Home > Football > West Ham and Manchester City show how to deal with FIFA's 6 plus 5 foreigner rule
by gerald mclaughlin on 28 June 2008
Email this Article (4) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Big savings on football products from boots to balls!
The discussions and debates on whether the English Premier League would benefit from a foreign players rule have been rumbling for quite some time now. On May 30 this year, FIFA voted in favour of the six-plus-five rule, with president Sepp Blatter hoping this will be in place for the season 2012-13.
The continuing dominance of English teams in the Champions League has perhaps stung the rest of Europe into such actions. The legalities are the main argument, with the FA quite rightly stating that this decision contravenes European law. Yet many believe that it would be to the benefit of the game in general.
Another view, of course, would be that English dominance in Europe is not going down too well with everyone else. The juggernaut that is the EPL and its money and attraction means that almost every club in the top tier of English football can afford players and their astronomical wages with far more ease than many other clubs throughout the world.
Is it sour grapes from the rest? Would it be good for English international football? Would it make the Champions League a far more level playing field? Did this year's final in Moscow just annoy everyone else because it was two English teams in the final? Who knows. There certainly wasn't this hullabaloo when Valencia and Real Madrid contested the final a few years back. Or are the English just being paranoid?
I think if you asked the top four teams' fans in England what they would rather have, a decent run in the Champions League or a successful national team, the former would be a winner every time. Moving further down the league table, I genuinely believe that fans would rather see a successful national team. But why can't both be achieved? Italy can do it, Spain can do it.
With plenty of time before this rule is implemented, every club in England has to make sure that they have a decent batch of youngsters coming through the ranks. Quite frankly, most teams already do. The likes of West Ham and Manchester City have some tremendous young players yet these same boys are hunted by the big money-earners and the promising players are obviously tempted by big bucks. Who can blame them?
It has been clear for some time that changes were to be made. Change happens and usually for the good but some teams will initially suffer, although, in all honesty they should not. Much can be blamed on the dismal performances of the national team but I really don't think it is the clubs or standard of the players talents who shoulder the blame. It is the people in charge in England.
All I can see is a bunch of arrogant pen-pushers who really don't have a clue about running the most important part of English sport. Yes football is the main sport in Britain and no-one can deny that. The national pastime is a disgrace. It is the same in Scotland. These people in charge do not seem to have a clue; football is not their life and it shows in the decision-making.
Only time will tell if this new rule will be of any significance. I for one think that it will.
Comments (4)
by tom city fan on June 28, 2008
Where does the headline fit in with this article? there is about an sentance on west ham and city?
by Paul Also City Fan on June 29, 2008
Tom - See Page 2!
by Lance Poll on June 30, 2008
Of course this is an attack by all those foreigners on the brilliant management of the EPL. The EPL has grabbed the spotlight by focused strategies. The fans want to see the best players and aren't really bothered where they were born. In fact if they are from abroad that adds interest and mystique. The EPL has seen this and become the best league to follow and watch. At the same time those foreigners managing outside of UK have been paying off referees to be successful as all the top teams have been doing in Italy for years and also, but not yet exposed, in Spain. The fans in those countries know better than us that their leagues are corrupt and run in backrooms. They are boring. Look at Spain: it will continue for decades as a boring contest between Barcelona and Real Madrid, with no change. Italy is just the same with Inter and AC Milan. Instead of being petty small-minded politicians envious of the EPL success, these foreigner manipulators should just get their act together. Right now everyone can see that they are just a bunch of moaning losers.
by Scabby Babbage on June 30, 2008
I second Lance's comments. Fifa and Uefa have been pro-Italian for as long as I can remember. When the fighting happened between Liverpool and Juventus in the eighties it was the English clubs (ALL English clubs!) that got banned for five years. That ended English dominance in Europe and for the next ten years Spain and Italy were dominant. The English presence took a long time to come back but now it is, they want to ban foreigners! Laughable, after all the Van Bastens, Maradonas, Mattheus's and Ruud Gullits that have spent their careers in Italy. Anyway, the horse has bolted. There's too much money in the premier league now for it to lose a fight with fifa. If fifa want to ban all players who play in England from the world cup, that will only harm their world cup.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
England must scrape the bottom and turn to Spurs for wide-left salvation
Spurs go one better than Barcelona in Krakow – now bring on Hull City!
Ouch! The TOP TEN freak sports injuries
Arsenal Champions League Chelsea Cricket news Euroleague Fantasy football Football news Formula 1 Liverpool Manchester United NBA Newcastle United Premier League Sports news Tottenham Hotspur Transfer rumours Twenty20 UEFA UEFA Champions League
© SportBuzz All rights reserved 2008 Sportingo- Sports News & Sports Articles site. Sportingo delivers fresh sports news and analysis by fans-Football News, Tennis News, Rugby Union News, Rugby League, Cricket News, Cycling News, Basketball News and other Sports TV. XML Sitemap 2008.