Home > Football > A black mark for Zenit's UEFA Cup winners as Rangers pay price of negativity
A black mark for Zenit's UEFA Cup winners as Rangers pay price of negativity
Zenit St Petersburg, it seems, are a club that will not tolerate or encourage black players. When is this attitude going to change?
by Patrick Cook on 16 May 2008
Email this Article (10) Comments
Zenit St Petersburg won their first, and Russia's second UEFA Cup on Wednesday night. They where my favourites to beat Rangers, whose defensive football has been terrible to watch.
I think the main problem I have with their football, particularly in European competition, was the cause of their downfall. When Zenit scored with just 18 minutes to go, Rangers had no ability to put their foot on the accelerator and find an equaliser.I don't have issues with every club that plays defensively because usually they also try to use the counter attack or set piece to score goals. Rangers didn't even seem interested in scoring in this manner. They had 120 minutes and penalties on their mind.However, my restrained adulation at seeing Zenit beat those anti-football Glaswegians has been scuppered by the reports of a racist transfer policy at the Russian club.Martin Samuel reports on timesonline.co.uk that Zenit coach, Dick Advocaat, won't sign black players because the fans won't allow him to.
"Advocaat said in an interview conducted with Yuri Doud, an English-speaking journalist working for Pro Sport magazine in Russia, that he could not sign black players as coach of Zenit. The fans would not allow it, he claimed. In 83 years Zenit have never found use for a black player and Advocaat’s chosen path is not to confront this standard, but to work with it. “I don’t want to sign a player who won’t be accepted by the fans,” he told Doud, who has the interview on tape."Advocaat continued the interview by stating: “The fans are the most important thing that Zenit have and that is why I have to ask them outright how they will react if we sign a dark-skinned player.”
He also said, in the conversation with Pro Sport: “The only players who can make Zenit stronger are dark skinned. Look at the Brazilians who play for CSKA Moscow. For us, it would be impossible. I would be happy to sign anyone, but the fans don’t like black players. I do not understand how they could pay so much attention to skin colour. For me, there is no difference; but they care.”Advocaat renaged on a contract with the Australian Football Federation to manage the Socceroos to take up his current role at Zenit and I'm very glad he did.
Comments (10)
by Richie Walker on May 17, 2008
I agree with your view on the Zenit transfer policy but let's not forget Rangers transfer policy formost of the 20th century!
by Henry Cope on May 17, 2008
Patrick, I can't believe you've written an article about racism and the uefa cup final and not mentioned Rangers. Apart from their policy of refusing to sign Catholics, their fans still run through a repertoire of anti-Irish songs at every match. This racism is at the heart of the hooliganism that followed the uefa cup final, which you also failed to mention. Bravo!
by Essexian76 on May 18, 2008
Supporting Milan though?, you know the ones who are so snow white when it comes to a little backhander here and there, hypocritical or do you just select which crime is or isnt acceptable?. Advocaat, merely said what was fair to the PLAYER, not expressing an opinion as to the rights and wrongs, and that was the PLAYER would endure a torrid time there because of the fans attitude towards players of a different skin, as opposed to Moscow where its not a problem!
by pat cook on May 19, 2008
Henry Cope, I think there is a difference between racist fans and racism in a club. While i hate to see racism anywhere, i feel its much more important to ensure clubs set an example for their fans. Essexian, I know you don't like me and I assume your refering to Calciopoli. Milan have paid the price for that, I hope Zenit pay the price for their crimes
by chris inkt on May 19, 2008
Having listitend to the fans to do what you say is correct, butt when are the fans going to listen what you have to say, if they really care about there team lett them just accept anyone, because its not the colour that plays the ball butt the player its self! soccer is the very best sport on this planet, its brings people together, if the fans realy love soccer and their team THEY must love anyone that plays it and dont look at the colour butt at the Quality of the player
by A Moses MacNeil Sandal on May 19, 2008
Henry and Richie, it's been 20 years since Mo Johnson signed for Rangers, when will you finally accept there is no 'policy', and you think we live in the past? Rangers fans were guilty of many things on Wednesday however racism is not one of them and your assertion says more about your prejudices than it does about mine. The article is about Zenit and intolerance in modern Russia, it is pertinent, informative and timely yet you ignore it so you can make some cheap and inaccurate digs at Rangers. Go have a look in the mirror guys. Good article.
by Henry on May 19, 2008
Moses, every Rangers game this season has featured thousands of their fans singing 'The [Irish] famine is over, why don't you go home?'. Their fans routinely boo Irish players like Noel Hunt of Dundee United and even Scottish players who play for Ireland like Aiden McGeady. This is racism.
by pat cook on May 21, 2008
i wrote this article straight after the final, before thepost-match violence had come to light. i have written some stuff about it on my blog. I also want to again underline that while some rangers fans are still racist the club has come in leaps and bounds in promoting tolerance and hopefully the generation of fans filtering through will follow the clubs example. Anyway, i think its good football provides a forum for these discussions
by A Moses MacNeil Sandal on May 23, 2008
Sorry Henry I heard that chant for the first time about 2 months ago and it is purely and simply aimed at Celtic fans who wear Irish strips, wave Irish flags, flaunt thier 'Irishness' and sing about the Irish famine like it happened yesterday. Racism? - get real. And you really don't want to open the racism can of worms? We both know what happened when Mark Walters made his first appearance at Parkhead. Noel Hunt is booed by every teams fans, he is an annoying, persistent, complaining and frustratingly effective forward, the type you hate when he plays against you and love if he plays for you, he could come from the moon and he would get booed. Nacho Novo gets far worse from opposing fans, are they anti-Spanish? Pat Bonner played for Celtic for a long time and I don't remember one instance of him being subject to anymore abuse than anyone else and certainly nothing like your current goalie, but don't tell me that's because we're anti-Polish no doubt! On McGeady, tell me if he'd chosen to play for England do you think he'd still get booed?
by Evil Genius on June 10, 2008
Moses Congratulations for arguing your point in an intelligent manner but the song why dont you go home may not be aimed in a racist manner but it does have racist connotations. Surely an intelligent man like yourself can see how this song damages your club? Ps why shouldnt they flaunt their Irishness? Why should any immigrant not flaunt their heritage?
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Last Name
Sport
Email
League
Heading
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Cardiff City must stick to the rules in all this Hasselbaink hassle
Arsenal fans can relax - with Wenger in charge the future is red and white!
Fedrinator v Nadambo: The keys to Roger Federer retaining his Wimbledon title - or a Rafael Nadal takeover