Home > Football > Manchester United prove the Premier League is better than Serie A
Manchester United prove the Premier League is better than Serie A
Last night's 2-0 Champions League win over Roma, Arsenal's destruction of Milan, Liverpool knocking out Inter – they all go to show that the Italians are second best.
by 101greatgoals.com on 03 April 2008
Email this Article (12) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
After another easy win for an English team in Italy last night, the dominance of the Premier League over Serie A cannot be doubted. United’s comfortable 2-0 win was the third victory for an English team in Italy in just a few weeks. Both Arsenal and Liverpool won in the San Siro in the last 16 and after years of hearing the hyperbole claiming the “Premier League is the best in the world,” at last it appears to be coming true.
It has been noticeable in all the games between English and Italian sides in the Champions League knockout rounds that the teams from Blighty have all won fairly comfortably. Of course, United are not through to the semi-finals yet, but with a 2-0 lead from the away leg, Alex Ferguson’s side are on course for a semi-final berth, probably against Barcelona.
United conquered Roma with ease. The second-placed side in Serie A appeared scared of taking United on and looked like they never believed they could overcome Rooney, Ronaldo et al after the 7-1 drubbing at Old Trafford last season. Without inspirational captain Francesco Totti, Roma failed to threaten, and United’s greater squad depth was illustrated when they could bring on Carlos Tevez late on whereas the home side were clearly short on numbers and brought on Ludovic Giuly to turn the game round.
Whilst still a fine player, the former Barcelona winger is not at the peak of his powers, and these two substitutions illustrate the financial gulf between the two leagues.
The difference between the top divisions in Italy and England was starkly illustrated by Arsenal’s 2-0 aggregate win over AC Milan. Arsenal’s team was visibly fitter than the ageing Rossoneri side in both legs. It is no coincidence that Arsenal’s two goals in the second leg came in the final 10 minutes.
This tie provided a fine analogy of the differences between Serie A and the Premier League. In the 1990s the Italian top division was full of big stars and dominated European competition. Now the English league has taken on this mantle and Milan, despite being Club World Champions appeared to have only a few players (Kaka, Pato and Nesta) who could live with the young Gunners. Like the Premier League, this Arsenal team will only get better and Serie A, and AC Milan especially, have a lot of work to do to catch up.
The Inter Milan-Liverpool tie showed just how far ahead the Premier League is in comparison with Serie A. The Reds are fourth in England, whilst Inter are four points clear in Italy and should secure another Scudetto in the coming weeks. Yet Inter struggled to make an impact on either game – admittedly the sendings-off in both games did not help, and they failed to score in 180 minutes.
The dominance of English teams has not gone unnoticed in Italy. Writing in The Guardian, Guido Santevecchi, London correspondent of the Italian daily Corriere della Sera, claimed yesterday that the influx of foreigners on the Italian game has diminished the potency of Italian sides: “I am convinced that the overwhelming presence of foreign players dilutes the natural, Italian style of rock-like defence and a strong sense of cohesion. There was a time, when they were carrying off European Cups in the 1960s, when Inter had Giuliano Sarti, Tarcisio Burgnich, Giacinto Facchetti, Aristide Guarnieri and Armando Picchi as defenders and Sandro Mazzola and Mario Corso as forwards. Today, they have a wild bunch of international stars.”
Santevecchi may well be right and the foreign influx has had the opposite effect in England. Managers from mainland Europe and players from all around the world have improved the best English teams and added technical ability to the commitment and spirit they have always shown. Ironically, this has come at a cost to the England national team, who now have an Italian in charge, whilst in recent seasons the Italian national team has prospered.
For the sake of clarity, it is important to note that Serie A has had some success over the Premier League this season. Fiorentina knocked Everton out of the UEFA Cup and the dominance of the English league has been a long time in coming. Yet, with the financial clout of the Premier League getting greater, with what looks to be yet another record-breaking summer of transfers, Italian teams are playing catch up and should perhaps get used to losing to English teams in the coming seasons.
Football often goes in cycles. Serie A was dominant in the ’90s, La Liga had its spell in the sun in the late ’90s and early 2000s, now is the turn of the Big Four in England – they had better not waste these years of plenty.
