Home > Football > The poisoned chalice: Why Manchester City's Hughes-Shinawatra partnership is doomed
by gerald mclaughlin on 06 June 2008
Email this Article (60) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Big savings on football products from boots to balls!
With Mark Hughes taking the hot-seat at Manchester City, one must wonder if it is the correct decision for the Welshman. It’s good for City, that’s for sure.
Hughes had taken Blackburn as far as he possibly could. They are now one of the most difficult teams in the Premier League to beat and a very aggressive yet talented side. Much like Hughes himself.
Money will be of no concern to the former Manchester United and Barcelona star but the heavy weight of Thaksin Shinawatra’s demands may cause an uneasy tension between the two.
Already Shinawatra is courting the possibility of Ronaldinho and his Brazilian countryman Jo arriving at Eastlands. Both will cost huge amounts of money but that isn’t the problem. Hughes is very much his own man and will undoubtedly want to do things his way. Why wouldn’t he?
Perhaps Sparky has demanded reassurances from the former Thai Prime Minister that his new job will not be undermined by the owner signing players whom HE wants in the side. If, and it’s a big if, Ronaldinho decides to swap the Nou Camp for the City of Manchester Stadium Hughes could have no real complaints. The Brazilian is finished in Spain and desperately needs a new focus in life - otherwise his incredible talent will be lost to the world. Shinawatra is showing his determination to succeed but at the same time displaying a complete ineptitude in business dealings at a football club. Hughes will not appreciate this.
It’s a crying shame that the owner of Manchester City simply does not know how to conduct himself in the very different world of football. Yet he will not be told and there could be many more uncomfortable moments for the fans, players and ultimately Hughes in the months to come.
Roman Abramovich may stick his nose in occasionally at Stamford Bridge but it is rarely made public - and apart from Andrei Shevchenko he has stayed out of team affairs.
Shinawatra is public and not in any way reserved in his comments regarding thoughts on his new toy. Why should he be? Well, football ain’t politics and the man may make more enemies than friends over the next few years.
It’s another step up the managerial ladder for Hughes and the next part of his learning curve. Perhaps Chelsea would have been a better choice but I do not think Abramovich really wanted him. Hughes is still not high profile enough for Chelsea right now.
I just can’t see the Shinawatra-Hughes relationship lasting or being a successful one for both parties. In fact, I do not believe that anyone in his right mind would take that job on. It’s already a poisoned chalice and the limited patience that Shinawatra obviously holds will grate on Hughes.
Totally blinded, Shinawatra believes that City will be challenging for the title next season. The pressure on Hughes (and not from the fans) will be intense and he will not relish or enjoy this side of the lucrative package he has been given.
Whether he realises it or not, Shinawatra has created a dark cloud that hangs over Manchester City and has developed into a lasting uncertainty over his credentials to run a football club. He won’t take a back seat and allow the people in the know to get on with things - and this would cause disruption in any job or walk of life.
People in general do not like others peering over their shoulder with an axe which could fall at any time. It creates tension and nerves, which in turn festers to minimise the productivity and happiness of an employee.
I can only see discontent and bizarre goings on at the home of a club with great and proud fans.And I worry for football in general if this trend continues.
Comments (60)
by John Wild on June 06, 2008
I believe the person you are forgetting is Garry Cook. As Dr. T's appointed CEO he shares his vision. It was Mr Cook who convinced Mark Hughes that this was the challenge he needed. From what I can see neither Cook or Hughes are anybodys fools and I predict good times ahead for the Citizens. Please dont be so negative, it's about time we had something to cheer about and I for one am enjoying the prospects for next season.
by Grumpypants, Manchester on June 06, 2008
Yawn.... You're a few days late on all this neg press. Some of your comments are extremely far from the truth and you've obviously not done much research. This article is made from selective cut and pastes; yet another blinkered view from someone who comes off as an armchair rag. How about some unique journalism instead of this regurgitated pap?
by Matt Diablo on June 06, 2008
Complete and utter garbage you silly fool-CITY ARE ON THE MARCH dipstick. "He won't sit back and let people in the know take care of things" ? Whats Gary Cook doing there then you cluless moron-pathetic journalism to the extreme!!
