Home > Rugby > Rugby Union > Lowering the All Black flag: Why New Zealand are nothing more than a circus act
by Greg Smith on 29 August 2008
Email this Article (15) Comments
The black flag was a well-known symbol of a ruthless combat, symbolising giving no quarter to the enemy. In contemporary 19th-century England it was also a symbol of the plague.
In picking this colour, New Zealanders showed their marketing savvy right from the outset of All Black rugby, intentionally striving for the emotive edge, even in their dress on the field.
At the other end of the spectrum, the Springboks picked green because they already had a supply of used jerseys. Within this contrast lies the ultimate eternal difference between rugby from South Africa and New Zealand.
New Zealanders were pay-for-play professionals from their very first tours, taking a portion of the stadium's gate earning and touring for incredibly long periods of time to make a buck while competing with Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show, the great circuses, freaks and escapologists.
They added value to their shows with a crowd pleasing ''haka'' and fine-tuned their image to maximise returns for their pockets. These were not country New Zealanders as you'd imagine when thinking of Colin Meads - the vast majority were city slickers and out-and-out professional showmen.
Through the Boer War South Africa divided itself. Language was a great divider and rugby union a miraculous uniter. Look at these teams circa 1900 and pick the English, South African and New Zealanders:
G. Gillet, B.A Wallace, D. McGregor, E.C Booth, G.E. Smith, H. Abott, H.D Thompson, E.J Harper, B. Deans, G. Nicholson, G.C Tyler, D.Gallaher, J.H O'Sullivan, B.I Johnston, B.Cunningham, F.Roberts, J.D Corbett
C. Campbell, C. J. Caborn, T. Marshall, H. Whitfield, H. A. Swepstone, J. Hunter, S. W. Widdowson, E. Luntley, J. F. Princep, N. C. Bailey, H. McNeil, E. C. Bambridge, M. Linsay, J. Sands, F. J. Sparks, F. W. Earp, T. Brindle and W. Mosforth.
P.J Stegmann, C.Z Krige, A.J Greef, B.J Daneel, R.Brooks, Morkel, Moore, Carolin, Burger, Marthys, Roos, Le Roux, Loubser, Becker, Miller, Burmeister, Jackson, Hirsch and De Villiers.
The first miracle of Springbok rugby is that it repaired a war-torn country. The second is that it remained, unlike New Zealand's ''shamateurs'', a strictly amateur game. The third is the diversity of the members (German, Dutch, French, English and Jewish).
They ALL had to earn a living and couldn't play rugby full-time like their Aussie and Kiwi counterparts. Roos was a school teacher, De Villiers a wine-farmer, Carolin a shop-keeper, Greef a mechanic and so on and so forth. Every last one was gainfully employed.
Cecil John Rhodes, the richest man in the world at the time, insisted the Springboks remain amateurs and paid for the costs of all tours to and from early South Africa. The Springboks didn't put on a show in England, their tours were short and to the point. No gate earning were taken by South Africans and they didn't perform ''hakas'' and other party tricks to amuse the crowds.
The Springboks behaved with decorum and never questioned the referee while the All Blacks were renowned for arguing and rough unheard-of tactics.
Today, the All Blacks boast an extravagent record of success and claim to be the greatest while the Springboks look on typically amused. They have done a grand job, and it all started with an all-black jersey and a catchy song-and-dance routine.
I'm sure Black Sabbath copied their act, but I'd rather choose the real thing than some show from the South Sea Islands, no matter how well they sell it.
Comments (15)
by Steven Bissett on August 29, 2008
Greg - The "Rocokoko Show" is about to hit our screens in the next couple of weeks accorkding to Graham Henry. Rocokoko is one of our best out-and-out professional showmen as you put it. Stay tuned. You'll love it!
by Paul Daly on August 29, 2008
This is an extremely far fetched article even for a one eyed boer like you. The all blacks have built up the most impressive win/loss record in the history of the game, by hard work and huge talent. It shocks me that at every opportunity you try to belittle that.
by Zim Bok on August 29, 2008
Funny that...I could've sworn that the Zimboks performed a Zulu war-cry up until 1928 (at the request of British audiences) just like the All Blacks. Apparently our pre-match "song-and-dance" matched our ability on the field and so was scrapped as our British paymasters found it rather boring...
by Boyrich on August 29, 2008
This article is bloody ridiculous. I know from my childhood growingup in NZ in the 1930s that every All Black had his working job, and played Rugby for the love of the game. This is the first time I have ever heard the AllBlacks described as professionals in the early years. Utter rubbish!