Comments (12)
by tim on April 03, 2008
If you thought the game against Roma was a cakewalk you need to have you eyes examined. Roma dominated the game entirely for all but the final 2o minutes, when they had completely had the wind taken out of their sails by two goals totally against the run of play. It was daylight robbery that United managed to walk away with a win, and it was only the most outrageous good fortune, and some good keeping, that kept them in it. Roma has every right to be wandering how they could have lost when they so thoroughly dominated the match. I say all that as a die hard United of forty years standing. It's one thing to be a staunch supporter, another to be completely blinded to reality. United were dead lucky, and should take a serious look at their performance if they really want to take the championship out. Barcelona, even as poorly as they're playing at the moment, won't let them get away with such a poor showing in the next phase.
by craig on April 03, 2008
howbadly wrong you are, youmy friend are blinded by the dazzling displays at the theatre of dreams, we play 4-4-2 in the premier league and dominate play, however SAF has now grown wise to the continental game, he went with a 4-5-1 and intended to hit the on the counter attack. which is exactly what we did, are stone wall defence soaked up all the presure, and we hit them with two goals when the commited them selves, i think they got one shot on target, the ball went past the 6 yard box 2 times but with the nearest player 30 yards away, we have not lost yet in the champions league thanks to this set up, you cant expect us to destroy a team like roma, its more like cat and mouse and saf proved him self the master tuesday night
by junior nkem on April 03, 2008
all i will say to man utd is that is like our strikers are getting weak
Craig When you can actually manage to write something coherent and reasonably intelligent in English get back to me. One little point. The team does not play 4-4-2 as some fixed sort of credo in the Premiership. Formations change from week to week to suit the opposition. 4-4-2, 4-2-3-1, 4-3-3, etc. Try watching a few games and learn something, instead of waxing rhapsodic in your fractured English.
by AndrewUnited on April 04, 2008
I assume that if you answer this comment, you will put that arrogance away, where it belongs. I suppose it wasn't the best perfomance by us, but let me remind you what happened exactly a year ago. We tried to play roma, tried to force them out of the game by playing our own 4-4-2. We were miserable. We lost 2-1 and were lucky that Rooney helped us with a little peice of magic. I thought that the perfomance was absolutely what was needed. And except for a few shaky minutes in 2nd half, we looked very strong. And roma, for a home team in the CL, were shockingly bad. Don't know what game you saw, but what they did was exactly what Sir Alex wanted + we won 2-0. And by the way. It doesn't really take a genius to figure out that the Premier League is a couple of levels above everything else .
by torcher monies on April 04, 2008
I know that As Roma is going to win when they use the fomation 5 3 2 of the ACMillans
by Andy Snzaccki on April 04, 2008
The Premier League is the best but why do ya all have to keep on harping on about it? Clearly the Serie A has been the best league in the world the last 20 years and who are the WORLD CHAMPIONS? yeh ITALY!!!!! this is a basless argument and u all need to get a life. basically its just dowmn to pwersonal opinion and to harp onto all u englishmen out there AC MILAN who came 4th last season with one player carrying around 10 grandmas and beating United and Liverpool well then. . . yeh no need to explain. its just personal opinoiin and it comes down to the match itslef and not form and so on. cheers bouysh
by Marcio gabriel on April 04, 2008
Manchester United must sign another striker to create unpredictability against opponents. In Mauro Zarate Of Birminghan Club has a player who moves like MESSI and defines like TORRES. Pay attention to this kid.
by Tony Z on April 05, 2008
Without Totti having played, A S Roma was at a supreme disadvantage. What true satisfaction could there be beating a wounded tiger?
by undefined again on April 06, 2008
I thought there were 20 teams in the premier league, not just Manchester united. I said it before and will say it again, the reason the premiership is the best league in the world is because of the style of play. The end to end action and passion is what makes a league, one team doesn't.
on April 14, 2008 on April 14, 2008
I think we rode our luck against Roma in the olympic stadium. They were woeful in the return leg though. As for the Prem being the best in the world, well that is of course debatable. I would certainly say that it is better than the Italian league at the Moment. Yes Italy won the world cup, but thats a different kettle of fish. No one is saying English players are the best in the world (well not me anyway) but our league is made up of many foreign players who have improved the game immesurably, at least technically. The fact that United, Liverpool ,Arsenal and Chelsea made it to the Quarters speaks volumes of our league standing in european football. Also Liverpool beat Inter easily and Arsenal beat Milan. There is only Barcelona to stand in the way of an all English club final. So for me the prem has to be the best in Europe at least. And that is an accolade to all the teams in it.
by jaime montero on August 16, 2008
im sorry but i find the itallian league much more intrestng, itallian passion for football is un matched it was a bad year for itallian football last year. but this year the englis teams will be put in their place
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
England must scrape the bottom and turn to Spurs for wide-left salvation
Jelena Jankovic v Ana Ivanovic - Serbian tennis rivals for the world No.1 spot
Spurs go one better than Barcelona in Krakow – now bring on Hull City!