Home > Football > Paul McStay - a Celtic legend who made the wrong choice
Paul McStay - a Celtic legend who made the wrong choice
He was the quiet, one-club man who was courted by Europe's top clubs. But did he make a big mistake in swearing allegiance to the Hoops?
by gerald mclaughlin on 11 April 2008
Email this Article (15) Comments
Free £25 bet when you register at
One of the finest players I ever watched on a football pitch was Paul McStay. It was just such a shame that "The Maestro" was born at the wrong time.McStay captained Scotland at every level in football and earned 76 caps for his country at senior level. He was a rarity in modern football being a "one club man" which, in part, may have led to the unfulfilment of a special talent.He appeared 678 times for his beloved Celtic, scoring 72 goals from midfield. His early years at Parkhead were fairly successful, winning the Scottish League title three times in the 80s. McStay also won four Scottish Cups and one League Cup in his career with the "Bhoys". He also represented Scotland at two World Cup Finals. 'I would have liked to have seen him leave when he had the chance because a player with his ability should have been showcased on the biggest stage'Surrounded by a solid and talented bunch of professionals during the 80s, and playing in a Scottish League that was at its most competitive in years, Celtic and McStay enjoyed enormous success.Indeed it was not until the 90s, when Celtic were beginning to fall apart financially, and Rangers were striding ahead thanks to a David Murray/Graeme Souness-led revolution, that McStay was being courted by clubs in England and further afield. He was handed the captaincy at Parkhead but this time the supporting cast of players around him were not up to scratch. Rangers had already embarked on their nine-in-row title run and Celtic were struggling to keep pace.
Comments (15)
by Mort on April 11, 2008
I remember in Paul McStay's final year, there were a number of mid-table EPL sides courting "The Maestro" to play one last season with them but he declined stating that he always wanted to be rememembered as "Paul McStay - Celtic and Scotland". A true legend and boy could we do with him now. Mort
by Danny 427 on April 11, 2008
The guy was a genius - oh how we could do with him now right enough. I'm just glad that I had the privilege of seeing him play!
by Al 888 on April 11, 2008
Square pass McStay. Average at best.
on April 11, 2008 on April 11, 2008
by kev mullen on April 11, 2008
mcstay a player of genuine quality was fastly underated probably untill now when you see the likes of scott brown going for and earning rediculous amounts of money.as a celtic fan i feel paul should of left when celtic played on his loyalty and refused to spend and rebuild a team worthy of him in it.paul mcstay deserves to be called a celtic legend pure class.
by jimbo murt on April 12, 2008
Square pass??? surely ure talking bout bazza ferguson!!! The maestro was a fantastic player , a rarity showing loyalty to the club he loves a true celtic legend from a true celtic family!!! If mcstay had have went to a mid league EPL club like bazza chose, hed have set the world alight and went onto bigger and better things and not come crawlingup north again tail between his legs, unable to hack it in the big league!!!
by mo mo on April 12, 2008
I saw Mcstay week in week out and i have to agree with the queen lover he was pretty average and way way overated.
by Mick Reilly on April 12, 2008
Square Ba my A*** McStay was undoubtedly the most gifted footballer of his generation in his position who could forget his burst onto the scene with his goals from midfield particularly his blockbuster against TFOD and his wonderful goals for Scotland at Hampden, the dynamism of his early days gave way to a more thoughtful mature operator in the midfield but to this day I could not say for certain whether he was a nuturally left sided or right sided player ala Mr Moravcick. Had he the inlination to leave the club he loved I have absolutely no doubt that he would have graced any of the top stadia in europe and I for one am forever thankful for what he done for our team during the bad days when many others used and abused us for there own ends! Thats why I sing " They gave us James McGrory and Paul McStay" Hail Hail my son!
by Finbar Eastand on April 12, 2008
He was an above average player in a poor side, which made him look a lot better than he actually was. Played over 70 times for Scotland, and can't remember having a good game.
by Gunga Din on April 14, 2008
Celtc failed Paul. He had potential...but a series of mistakes managerially and the biscuit tin mentality deprived him of realising it. Nice guy though...met him a couple of times. Best ambassador for you lot since Danny McGrain. Compare his attitude to almost all of your squad now. How many play for the jersey? I'm not saying Rangers are any different btw...just pointing out a sign of the times. Anyhoo...I think Paul was too trusting and was manipulated by a club who were desperate to sell season tickets at the time.
by Andy Gilhooly on April 26, 2008
Paul - a true modern day celt legend. If he reads this thank you
by home insurance home insurance on April 29, 2008
fvramea-qj7g56y-tw6q6482-0 <a href="http://carinsurance.thrill.to#2">car insurance</a> http://finance.groups.yahoo.com/group/insurance-/#1 [url=http://finance.groups.yahoo.com/group/car-insura nce_/#3]car insurance[/url] [url]http://lowcostautoinsurance.escape.to#4[/url] [http://lowcostautoinsurance.andmuchmore.com#5 low cost auto insurance] "auto insurance":http://finance.groups.yahoo.com/group/insur ance-/#6 [LINK http://homeinsurance.andmuchmore.com#7]home insurance[/LINK]
by Jean Gallagher on May 29, 2008
Paul was one of the greatest players to ever were the hoops, I also believe that if he had played along side the likes of Larsson and Sutton, he would have been a multi million pound player, apart from that he could have played for any team in the world and left a greater mark on world football, never the less he will always be a world class player in the eyes of the Celtic following
by brian mccarry on June 06, 2008
the best midfielder in u.k in mid 80s.pure genius.pity about some of his team mates over d years.met him a few times.shear class.love d maestro 2 present trophies in c.nauld 2moro nite.any chance .keep the faith
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Time the All Black and Wallaby rugby meanies paid their way in the sacrifice stakes!