by mick on June 06, 2008
...rag
by Jack Millington on June 06, 2008
In the press confrence to introduce MH to City, Cook (the executive chairman) was at pains to point out that Mark Hughes had been consulted before they continued the pursuit of Jo and Ronaldhino. Get your facts right before you fgo into print with your anti city vitriol you red muppet.
by Blend on June 06, 2008
Hello, my name is Gerald Mclaughlin , I'm going to write a completely ridiculous, outrageous non factual piece of crap to stir up opinion in the hope of getting some traffic.
by Jay blue on June 06, 2008
Gerald, you have not got 2 clues to put together have you, bitter little boy spitting his dummy out. Grow up & get with the program.
by Johnno on June 06, 2008
We wouldnt have it any other way and it keeps lazy journos in a job.
by Baldy Bouncer on June 06, 2008
Obviously a Rag!! Stick to cooking!!
by MCFC on June 06, 2008
Unbelievably bad journalism, you clearly are neither well informed or well read on the appointment of Mark Hughes at MCFC. Your views are biased and dare I say you are probably a 'fan' of the football club from just outside Manchester. Can I suggest you read the excellent piece of journalism in the Mail online in which Dr Thaksin explains his vision and business plan. You may also wish to be aware of the apppointment of Mr Garry Cook (former Nike Executive) as Executive Chairman, just in case as you say ' run his complete ineptitude at business dealings within a football club.' Still shaking my head now !!
by Paul Rudders on June 06, 2008
I agree with all the coments already made. Has the writer of this tripe seen any of the recent intervierws by Cook or Hughes. Looks like someone with no story writing the first thing that comes into their head. Or a rag. Making no sense as usual.
I'd stick to cooking if I was you mate
by Blendda Myfanwy on June 06, 2008
This is amazing. Gerald, let me guess that you are an unemlpoyed nobody who sits at home writing shite like this to stir up opinion. "Shinawatra is showing his determination to succeed but at the same time displaying a complete ineptitude in business dealings" This simply one of the best sentances I have ever seen! The man who developed Shin Corp from nothing and sold half of it for $1.88 billion is an inept businessman. Amazing, truely amazing!
by Gerald McLaughlin on June 06, 2008
Sorry, I admit, that was a really poor, ill-formed, lazy piece of journalism
by MCFC Follow Up on June 06, 2008
Gerald, I have commented previously, and not surprisingly you are generating a lot of responses from bemused City fans. I would be interested in hearing some response from you in defence of your 'article' It maybe that we are all missing the poine here ??
by Tim on June 06, 2008
Of course, he is completely inept in business! Tha's why he has 800m in th bank... The only reason this will not work is if wankers like you... blah blah
Couldn't vote as I could not find the 'Johnny No-stars' ranking. Please add.
by OB1 on June 06, 2008
Another editorial that's up to the usual Sportingo standard. Thank goodness Frank expects higher standards of City. Quite why you think that no one in their right mind would take on a £2m a year job managing a football team is beyond me. As others have mentioned this is a poorly researched and cliched piece of work e.g. Frank clearly does not think City will be challenging for the title next season.
Gerald... I'll tell you what... I'll bet you 50,000 quid that Man city make it into the top 4 within the next two season with Hughes... Got the balls? Me thinks not
by Tom on June 06, 2008
How is firing a world class manager and replacing him with second grade goon a step up in anyones book?! Haha on us.
Obviously I didn't mean that previous comment really
by Harold Skintyres on June 06, 2008
Flip burgers do you? I'd stick to that you rag muppet.
Frank has a lot more that £800m that was just what was frozen. His estimated net worth is approximately $3 billion
by gerald McLaughlin on June 06, 2008
......that wasn,t me with Man Utd crest above.I aint a Red fan.I,m a Celtic fan.The above piece was an opinion.I dont need facts, figures and highly excited Man City fans to stop me from forming an opinion.I,ll take that bet on Tim.Just wait and see what happens next season.I,ll do an article mid-season hows that?
by archie on June 06, 2008
I think you are forgetting Mark Hughes and Garry Cook are nobody,s fool and they have an understanding of what the future may hold for Man City which i am sure you most certainly not privy to
See us destroy you at OT next season.......
by Herbert Herbert on June 06, 2008
I'm training to be a journalist and I think I could already teach Gerald a thing or too. He's betrayed the 3 rules: 1) Check your facts, 2) Check your facts and 3) Check your facts. What a muppet.