Home > Football > Barcelona v Manchester United is a showcase of talents, while Liverpool v Chelsea is more like chess
Barcelona v Manchester United is a showcase of talents, while Liverpool v Chelsea is more like chess
Who will win come through the Champions League semis – and will it be an all-English final in Moscow? Here's one fan's verdict ...
by Charles Segujja Musoke on 22 April 2008
Email this Article (14) Comments
Free £25 bet when you register at
Big savings on football products from boots to balls!
Manchester United visit Spain in confident mood after their fantatsic displays of total football this season. The first leg of their semi-final is at the Nou Camp where United won the Champions League so dramatically in 1999. It’s going to be a mouthwatering tie. The previous notable clash between the two sides came in that amazing Treble season for United when they faced each other in Group D and both games ended 3-3.
Paul Scholes, Wes Brown, Gary Neville and Ryan Giggs featured in that United side while Xavi is the only Barcelona player still around from their 1998-99 team. With the hopes of an all-Premier League final dashed last season, the scene is set for a memorable night when two great English sides will grace the final in Moscow. My take on this is a Manchester United v Liverpool final in the Luzhniki Stadium.
Cristiano Ronaldo, arguably the best player in the world right now, is leading the race to take all the individual honours this season and he will spice up the game in the Nou Camp, especially with a point to prove to Lionel Messi and Co. The supporting role of Scholes and Giggs will richly benefit United at this stage where maturity and brains play a vital role.
On the other side of the coin, Barcelona are locked into all kinds of mishaps on and off pitch so we expect them to play under lots of pressure, with manager Frank Rijkaard really feeling the strain. Their performance in La Liga is fast becoming a serious turn off; the fans are calling for Rijkaard to resign and the absence of former World Player of the Year Ronaldinho – a player who can rise up to any occasion – will be a huge blow for Barcelona's hopes.
But even without the Brazilian, the game showcases the richest of talents – Barcelona have Bojan Krkic, Giovanni and Messi while United can boast Anderson, Nani, Ronaldo, Rooney and Tevez.
The other semi-final kicks of 24 hours earlier at Anfield tomorrow night. Liverpool are rightful favourites to go through against Chelsea, based on their European tactical nous and know-how. The two teams will cross paths for the third time in just four years in the Champions League. These games are usually very moody and tense, providing a dull display of football and few goals, including the controversial winner by Luis Garcia that decided the 2005 tie and that Chelsea fans swear to this day never crossed the line.
Liverpool had the advantage for the previous ties as the second and decisive legs were played at Anfield, but this time round it’s vice versa. The big question is: Can Avram Grant do what the Special One failed to do and beat Liverpool in the Champions League or will it be another cheesy ride for Rafa Benitez over the Blues.
This is a tie I believe will be decided by tactics rather than talent.
Avram Grant doesn’t have half the experience and knowledge on such a stage as Benitez, who is far tactically superior at the European game. Even the Special One had to bow to Rafa when the teams met in the Champions League, so I think Grant’s inexperience and tactical inability will hamper Chelsea’s chances of a place in Moscow.
Playing Michael Essien at right back to accommodate the stars in the side is the perfect example of his poor team selection and his tactics have been exposed this season by great thinkers like Wigan boss Steve Bruce and Tottenham's Juande Ramos.
I only see a more severe and punishing test from Rafa Benitez’s Liverpool, who killed off Inter Milan and Arsenal with good organisation and tactical composure. Expect the resurrection of Xabi Alonso, a man who hasn’t been up to his usual high standard this term but who always seems to fancy games against Chelsea. He and Javier Mascherano can dominate the midfield.
Fernando Torres can roam wild into the Chelsea defence, with Steven Gerard playing in the middle and Jermaine Pennant racing down the right flank and providing the ammunition for Peter Crouch and Torres.
Chelsea’s fortunes could rely on the acumen of Michael Ballack and Claude Makelele in midfield and Andriy Schevchenko and Nicolas Anelka – both Champions League winners – up front. Frank Lampard's creativity and goals will be needed more than ever and Liverpool should not give him any space within 30 yards of goal. But with You'll Never Walk Alone ringing around Anfield and the Kop in full voice, I expect Liverpool to outclass Chelsea and win this game.
VERDICT: Liverpool 2 Chelsea 1
Sir Alex Ferguson's side has more than enough quality to get the job done in Barcelona. And with the tactician in Carlos Queiroz, United will play a more European style system to facilitate the experience of Englishman Owen Hargreaves, who scored a stunning free kick against Arsenal in the Premier League recently. With options to look out for on the bench in the shape of Nani, Anderson and Park Ji-Sung, United should have little to worry about.
Ferguson sees this as a great chance to win the Champions League after describing his current side as the best he has ever worked with. United have potential match-winners all over the pitch and any side would fear goal-machine Ronaldo, the never-say-die Tevez and the influential Wayne Rooney. At the back they have the steel of Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic. Then there is the experience of Giggs and Scholes, which could be crucial for the Red Devils. However, when making predictions for great such ties, a note of caution should be taken because anything can happen.
Barcelona, like United, have all the attacking riches and talents in their ranks to beat any football team in the world when they click. Problem is Rafael Márquez and Gianluca Zambrotta have still got a point to prove for the Barca fans at the back – without inspirational captain Carles Puyol, Barcelona look fragile and will get caught by the trademark United counter attacks.
