Home > Football > Will Sepp Blatter get his way and will the likes of Arsenal be left counting the cost?
Will Sepp Blatter get his way and will the likes of Arsenal be left counting the cost?
The money men and top European clubs will not allow the restriction of foreign players into Europe's top leagues as envisaged by the FIFA president. There's too much money at stake.
by gerald mclaughlin on 29 March 2008
Email this Article (7) Comments
Free £25 bet when you register at
By 2010 Sepp Blatter would like no more than five non-nationals playing for their respective clubs on the field of play at any one time.
It's an idea that has been thought about ever since it was obvious the influx of foreign players in different EU member states was hampering the youth structures and progress of homegrown talent.
Blatter said:"This is a matter of principle and we need to protect the national identity of the football clubs."
There is a current rule on players from outside EU countries which is limited to three - and it makes perfect sense. In 1995, however, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled that all sports professionals should have more freedom to change clubs within the EU - the famous Bosman ruling.
As with many instances, it is now too late to try to bring this rule to fruition. Blatter would like footballers to be given an exemption regarding workers within the EU. He said: "You cannot consider a footballer like any normal worker because you need 11 to play a match... and they are more artists than workers."
A can of worms could be opened by this statement. What about a brigade of construction workers on a building site? Could they not be construed as a team? A brigade of chefs in a large restaurant? Are they not artists? It's a rather flimsy argument from Blatter.
The Premier League is awash with foreigners, whether you think it is good or bad. And whether it is good for English football or not, it is now way too late to attempt to implement new rules.
Indeed, if such rules were employed even in two years' time the effect on the Premier League would be catastrophic. Eventually, yes, it would be for the good of all EU member countries.
The whole episode for British teams is highlighted by Arsenal FC boss Arsene Wenger, who said: "I am against it. Sport is competitive and competition is based on merit. It does not matter where you were born. It matters who you are."
That is a very true statement from a great manager but one can't help thinking it was said on the back of the fact that his own side would be the team most disrupted by this rule coming into effect.
The members of the elite European clubs have voiced strong resistance to the proposal. Michel Platini said: "The philosophy is fantastic but legally it is difficult." Major money and the importance of keeping the fans entertained is more important to the big clubs.
They will not hesitate to buy superstars, foreign or not, to keep the big bucks rolling in. Whatever the eventual outcome may be, one thing will remain - and that is the game of football.
It may be a long time before it happens because, as much as FIFA and UEFA think that they are running the game, they are not.
The top European clubs, money and the media are running world football and whatever they want, they get.
Comments (7)
by Rico . on March 29, 2008
Before anyone jumps on the - 'only because I am an Arsenal fan' theory, believe me it is not... My view is about Human Rights - and have said many times before in similar bloggs, that trying to implement a maxium number of foreign players in any football team, for me would breech this rule. England has opened its gates over many years gone by, and welcomed many different nationals to live and work here. And as time has gone by we have many many different choices to make - for example - how many of us when going out for dinner choose - Indian, Thai, Chinese, Italian, Greek, French, Spanish etc etc, rather than an English Pub/Restaurant? I dont know the stats for the answer but I for one prefer to eat any of the above, rather than English food when out. (Off at a slight tangent, but not only the food, but the service is normally much better!) So, for example, I go to an Indian Restaurant, ten members of staff are working on this particular night, and funny enough, they are all Indian males. Are we now going to suggest, that in this particular restaurant there can only be 5 Indian males, the rest must be British???? OK - maybe an extreme example, but what is the difference? In principle, whether a footballer, chef, waiter or whatever, these are human beings who have sought employment in a different country for whatever reason. To start implementing some kind of change, will open up a massive 'can of worms' and maybe even court cases. In relation to England's football team - if the English players are good enough they will be scouted and play - but I think it is about time we all realised that someone (Sir Trevor) has got to get boys away from computers and back into the parks for a kick about, maybe then our youth set up will become stronger and produce a few more Beckhams, Butts, Scholes, Adams, Gerrerds etc. Stop looking for excuses, and let football be
by Petter on March 29, 2008
Oh crap! I did it again! I clicked on the Sportingo link! The site that pushes out the most bollocks of them all! Even Man Reds site is more informative. In case you haven't read it yet The EU commission have already used their veto against this. blah blah blah! Sporting should be put out of business or at least been thrown away from newsnow! Bollocks and shit site!
by moy kokwah on March 30, 2008
There is no need to put up more barriers in sports. The barriers must come down. The world will benefit from a freer flow of talent.
by johhny foreigner on March 30, 2008
There are too many english players in the premier league so cant we put a restriction on them? no one cares about englands national team anymore. the clubs are foreign owned with foreign managers and foreign players and in london a large proportion of foreign fans. In fact englands national team should be made up of foreigners. Arsenal fans. Proud to be English.
by Jonny Dickins on March 31, 2008
Every club would be hit hard by this ridiculous proposition. Blatter doesn't give a toss about 'national identity', he just doesn't want to see Premier League domination. In ten years every other league will be nothing compared to the PL and the Champions League will be a foregone conclusion. If this stupid rule ever gets put into effect this will halt the monopoly and lower the PL to the standard of the Eredivisie or lower.
by Paul Cranswick on March 31, 2008
Blatter is right and ...wrong as well. The law does not allow discrimination or restriction of employment on national lines within the EC. Football in England does desperately needs to address both the absence of young talent coming through as well as the growing disparity between the top four and the rest. This can be addressed by introducing rules on the adoption of academies. There is no restriction on EU nationals joining the academies of the various clubs but in practice it is more likely the home grown talent will benefit from legislation making compulsory quotas in squads from academies. The rules I would propose would be as follows: Each club names a squad at the beginning of the season of 25 players. From the 25 players for the first 2 years 40% of the same (10) must have been developed by the academy of that club. After that it should be 60% (15 players). Within a particular season 5 signings in or out can be made but retaining the minimum percentage of academy product. Under the present system Man Utd would not be greatly inconvenienced whilst Liverpool have only 2 academy products in their squad and Chelsea only John Terry. Players such as Fabregas would qualify as they made their professional debuts for the club; i.e. Arsenal. Teams would still be able to attract the top quality players but the middling squad players would make way for the clubs youth product. This is surely the way forward and would be EU compliant.
by Terence McGovern on April 30, 2008
The sooner that Blatter is ousted from his dictatorial position within FIFA the better for all concerned. He is the most regressive force within the game. Restrictive changes for foreign players to control the levels of skill imported to different leagues. This will provide more stability for champions league and Big club sponsors. No video replay on big decisions. This would make match fixing almost impossible. English players are overpriced as a result of media hype and they tend to believe their own press when they play internationally up until the point that they get knocked out. The English manager that eventually wins a trophy will be the one that shuts out the press and picks as he pleases. Bans the WAGS and sends home any complainers. It would also probably help to inform his overpaid players that petulant red cards will result in end of international careers. Cost your country a tournnament and you dont play again ... EVER. The battle between xbox and football boots is the pivotal one in determining if Britian really does have talent.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Ipswich Volz into town as Watford seek to close the gap
Houston lift-off: Will Ron Artest and Yao Ming combine to fire up the Rockets?
Roddick serves up a US Open treat to wrap up the first round