Home > Football > All change at Spurs - is this the shake-up that will make all the difference?
by Pete Lyons-McCarthy on 07 August 2008
Email this Article (14) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Big savings on football products from boots to balls!
So the exit and entrance doors at White Hart Lane have been turning in equal measure. Juande Ramos and Gus Poyet clearly have a vision for Spurs and Daniel Levy has backed his manager with more funds.
If it all goes the shape of pear, the one person who the fans cannot blame is Levy, although he got his fingers well and truly scorched with last season's purchases. The chairman has once again sanctioned a spending programme designed to elevate Tottenham toward the Premier League top table. Fans of Newcastle and Everton must be envious when they read in the newspapers of yet another quality player arriving and another mediocre one departing.
This brings me to the million-dollar question. Obviously many of those who've left are inferior to those who have arrived, but have Spurs been a little too hasty in allowing two players in particular to leave? Steed Malbranque, for instance, is a tremendously under-rated player in my opinion, and even if not first choice would be a great player to hold in reserve, especially when the going gets tough.
Another imminent departure is Younes Kaboul. He should be given time to develop over another season and then re-assessed to see if he can cut the mustard, or establish for sure that he was another of Damian Comolli's expensive yet ineffectual purchases.
So now Spurs have a quality midfield with Englishmen prominent throughout the team. The purchases appear deliberate and calculated, and therefore are the choices of Ramos and Poyet. So no blame for failure on past managers or Comolli (which begs the question, what does he do, and can I do it better?).
David Bentley and Luka Modric SHOULD form a chalk-and-cheese partnership, alongside Jermaine Jenas and Didier Zokora, but where's the tenacity, where's the bite? In defence, Spurs have quality players on both flanks and in the centre, but ALL are injury-prone and there seems no cover of note should the treatment room beckon.
Heurelho Gomes is a purchase that, on paper, would have seemed essential, but also consider that he's the No.2 Brazilian - and their No.1 isn't all that marvellous, is he? Paul Robinson could have improved this season, of that I have no doubt. When you consider the calamities the Spurs defence endured early last season, it was no wonder his confidence suffered.
I believe if the team had been a little more industrious and tenacious in midfield last term, then you would have seen perhaps fewer goals, but a tighter outfit generally. This year we'll see if the Spurs faithful will once again sell out White Hart Lane and the team score a shed-load of goals but, more importantly, concede far fewer and retain the ball better. If those things are drilled into them, who knows?
As an early-season indicator I think the major success at Spurs this year will be Tom Huddlestone and the player most missed will be Malbranque, while the player least missed has to be Pascal Chimbonda.
But rumour has it that there are a few more yet to leave ... plus perhaps a few more to arrive. Still, not long now... tick, tock, tick, tock.
Comments (14) by theotheyid yid on August 07, 2008 Is there anything new or refreshing about this article? It's all old stuff we already know. The only newish is your opionion on us having a Brazilian No.2 goalie suggesting it's not good enough as he is not a no.1. Goalies are a different breed. It's mostly down to the manager and it doesn't make a no.2 keeper an inferior one. Was Clemmence inferior cos he was no.2 to Shilton? Lehmann was no.2 in Germany when he won the title at the Goon. Robbo was not even in the squad when England played Trinidad. Does it mean the kid from Posh who was called into the squad is better than Robbo? It's a bit of drivel if you ask me. by Declan Walker on August 07, 2008 It has a nice ring to it. Vey catchy. May sell one or two newspapers perhaps. Mr. Levy promised Ramos a 50M budget for the coming seaon. Lets see how he's used that. Firstly lets add the sales to the 'kitty' Robinson, Sunderland Trio, Keane. (3.5+16+19) so that gives Spurs a budget of 88.5 Million. Purchases: Modric, GdS, Gomes, Bentley, Bostock (15.8, 4.7, 7.8, 15, .7) That is 44 Million. Not even half of the kitty, and the 'Spending Spree' has only used up 6.5m of the oridanal budget. NB. Berbatov + Kaboul to make way (28+5). Please get your facts straight. Spurs have been on a spending spree, but the sales have basically covered the purchases. by name on August 07, 2008 "NB. Berbatov + Kaboul to make way (28+5)." 38 not 28. by Darren Dawson on August 07, 2008 Declan, do not forget we spent 30m of our kitty in January by Steve Smith on August 07, 2008 Good article. Not new but certainly a diiferent angle on a worry that I share with many Spurs fans.I agree that a team needs opposites and a balence between steel and skill. When we finished 4th I would argue that was the skill matched with the bite of Davids and Carrick. Who would argue against the bite that Keane installed into past ManUtd teams? Why with Mascherano already there are Liverpool after Barry? I do trust In Ramos but it is getting pretty late now and we do need some steel to back up the wonderful signings of Dos Santos and Modric. by steve smith on August 07, 2008 Before I get jumped on for the finishing 4th statement, I want to explain that in my opinnion we did in fact finsish 4th and were just robbed by a dodgy Lasagne by mike oconnor on August 07, 2008 I think since Sol Campell left a long tome ago to our near neighbours and Ledley king been out for much of last season we have been sufering very badly at the back. I think Paul Robinson has been sold because of sillly mistakes been made at the back last season.Hopefully Woodgate will stay injury free and we dont let in as many goals as we score fingures crossed. by Bingy Kelly on August 07, 2008 Even as we speak (type, then) there is a revolution of, rarely seen, optimism at WHL. We are gathering together a 'merry band' of some of the best, and not just budget basement either, and more attacking players. Modric will 'put to bed' the assertion that he is 'lightweight'. He will have a wealth of assistance in his 'corner' and EVEN the loss of RK will not damage our ATTACK/Goal Tally. The CD subject is a little more pressing BUT, there again, we are able to field (on a good day) a rear guard that would feature at ANY CL side. The whole squad is a vast improvement on previous seasons and, were it not for that Lasanga etc we would be in Arsenals 'berth' now and nobody would question our credentials. We might not have brought the quality of the current squad BUT....that is a discussion for another day? Sadly, even though we have shed many/most of the group that failed so unfortunately in 05/06 (Lasagna gate) we are in better shape now? The old 'Spurs' are gone and a new....fitter and more tactically astute team will soon take the field....The doubt will still be there, for a while at least, but I expect great things from THFC in 08/09....and it could be Manure, ArsenicAL, Chelski or Piddle pool, who should be checking their rear view mirrors? I hope so, for the good of Football....and for the good of Spurs, as a by product, maybe lol. COYS! by Jon on August 07, 2008 If you do the maths, its been one in, one out almost pound for pound. And if you prefer malbranque to modric, you need your head checked. by IFOR EVANS on August 07, 2008 Gunter has already performed in the central defender position for WALES! So should be able cover for King or Woodgate. by Declan Walker on August 07, 2008 To Darren Dawson........... Okay, true, we made fur signing. Lets indlude those into the 50m(or 43.5 this summer). Gilberto, Gunter, Woodgate, Hutton..(1.9,3,8,9)=21.9 M.. This means currently we have 21.6M left(before future sales). Fair enough. But, Defoe? Routledge? Murphy? (9,2,1)... +12. So we have 34.9M left.. Before sales off Berba, Kaboul, Lee, Boateng, Stalteri, ?Zokora?... So we Still have well over 50m to splash (as long as Berba bounces).. And we need it.. Nene, Corluka, Evans/Cuéllar , Arshavin, ?Ashton?.. We are very thin on the ground. COYS by Declan Walker on August 07, 2008 What I would like the Spurs team to look like come August 16(31..) GK. Gomes, Caser.. RB. Hutton, Gunter.. LB Gilberto, ?Assou-Ekotto?. CD. King, Woody, Corluka, Dawson, Evans.. CM. Jenas, Modric, Thudd, O'Hara, ?Zokora?.. RW. Bentley, Lennon.. LW. *Bale, Nene.. CF. Arshavin, dos Santos.. ST. Bent, ?Ashton?.. *Bale would be used as LB|LW. GdS as CF|LW. ?? I would like Zokora replaced with a better player. Maybe BAE too... Ashton could be good as a Back-Up ST. tall, goal getter... *Injury-prone, true. But maybe not been used as 1st 11 every game will give him time to get over his problems... Opinions??? by Pete Lyons-McCarthy on August 07, 2008 If you do the maths, its been one in, one out almost pound for pound. Where did I mention that I prefer Steed to Modric, having never seen Modric play in the premiership, I hold by judgement, but Steed would be a useful SQUAD member....Which is what I wrote!, also as regards maths 11 out and 6 in is a deficite of 5, at least it was when I went to school And if you prefer malbranque to modric, you need your head checked. by bat spur on August 08, 2008 Play Kaboul as an defensive midfelder, don´t buy anymore strikers, tell Berbs hes going nowhere for atleast a year, let Perkard play some games, spend good money on a world class centre back... Please enter E-mail accountPlease enter CommentThe text you have entered from the picture is not correct. Please try again. Add your comment here PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED First Name Last Name Email Show my email on site Heading Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment. Sport Select sport... All Sports American Football Aquatics Archery Athletics Australian Football Badminton Baseball Basketball Boxing Canoe/Kayak Cricket Cycling Darts Equestrian Extreme sports Fencing Field Hockey Football Golf Gymnastics Handball Horse Racing Ice Hockey Ice Skating Judo Mixed Martial Arts Motorsport Netball Pentathlon Rowing Rugby Rugby League Rugby Union Sailing Shooting Softball Table Tennis Taekwondo Tennis Triathlon Volleyball Weightlifting Wrestling League Choose league... Team Choose team... Comment * Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Comments (14)
by theotheyid yid on August 07, 2008
Is there anything new or refreshing about this article? It's all old stuff we already know. The only newish is your opionion on us having a Brazilian No.2 goalie suggesting it's not good enough as he is not a no.1. Goalies are a different breed. It's mostly down to the manager and it doesn't make a no.2 keeper an inferior one. Was Clemmence inferior cos he was no.2 to Shilton? Lehmann was no.2 in Germany when he won the title at the Goon. Robbo was not even in the squad when England played Trinidad. Does it mean the kid from Posh who was called into the squad is better than Robbo? It's a bit of drivel if you ask me.
by Declan Walker on August 07, 2008
It has a nice ring to it. Vey catchy. May sell one or two newspapers perhaps. Mr. Levy promised Ramos a 50M budget for the coming seaon. Lets see how he's used that. Firstly lets add the sales to the 'kitty' Robinson, Sunderland Trio, Keane. (3.5+16+19) so that gives Spurs a budget of 88.5 Million. Purchases: Modric, GdS, Gomes, Bentley, Bostock (15.8, 4.7, 7.8, 15, .7) That is 44 Million. Not even half of the kitty, and the 'Spending Spree' has only used up 6.5m of the oridanal budget. NB. Berbatov + Kaboul to make way (28+5). Please get your facts straight. Spurs have been on a spending spree, but the sales have basically covered the purchases.
by name on August 07, 2008
"NB. Berbatov + Kaboul to make way (28+5)." 38 not 28.
by Darren Dawson on August 07, 2008
Declan, do not forget we spent 30m of our kitty in January
by Steve Smith on August 07, 2008
Good article. Not new but certainly a diiferent angle on a worry that I share with many Spurs fans.I agree that a team needs opposites and a balence between steel and skill. When we finished 4th I would argue that was the skill matched with the bite of Davids and Carrick. Who would argue against the bite that Keane installed into past ManUtd teams? Why with Mascherano already there are Liverpool after Barry? I do trust In Ramos but it is getting pretty late now and we do need some steel to back up the wonderful signings of Dos Santos and Modric.
by steve smith on August 07, 2008
Before I get jumped on for the finishing 4th statement, I want to explain that in my opinnion we did in fact finsish 4th and were just robbed by a dodgy Lasagne
by mike oconnor on August 07, 2008
I think since Sol Campell left a long tome ago to our near neighbours and Ledley king been out for much of last season we have been sufering very badly at the back. I think Paul Robinson has been sold because of sillly mistakes been made at the back last season.Hopefully Woodgate will stay injury free and we dont let in as many goals as we score fingures crossed.
by Bingy Kelly on August 07, 2008
Even as we speak (type, then) there is a revolution of, rarely seen, optimism at WHL. We are gathering together a 'merry band' of some of the best, and not just budget basement either, and more attacking players. Modric will 'put to bed' the assertion that he is 'lightweight'. He will have a wealth of assistance in his 'corner' and EVEN the loss of RK will not damage our ATTACK/Goal Tally. The CD subject is a little more pressing BUT, there again, we are able to field (on a good day) a rear guard that would feature at ANY CL side. The whole squad is a vast improvement on previous seasons and, were it not for that Lasanga etc we would be in Arsenals 'berth' now and nobody would question our credentials. We might not have brought the quality of the current squad BUT....that is a discussion for another day? Sadly, even though we have shed many/most of the group that failed so unfortunately in 05/06 (Lasagna gate) we are in better shape now? The old 'Spurs' are gone and a new....fitter and more tactically astute team will soon take the field....The doubt will still be there, for a while at least, but I expect great things from THFC in 08/09....and it could be Manure, ArsenicAL, Chelski or Piddle pool, who should be checking their rear view mirrors? I hope so, for the good of Football....and for the good of Spurs, as a by product, maybe lol. COYS!
by Jon on August 07, 2008
If you do the maths, its been one in, one out almost pound for pound. And if you prefer malbranque to modric, you need your head checked.
by IFOR EVANS on August 07, 2008
Gunter has already performed in the central defender position for WALES! So should be able cover for King or Woodgate.
To Darren Dawson........... Okay, true, we made fur signing. Lets indlude those into the 50m(or 43.5 this summer). Gilberto, Gunter, Woodgate, Hutton..(1.9,3,8,9)=21.9 M.. This means currently we have 21.6M left(before future sales). Fair enough. But, Defoe? Routledge? Murphy? (9,2,1)... +12. So we have 34.9M left.. Before sales off Berba, Kaboul, Lee, Boateng, Stalteri, ?Zokora?... So we Still have well over 50m to splash (as long as Berba bounces).. And we need it.. Nene, Corluka, Evans/Cuéllar , Arshavin, ?Ashton?.. We are very thin on the ground. COYS
What I would like the Spurs team to look like come August 16(31..) GK. Gomes, Caser.. RB. Hutton, Gunter.. LB Gilberto, ?Assou-Ekotto?. CD. King, Woody, Corluka, Dawson, Evans.. CM. Jenas, Modric, Thudd, O'Hara, ?Zokora?.. RW. Bentley, Lennon.. LW. *Bale, Nene.. CF. Arshavin, dos Santos.. ST. Bent, ?Ashton?.. *Bale would be used as LB|LW. GdS as CF|LW. ?? I would like Zokora replaced with a better player. Maybe BAE too... Ashton could be good as a Back-Up ST. tall, goal getter... *Injury-prone, true. But maybe not been used as 1st 11 every game will give him time to get over his problems... Opinions???
by Pete Lyons-McCarthy on August 07, 2008
If you do the maths, its been one in, one out almost pound for pound. Where did I mention that I prefer Steed to Modric, having never seen Modric play in the premiership, I hold by judgement, but Steed would be a useful SQUAD member....Which is what I wrote!, also as regards maths 11 out and 6 in is a deficite of 5, at least it was when I went to school And if you prefer malbranque to modric, you need your head checked.
by bat spur on August 08, 2008
Play Kaboul as an defensive midfelder, don´t buy anymore strikers, tell Berbs hes going nowhere for atleast a year, let Perkard play some games, spend good money on a world class centre back...
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Tackling violence - the biggest stain on Italian football
The SEVEN secrets that turned Usain Bolt into a world-beater
How Zenit reach the zenith as Manchester United crashed...