by D C Kiwi on August 30, 2008
I find it amusing how countries that can't consistently win against the All Blacks find it required journalism (if that is what it's called) to draw attention away from their own short commings in their nations rugby by attacking the All Blacks. Regardless of World Cup performance, the All Blacks have consistently been the best Rugby side in world rugby for generations. You only have to look at the lives of the great All Blacks prior to professionalism to understand that Rugby didn't line their pockets with gold, far from it. And in today's world, if money was the only motivation all of the NZ players would be playing in Europe. Yes, some of them are, but usually that comes after All Black goals have been achieved. You only have to look to Sunny Bill Williams (NRL) for understanding of the pride that goes along with an All Black jersey. Yes, he's playing in Europe for money, but has his eye on an All Black jersey for the next world cup. It's not just a jersey, it's so much more. Take a look at the This is NOT a jersey website for the sentiment of what it really means to wear that jersey. I will guarantee that you will never find that sort of feeling in any other rugby playing nation anywhere, period. The Haka shows a New Zealand identity and embraces the culture of the land. Yes, it is entertaining. One tradition that stands strong in sport is the playing of the national anthems. And somehow this is supposed to represent national pride. It's plain arrogance to suggest that anthems mean the same thing to every nation. The Haka adds far more meaning to NZ sport than the anthem. Any country is welcome to bring what represents them onto the field. Perhaps an Irish jig, a highland fling, or a Zulu war dance. Whatever floats your boat.
by Brad on September 04, 2008
Im a Wallabies fan and i love the haka its a spectacle in itself.
on September 05, 2008 on September 05, 2008
Hahah just when i think you cant sink any lower Greg, dont react i believe hes trying to get a reaction because hes got nothing else going on in his life. I honestly feel sorry for you young saffer you bring shame to your fellow saffers you make them look like fools.
by Keith Wawn on September 05, 2008
Zim Bok, as I have previously stated on this site, if we are now the “Zim Boks”, because we have a few ex Zimbabweans in our ranks, at least they share a border with us, which cannot be said of your Samoan, Tongan and Fijian imports, who are probably so far away from New Zealand, that they are in another time zone! So, if the same principal were applied to New Zealand, then you would have to be called the South Pacific Isles, or the South Pacific Invitation XV. How about the All Pacific Islands? It would be interesting to see how the All Blacks would fare with only homegrown talent in the side. Jibes aside, however, as I have stated in reaction to another article on this site, The All Blacks “remain a high quality rugby nation, and it is their rugby that has put New Zealand on the map. I love the haka, and so do most of South Africans. Youngsters growing up here consider it the pinnacle of their life’s achievement to face it, dressed in the green and gold of the Springboks. Look at Francois Steyn’s reaction every time he faces it. He grins because he loves the experience so much! The rugby world would be that much poorer without the mighty All Blacks brand”.
on September 06, 2008 on September 06, 2008
the vast vast majority or island "imports" were either born or raised from a young age in nz- hence nzers, trust a south african to only think along racial lines... thats what got you bunch into trouble the first time. You dont know what youre talking about.
by John Wrigley on September 06, 2008
I doubt actually that 'marketing' had much to do with the choice of the black strip decades ago and actually the Haka was not the show piece that it is today - so mate your article is rubbish.
by Keith Wawn on September 08, 2008
Crap! If they were born in NZ, they would be called New Zealanders, and the commentators would not refer to them as either former Fijians, Samoans, etc., so it’s you who doesn’t know what you are on about. Show me in my response where I raised the issue of race? Only you did. I named countries, not race groups.
by Ricky Kake on September 15, 2008
If the All Blacks are sooooo bad - what must this author think of his losing spring bok team? A team who finishes last again. A team who along with the Australians has only managed two mega wins in the Tri nations while the great All Blacks have won it 9 times! Ha.
by Brad on September 16, 2008
Rick mate we have won the world cup twice and so have the saffers and thats the biggest event in world rugby.. you guys can keep the tri nations i would hate to see the all blacks lose and suicide rates increase in nz i mean its all you have over there... hows the rain?
by Blair on September 23, 2008
Brad- I find your comment on suicide disturbing. Lets just hope no-one you know takes that option. Keith- Research your facts before you post. Pacific island people immigrated to NZ for a life away from the islands and the opportunities that came with it. We are called Kiwi's and are proud that we have so many different cultures under the one name. If the commentators were Kiwi's and calling our players Samoan, Fijian etc it would be out of respect for their heritage. If it was made by commentators from another nation then I am hoping it would be for a similar reason. Maybe the way you understood the comment needs looking at. If this message is falling on deaf ears then I invite you to come to NZ. You could try a hungi or a umu while drinking some cava.
by david savec on November 12, 2008
I have found a related page! Visit http://newfileengine.com/ I find it very useful when you try to find something quickly!
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Roman conquest lifts Spurs out of relegation zone - but Redknapp still needs to strengthen
Australia 20 New Zealand 34: Was this the biggest Rugby League World Cup upset of all time?