Home > Football > Forget Rio at Manchester United and Chelsea's Terry - Gerrard's the man to lead Liverpool AND England!
Fabio Capello is ready to appoint a permanent captain for the national side - and it's the Anfield contender who wins this Sportingo writer's vote.
by Iestyn Stevens on 19 July 2008
Email this Article (14) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Big savings on football products from boots to balls!
Depending on who you believe, about half of England could be a captain, from Wayne Rooney or David James to Gareth Barry or Michael Owen; but there are only four serious candidates for one of the most sought-after roles in English football.
Manchester United’s Rio Ferdinand is captain at Old Trafford, but has a shady history that includes not turning up for drugs tests and harassing referees. He might be good at organising a defence and was instrumental in leading his club to the Premier League and Champions League in 2007/08, but is he really the kind of person you want leading England permanently? A captain should set an example to the team and to the kids at grassroots level who look up to him. He’s not the kind of role model you want for the kids of the future. Everyone should be given a second chance, and Ferdinand has had that with Man United, but this is England, and a permanent captain he is not.
John Terry is the current Chelsea captain and was England skipper under Steve McClaren. He might organise the line well, and is passionate about what he does, but he’s worse than Ferdinand for hounding referees and trying to intimidate opponents. He might not be the ringleader as he once was, but he’s still involved in it far too much. Again, I feel it comes down to what message the England captain should be giving to the grassroots. He might be right for Chelsea, but he’s not right for England and was lucky to be made captain by McClaren. There are times when he just doesn’t seem to care about England the way he does Chelsea, and that’s not what you want.
The biggest mistake LA Galaxy’s David Beckham made was to step down from the captaincy. I find it difficult to accept that anyone who wants to captain England can give it up that way. His attitude on the pitch is certainly better than Ferdinand and Terry, and his technical ability and leadership is there - after all he did lead England for 58 games. But age is against him and I can’t see him playing too many more games for England when there are talented youngsters more than capable of replacing him down the right, and because of that he won’t become permanent captain.
Liverpool’s Steven Gerrard is the man I feel should be England captain. He’s a player who can make things happen and leads by example - and a good example at that. You just have to look at the way he’s led Liverpool since 2003 to see how good a captain he is; the passion with which he plays, and how much of an inspiration he is to his team-mates. He has been disappointing in a number of games for England over the years, notably at Euro 2004, but name me a player who hasn’t been disappointing for England at any time.
Sir Alex Ferguson said earlier this year that experience is important when looking for a captain, at the same time suggesting that Ferdinand has the experience after captaining United, but Terry has been captain longer than him, as has Beckham, and Gerrard even longer at Liverpool. He’s been tossed all across the midfield by Sven-Goran Eriksson and Steve McClaren, played as a second striker and even had a stint at right back, and while he will give his all for you, Gerrard needs to be pulling the strings from the centre of midfield.
He will be the best choice for Capello, it will make him a better player, and with the responsibilities of leadership he will lift the entire England side. He’s going to be around for a few good years to come and after the disappointment of not qualifying for Euro 2008 I expect he would at least lead England to the 2010 World Cup and Euro 2012.
Comments (14)
by Nick Hoppers on July 19, 2008
.....whenever he's captained England he's been pretty rubbish, and nowhere near the leader he is for Liverpool? Most evident when we lost to Croatia, and ultimately failed to qualify for Euro 2008. In that match Gerrard not only showed next to no leadership but also had an absolute shocker. Like most England players, Gerrard shows a fraction of the passion for his Country that he displays for his club.
by Ian Cook on July 19, 2008
It would be between Gerrard & Ferdinand and I have to go with your choice of Gerrard. The 2005 final v AC Milan & 2006 FA Cup final v West Ham are just 2 reasons why he would be the best man for the job. He has been a great captain for Liverpool and he is the first player you would look to if things were going wrong in a match. Passionate, determined and very private OFF the pitch would also contribute to him being the perfect choice.
by Ian on July 19, 2008
.....whenever he's captained England he's been pretty rubbish, and nowhere near the leader he is for Liverpool? Most evident when we lost to Croatia, and ultimately failed to qualify for Euro 2008. In that match Gerrard not only showed next to no leadership but also had an absolute shocker.
by Nick on July 19, 2008
Gerrard was the captain in that match, yes the team as a whole were poor, but at no point did Gerrard up his own game or show any of the leadership qualities he displays week in week out for Liverpool. When Becks was dropped as captain, I was a strong advocate for Gerrard to take over, he's had his chances and never risen to the occasion.
