Home > Football > After Arsenal, Chelsea and foreign domination, at last a BRITISH FA Cup Final!
After Arsenal, Chelsea and foreign domination, at last a BRITISH FA Cup Final!
For years, football's showpiece occasion has been dominated by the Big Four with their host of overseas superstars. But when Portsmouth take on Cardiff City at Wembley next month, 13 homegrown players are likely to be in the starting line-up. A good or bad aspect of having a Championship team in the final?
by Gerry Horsfield on 14 April 2008
Email this Article (12) Comments
Do you remember when the FA Cup used to be an occasion that showcased the best of English Football? You know, when players with almost exclusively British roots used to strut their stuff at Wembley on that glorious footballing outing each May?If you're under 21, you probably don't - apart from that fleeting occasion when Millwall made it to the final against Manchester United in 2004. The big day seems to have become an incessant repetition of Big Four confrontations with homegrown players perpetually a tiny minority of the stars on show.How refreshing, then, that this year's final on May 17 will feature MORE British and Irish players than overseas stars. All things being equal, I can see THIRTEEN homegrown players starting the Portsmouth v Cardiff match - and it's all down to the fact that for the second time in four years, we have a Championship team in the final. In 2004, when Millwall predictably lost 3-0 to United, there were SIXTEEN homegrown players in the starting line-up - nine in the Lions team and seven in United's. Since those balmy days, the big boys seem to have been bolstered by even more overseas stars and these days it's difficult to think of a Premier League team with more Brits than overseas stars,OK, one might argue that the more British players, the less successful the team tend to be. Hence the fact that overseas players are a distinct minority in the Championship - and the argument that the more foreign stars you have, the better your squad is likely to be. If that's so, how on earth did Cardiff get to the final while the Big Four all fell by the wayside?I for one find it really refreshing that a team like the Bluebirds, who Field only three non-domestic players in their normal starting line-up, (namely Finnish goalkeeper Peter Enckelman and Dutchmen Glenn Loovens and Jimmy-Floyd Hasselbaink), will be strutting their stuff at Wembley with a predominantly homegrown squad. The rest of manager Dave Jones's likely starting line-up will be a pleasant mix of English, Welsh and Irish (both from the North and Republic) - many of them with top-level experience in either England or Scotland.Before people start labelling me racist, let me say I have absolutely no prejudice against non-Brits. I love to see overseas stars weaving their magic (if only our lads had such graceful skills), but at the end of the day we are talking about the ENGLISH League. So why on earth shouldn't its players be predominantly English - or at least British?These days the Big Four's first-choice line-ups can't aggregate 11 British players between them; indeed, how many Premier League teams have more domestically-reared stars in their teams than foreigners?The Arsenal chestnut is the oldest of the lot. To call them an English team is to my mind ridiculous when it's hard to remember Arsene Wenger fielding a Brit in his starting line-up all season. Chelsea used to be the biggest 'villains', but at least they now have John Terry, Frank Lampard and the two Coles starting on a pretty regular basis.Rafa Benitez's first-choice non-rotational Liverpool line-up would probably only include Steven Gerrard and Jamie Carragher, leaving Manchester United to keep the home flag flying with Owen Hargeaves, Rio Ferdinand, Paul Scholes, Wayne Rooney and Michael Carrick providing almost half a team of Brits.How different it is in the Championship, where you'd struggle to find a team with more than a couple of overseas players and where non-British managers are a tiny minority. Personally, that's how I'd like it to be throughout the league. I'm all for quotas...and while I have no objection to foreign managers, they should never be allowed to name a starting lineup with more foreign players than Brits.Maybe then Arsenal might start winning something...
Comments (12)
by Gerry Horsefield Snr on April 14, 2008
What a load of bollox. Dont you have any Immigrants to beat up or BNP flyers to hand out.
by Ray Knight on April 14, 2008
Yep, at last a Cup Final that I don't have to bother staying in to watch.
by percy norman on April 14, 2008
This is most stupid and pointless article I have ever read. I dont know why I bothered to read it. And I certainly don't know why I am bothering to respond to it. In fact I don't think I will bothe............
by tamir tamir on April 14, 2008
by Anthony Duddy on April 14, 2008
Portsmouth with their 3 English players in the starting 11 and a Welsh team......need I say more!!!!!!!
by Tommy Tanker on April 14, 2008
Q: "why on earth shouldn't its [the premier league]players be predominantly English - or at least British?" A: Coz it would be shit; as you rightly point out it is the foreigners that make this league great in addition to some tope class homegrown talent like rooney, gerrard et al. Talking of manchester united flying the flag with british players. If you take away scholes, Neville and Giggs then you are left with Brown, O'Shea, Rooney, Hargreaves, Carrick, Ferdinand. The first two are derided for being shit, whilst the others cost nearly £100m between them. As far as I am concerned that is a negative thing for the game: That Man Utd use their financial muscle to buy up all the best English talent, that most others can't afford.
on April 14, 2008 on April 14, 2008
How much did you list of English (on summer vacation) players cost Gerry?
by Liam Daly on April 15, 2008
U are 100% right, the ENGLISH FA Cup final should be played predominantly by ENGLISH players and ENGLISH managers..........If only a WELSH side weren't in it
on April 15, 2008 on April 15, 2008
Why? this country voted to go in the EU and freedom to work in other countries. (we got what we voted for)
on April 16, 2008 on April 16, 2008
You is very good Cristiano Ronaldo!!!
by garcia rios on April 16, 2008
me gusta mucho estan los mejores jugadores y estan nejor organisados
by steven mcdougall on April 30, 2008
here here i agree. I think it is great that cardiff are in the final. I am glad that the final actually has predominantly English - or at least British players plaiyng. why is arsenal classified as a english team when only one player(theo) is actually from england? Don't get me wrong, i do enjoy watching foreign talent strut their stuff however you have got to remember this is an english league which should be showcasing mostly english talent.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Last Name
Sport
Email
League
Heading
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *