foolish player is binned for 10 minutes then the reaction to losing points and games (and bonuses) I’m quite sure, would dramatically morph certain players into little angels. Of course different players react in different ways. Some lose the plot and go for the ref; others go for opposing players.

Now the latter group are punished for cynical fouls on the opposition yet the cunning players, slyly pestering and badgering the ref throughout the game, usually go unpunished. This is undermining the ref and a slick way of influencing him into decisions.

Dissent is what we’re really talking about here and it is never punished properly. Ten thousand and thirty thousand quid fines mean absolutely nothing to the average Premier League player. Fines should be dealt with in relation to the wages that they earn.

As always, money talks and if you hit them where it hurts I’m sure this stupid back-chatting would disappear fairly quickly. A certain number of sin bins and the appropriate fine is issued.

Not only would these players start to find their bank balance dropping but their availability for first team games diminishing, points being dropped, fans on their backs and managers eventually shipping them out of the club. Is this what it will take?

How would you deal with dissent and lack of respect
Rank it:
RSS  Digg  del.icio.us
Comments
Shiggsy (27/03/2008 16:21)
As long as punishment is consistent with referees getting fined for failure to act, I have no problem with this, although I'm worried that football is no longer a contact sport. I also would have appreciated it if Andy Gray hadn't have been ready to hang, draw and quarter Masch for a bit of petulance, Gray was an absolute bastard in his playing time and has no room to lecture others. This is the first time I've particularly noticed Masch being petulant, he was asking to be sent off really, I can understand him questioning Torres' booking, but when he had been hounding the ref all game, it was bound to happen. I was bitter about it at the time, having watched Chelsea's entire squad baracking different referees for the past three seasons with no punishment, so as Bennett has now made the stand, I hope one rule fits all and we can expect more of this in the future. Sin-bins are not the way to go, returning discipline across the board through fear of the ref is.
Bob Evans (27/03/2008 17:58)
mouthing off at refs is not a new thing we can all remember Roy Keane and his army charging at the ref when a decision didn't go their way, so it makes me laugh to read about all the lack of respect in todays game. The problem has always been there, it has escalated because now you have players (teenagers and early twenty somethings) earning more money in a week than the average person would in a year thinking they can do and say anything, I don't want to single any one out but there is a young striker playing for one of the so called big clubs that consistantly gives the referees a volley of F words, is this not disscent because I am confused as he has never been carded for it. In my opinion the ref should book any player who interferes when he has made a decission the only players aloowed to speak to him should be the player in question and the club captain. Referees must be consistant though and not pick and choose which teams/players can get away with it. The one other thing I would say is that it is about time that referees were made to explain their decissions in an interview after the game as refs think the don't have to answer to anyone, this then breeds the contempt. Poor refs who make big mistakes should be delt with better as having the week off is not an adequate response.
JJ - (27/03/2008 18:28)
As long as the punishment is dished out to all (yes im looking at you ferguson + utd players and chelseas mob) then it can only be good for the game.
paul (27/03/2008 20:10)
As ever, the problem is the ref's being totally inconsistent. Not only within their profession, but in the same game. Look at why Masch lost he cool. The ref was totally blind to the home side's antics. Sin-bins have been proposed before, but the duffers in charge of the game are scared of change. I think it's worth trying, even if it's only at the lower levels to start with. We should also speak to rugby officials. They control games extremely well and don't have to put up with the crap like footballer refs, even when the goof. Anyone who has played at a low level will have experienced refs booking or sending players off immediately when they hear bad language. Somewhere up the chain, they choose to ignore it, unless it gives their favourite team an advantage when the penalise the opposition.
(28/03/2008 16:43)
I like the "acting as a child" thing. Clearly writen by someone who doesn't play football and doesn't understand the passion and mindset you need to install to be a good footballer. Armchair footballers shouldn't be allowed opinions.
(28/03/2008 16:44)
P.S - And not should those who only have an opinion to win Sat Nav's!!!
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED







*
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team




Adobe Flash Plug-in Needed

This website requires a Adobe Flash plug-in. Please download the latest version of the Flash plug-in by clicking here

Daily Poll

Who will win the Champions League?