by chris holmes on July 19, 2008
I think it's a really tough decision between Stevie and JT for who is best qualified but I would give the edge to stevie because I don't think taking the armband away from JT will make any difference to his game, he will still marshal the defence without being captain. Then Stevie is free to lead from further up the pitch.
by jobo on July 19, 2008
Most England fans are thick. Which players receive most stick for England? Crouchie (got booed tut tut tut), Gerrard and Lampard. Wanna know how hypocritical this is... Have a guess who have been England's most regular goalscorers in last 2 years - yep, you guessed it - Crouchie, Gerrard and Lampard. The England fans that dish out the dirt are the ones who support the lower realms of english football - e.g. the championship, div 1 and div 2. I agree with Franz Beckenbaur - 'Gerrard is the worlds greatest football leader'.
The 11 players who started the game consisted of some poor to average players. Bridge, Lescott, Campbell & Carson. Even Superman would have difficulty inspiring some of them. Take into account that Steve McClaren was clueless and seemed to have no idea of what he was doing at anytime during his reign and more often than not, his players also looked like they were clueless. No player under McClaren who wore the armband ever looked like a natural leader. Capello has guts, he proved it by leaving out the overrated Frank Lampard and Gerrard has looked a much better player in the games without him. Capello has given numerous players an opportunity to show leadership qualities and whoever gets the nod will be a far better Captain under Capello than at anytime during the McClaren era, Gerrard included. I'm not a Liverpool fan but there is no better candidate at this moment in time than Steven Gerrard. The comments about Ferdinand's & Terry's harassment of referees is not what Capello likes so based on that alone, Gerrard should get the nod.
by Declan Young on July 19, 2008
I think Nick is trying to say football is a one man game. Whenever the team loss we should blame the captain (only when Gerarad is the captain) eventhough the manager is clueless and the other 10 players are playing equally poor.
I think people just have their preferred choice based on who they support. Liverpool fans want Gerrard, Man Utd fans want Ferdinand, Chelsea fans want Terry and no doubt Newcastle fans want Owen as England captain. As a Portsmouth fan it would be easy for me to say give it to Crouch or Defoe but we all know THAT would be wrong. My thoughts are based purely as a neutral and for football reasons. I say it again, there is no better choice than Mr Gerrard. (and Crouchie as vice captain ;) )
by Stevo Jones on July 19, 2008
Nick:-Spot on. Although you have committed the cardinal sin of having the nerve to criticise Stevie Me. When he inspires Liverpool to CL or F.A cup win, he's god, when he does nothing to inspire his country, it's everyone else's fault. If it had been Beckham captaining England when we went out to Croatia, and he'd put in a performance as dire as Gerrards, the same people posting messages here wouldn't hesitate to lambaste him. Declan, clearly he isn't saying football is a one man game. Grow up.
by Yogi on July 19, 2008
Look Iestyn mate simple question for you. Why are you talking about this stuff when you're Welsh? Surely to god you like most of us Welsh and I'm sure Scots and Irish and probably quite a lot of English are sick to death of the England football team being the only thing that matters in the world. Sorry England fans but you buy into this we're the greatest blah blah blah rubbish from your media. Forget it you're crap in comparision to a lot of teams out there, sure Capello may change it but it's unlikely. No doubt theres some of you going we'd have won Euro 2008 if we'd been there, just like you were going to win World Cup 2006, 2002, 2998, 1994, 1990, 1986, 1982, 1978, 1974 1970. At the end of the day the Euro's were great and one of the reasons was that most teams wanted to play unlike the British teams. And before any Englishman goes on about another Welshman putting England down it's this simple WALES ARE SHITE end of but we accept that and get on with it, pity that England who are much better than Wales but still poor can't.
If it had been Beckham captaining England when we went out to Croatia, and he'd put in a performance as dire as Gerrards, the same people posting messages here wouldn't hesitate to lambaste him.
by aliva aliva on July 20, 2008
heyhey...we'r talking about the captain of england and it's not a joke.england needs a captain who's enthusiastic capable of leading the team and most importantly win things.if you look to the past few years rio's been in the back line manu and for england an done pretty much well.he's won the premier ship,european chmps' cup,fa cup...etc...an hes the one who late goal won the match aginst liverpool few years back.in my view gerrard got nothing much to show and better young star coming in midfld seems the edn of gerrard sooner rather than later.for rio theres no one such to compete in defence accept sergio ralmos of spain...so rio's the one for me,manu and for england.
by oyewole femi on July 22, 2008
i think Rio will be the best captain
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
England must scrape the bottom and turn to Spurs for wide-left salvation
Spurs go one better than Barcelona in Krakow – now bring on Hull City!