I believe United can harm the Catalans in the Nou Camp just like they destroyed AS Roma’s hopes in the first leg in Rome.
Barca’s chances surely rest on Messi’s artistry and composure for such big games. Samuel Eto’o, Xavi and Andres Iniesta can all be a threat while Thierry Henry, with his knowledge of the English game and blistering speed, will need no incentive to try to spoil the Man United party. However, with the final leg in the Theatre of Dreams, and taking form considerations into account, I see a United away win.
VERDICT: Barcelona 1 Manchester United 2
Comments (14)
by Peter Archer on April 22, 2008
Can we put this one to bed about the so called disputed Garcia goal once and for all!! The ref admitted he was going to award a penalty if Garcia had not 'scored', so whichever way you look at it we won. Thank you and goodnight.
by Peter Cech on April 22, 2008
What makes you think you would of scored the penalty? Garcia's goal was definately not a goal so the story will never end.
by LondonGooner on April 22, 2008
Atleast the Barca v Man Utd game will be worth watching, christ Liverpool and Chelsea bore the pants off everyone, including their own supporters. Looking forward to seeing players with flair, creativity, passing ability and manageras who like to win things (obviously) AND have the ability to play good football also. Which rules out Benitez and Grant wether they admit it or not.
on April 22, 2008 on April 22, 2008
Who cares if it was a goal, or wasn't? You lost, we won. End of. Bring on Round 3.
by Wardy on April 22, 2008
That pretty much rules Wenger out as well then doesn't it he's been potless for seasons.
I'm sorry, but why does everyone conveniently forget that Liverpool have scored the most goals this season in all competitions, and in Europe alone? And yet, they're a dull, defensive team... Lazy and biased journalism and comments do not make them true. Research all your facts before spouting lazy rubbish, please.
by Lester Basson on April 22, 2008
I read this assuming that it will be an unbiased piece of reported. Till I saw Man U and total football in one sentence. What is the British press' love affair with Man U. Jeez what does Liverpool have to do to be given credit. We lost last years final against the same ageing Milan side that destroyed Man U and what was said afterwards? Take Ronaldo away and Man U would have been mid table. FFS grow a brain or balls and stop being so anal.
by jobo on April 22, 2008
Most entertaining prem game = LIVERPOOL vs Newcastle - {...} - Most entertaining FA cup final in a good 20 years = LIVERPOOL vs West ham - {...} - Most entertaining UEFA cup final ever = LIVERPOOL vs Alaves - {...} - Most entertaining European cup final ever = LIVERPOOL vs AC milan. The most entertaining team in the Prem is Arsenal who play great football all season. In europe, no other team can boast such entertainment as Liverpool. United have beaten the likes of Roma and Lyon etc - who, lets be honest... cannot cut it. Lets give credit were its due - Liverpool are superb in europe. Arsenal are great in prem - united don't figure because they win with bias and favours from refs and the FA.
by max adams on April 22, 2008
Try lester biason ... mid table without ronaldo lol, i think if u remember we beat AC once and they beat us once. We had our entire defence out or weakened on tht night so giving that thought i think its a fair point. And on the note of defence, our back four alone could get us mid-table let alone without ronaldo, y dnt u try liverpool without torres this year, dyu rly think u wud of pipped everton to fourth? no neither does anyone else ... wot have u got to do to get credit? How about you play either one of two things ... football that is fun to watch, or football that gets you points, because your well off the pace in the league and thats why you get no credit. Thank u and gd night
by Ken T on April 22, 2008
Yeah showcase like models doing catwalking and chess game for the genius.
by THE GREATEST on April 22, 2008
United do play total football you muppet, if you knew anything about football you would know that. Since im assuming you don't even know what it is its a tactic where players switch positions regularly; You know the way Rooney ends up on the wings? or Ronaldo roams and switches sides with Nani/Giggsy? or Tevez drops deep? ....... and so on. And as you are criticising United try looking at the stats and tell me how many years its been since you beat us? I can tell you now its 4. 4 years of us picking up easy wins at Old Trafford and Anfield. And sure Besiktas are being investigated for match fixing so therefore 8 of your goals dont count muppet
by Ray Akins on April 23, 2008
Wenger is my idol in soccer and if i was rijakarrd i would use a formation of 4-5-1, Man utd power is by the midfield and if barca can close that up they would have little or nothing to do and their weak points are also the flanks.most goals scored from them are crossing from the wings or running thru from the wings which messi does best. henry is also tall. I would line up henry as a lone striker looking at the fact that they are playing an english side and henry has played english football for most of his life, Man utd would not be an exception. Eto would handle west browns area, messi for patrice evra, 2 defensive midfielders in the middle of an attacking middle fielder and warn their defenders neva to come outside to attack that way manutd would not counter attack them, cause i find it hard to counter a team with 3 or four players with the goal keeper also at the back of the ball, and that is why i said etoo should play left flank while messi should handle right cause they are more than capable. There would be no need for a defender to overlap thereby giving the opponents little chance or no of counter attacking. if ronaldinho and deco are fit then i would prefer deco playing as the defensive midfielder and ronaldinho attacking midfielder and remember yaya toure/xavi preferable(Xavi's passes are as deadly as messi"s) could also join deco as a defensive midfielder. if not barca have got Xavi and inesta, one needs to play of a role defensive midfielder with yaya toure.
by romeo ofori on April 23, 2008
Barcelona have the chance even though they seem unglittery in their home league bar ca
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *