Home > Football > The rank hypocrisy of Fergie and Manchester United over Cristiano Ronaldo for Real Madrid
The rank hypocrisy of Fergie and Manchester United over Cristiano Ronaldo for Real Madrid
The bitter war of words between the two clubs shows no sign of abating, but United aren't exactly saints when it comes to wooing players – just ask Jaap Stam.
by 101greatgoals.com on 02 June 2008
Email this Article (15) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Big savings on football products from boots to balls!
To the newspapers' delight, the Cristiano-Ronaldo-for-Real-Madrid transfer saga is a story that refuses to go away. The fervour is being fuelled from all angles, with every sound-bite from Ronaldo, Manchester United, Real or even the Portuguese player's godfather being treated as gospel.
The nonsense is given fresh legs on almost a daily basis thanks to a continuous stream of verbal assaults thrown back and forth between Manchester and Madrid. Carlos Queiroz, the United No.2, got particularly hot under the collar last week with his outbursts, taking the whole episode to new heights by stirring up deep-rooted national hatreds coveted by the Portuguese and Spanish factions.
Queiroz, who was sacked by Real Madrid after just one season, spluttered: "Cristiano Ronaldo will never be Spanish as they will never take Olivenca again. They already did the same with Christopher Columbus and it now seems they want to naturalise Cristiano Ronaldo." Queiroz's bitterness towards Real was plain to see when he added: "The current chairman of Real Madrid [Ramon Calderon] was my manager, and I know what he told me and what happens in the end. I have the advantage of knowing the differences between the two clubs."
So there you have it. Manchester United are saints and Real Madrid are the thieving, lying sinners. United would never succumb to the low life tactics of trying to unsettle a player before prising him away from his club. Oh, wait. But what about Jaap Stam?
The holier-than-thou attitude of United seems incredibly rich having regard to the way the Red Devils went about their business in 1998. Back then, the towering, uncompromising centre-back was a mainstay in the Dutch league. PSV Eindhoven were not interested in letting go of their colossus. But did this stop Alex Ferguson approaching the player? Of course it didn't.
Following the release of his autobiography, Head-to-Head, Stam spoke to Simon Kuper back in 2001 to reveal how his transfer to United came about.
"In 1997, when Stam was established at PSV, Alex Ferguson approached him. But as the player reveals in his memoir – a book so uncharacteristically controversial it might almost have been written by someone else – Ferguson was dismissed… In 1998 Ferguson returned, this time with the famous unauthorised approach that Stam had to keep secret. They made a rendezvous in a safe house near Amsterdam airport… Stam caught only snippets of their first conversation. Nonetheless, he was so keen to join United that he waived the £1.65m signing-on fee due to him, because the club refused to pay PSV more than £10.5m."
Please do not read this as a justification for Madrid's current scheming. Their underhand behaviour, including using the influential Spanish paper, Marca, to unsettle Ronaldo, is scurrilous. Nevertheless, the cries from Old Trafford have a sanctimonious whiff to them having regard to their less-than-perfect record in tapping up players to their own benefit.
Rather than yelling abuse at Madrid, Ferguson should be sitting down with Ronaldo himself and forcing the youngster to make a clear and simple public statement putting the issue to bed. However, the fact that Ronaldo has yet to pour water on this fire gives the impression that Real's advances are playing on the mind of the United star.
Lovers of the Premier League will be urging Ronaldo to continue to ply his trade in England. However, in the event that he is Spanish-bound, United have little moral high ground from which they can cry about it.
Comments (15)
by Mike Smith on June 02, 2008
If you believe that then you're just about the biggest idiot this world has seen, so United was on operation big tower trying to get Jaap Stam? I can only imagine you're a Liverpool fan with a passion for United and not to mention a lack of brain cells. All teams have unsettled players just not in the way of Madrid, Liverpool are doing it with Barry, Chelsea with Essien, Madrid with Ronaldo, Kaka, Fabregas, Diarra etc... But Real are pushing the boundaries a bit if you read all the reports.
on June 02, 2008 on June 02, 2008
Ferguson, the biggest hypocrite in football, FACT!!!!!
by Kev barfoot on June 02, 2008
Well, If one wants to put on hold all of thier summer spending to try to 'encourage' Ronaldo to put in a transfer request I personally think thats going a bit too far. Utd had a similar situation with Owen H, but the difference being that they tabled an offer and then, and only then, did it go public. Also the Germans were willing to sell, just not in January. Real have not tabled an offer, they know Utd's stance, but yet they still come out with comments like "he will make real madrid a better team WHEN he plays for us". Constantly talking about WHEN it will happen, not if, not maybe, they seem to just presume they can push Utd to one side. Oh how I bet Real wish CR7 was at Sporting still, as then this approach would be GUARENTEED to work. Oh hang on, I just sounded a bit like Calderon then didn't I?
by Essexian76 on June 02, 2008
Utd use their status and the press to unsettle players to a fine art. look at the purchases of Carrick and Hargreaves, and many others in the past.Berbatov was targeted by Utd last season and Liverpool are doing it with Barry at the present, how on earth are teams below the top four ever going to be able to challenge when their best players are constantly getting tapped up.Nice to see Ronaldo is totally diassociating himself, by a vocal pledge of loyalty? .As for Gerrard openly trying to get Barry to join Liverpool?, I would have thought he would have left them for Chelsea if he really wanted a Championship medal !
by Garibaldi Sashakashamashahashaspalletikanouteson on June 02, 2008
Demand Higuain and Ramos plus £20 million and use that money to buy Karim Benzema. I don't understand why Ronaldo has to speak in riddles and be continually contradictory. What is this bizarre deadline of '2 weeks' then in '2 or 3 days' and 'I will make my decision'. No player is bigger than Manchester United. We all want to see him stay for at least two more seasons but if the worst happens, i would rather squeeze Real Madrid of their very best talent than keep Ronaldo in the stands. United should demand a ridiculous player money compensation package from Madrid if he ends up departing.
by The Boss on June 02, 2008
If ronaldo wants to go i think man utd should cash in cause it doesn't make sense to keep a player who has his heart set on a another club...and given the fact man utd have sell other big players like beckham, van nistelrooy who were instrumental to the team at the time of their sale....sir alex will get his players to rise to the occasion again to conquer england especially now that all the main title pretenders are going through some change or rebuilding stage. The key again will be Vidic and Ferdinand and Anderson (if he gets the starting role a lot of ppl desire).
I notice the story is penned by a non de plume? Is that because it could be construde as libelous?
by dr dre on June 02, 2008
i say that as a red devil. enough is enough. sell him buy benzima,ben arfa and sergio ramos
by sven on June 02, 2008
i remember when fulham didn't want to sell saha and utd told him to say he wouldn't play to force a move. bellion........ the list gose on and on and on.
by AndrewUnited on June 03, 2008
Hmm, we all have to reconsider what we see and read. If you don't see it on camera, dont believe it! Ronaldo is not really being unfair. All he's said is: I don't promise anyone anything, and there will be news in a few days, because i'm playing for the national team. He has also told us to stop believing the Spansih newspapers as these lie. Yesterday he even said he wanted to go down as a legend, the same as Cantona, Best and Bekham. That said, if he does want to go, I see absolutely no point in leaving him on the stands. Thats ludacris. Take the 60 mill and buy Benzema and a class defender and another left winger. Use Nani on the right and just watch, just watch how Rooney will develop into the goalscoring machine we all want him to be. Trust me, he'll turn into a world class goalscorer. Plus we'd be without this constant speculation every summer. Of course, that's until Anderson is fully developed.
by Fergies a Douche on June 03, 2008
United target and attempt to unsettle other teams star players all the time. Get over it Manure, Ronaldo is going to Real Madrid eventually !!!
by Fernando on June 03, 2008
Real Madrid are not Marca and Marca are not Real Madrid. Marca objective is to make a profit by selling papers. To say that "Real Madrid use Marca" is wrong, simply a myth propagated by the English press. As a matter of fact Marca had some unfavourable article about Ramon Calderon, and the relationship between club president and sports tabloid is very much fractured.
by The Prince on June 03, 2008
So two wrongs make a right? Assholes
on June 03, 2008 on June 03, 2008
Poor deluded glory-hunting south-coast plastic mancs! How many goals has Ronaldo scored this past season! 30-40 I believe? compare that with what is considered a decent goal return from a midfielder which is about 10 and this season without Ronaldo you would have been as trophyless as them sorry gooners, he is irreplacable!!!!!!!!
by dipsonroy oyediran on June 06, 2008
i dont know why man u family are complaining, all d big player they bought is it not a great painful 4 them,like tevez,rooney,anderson,nani. think of dis b4 u talk let these boy do what ever he want to do such is football all of u that make comment know what u want.that is what he want .u dont need to hate him now.he know what is good for himself ,plsssssssssssss let be.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
US Open crunch: Roger Federer survives - now can Andy Murray finish off Rafael Nadal?
Toulouse, Stade Francais or maybe Dan Carter's Perpignan - who's hot for French rugby's Top 14?
Andorra a doddle, Croatia the BIG test - but are England up to it without Newcastle's Owen?