Home > Rugby > Rugby Union > Top referee joins the All Blacks? This Springbok fan isn't surprised!
by Greg Smith on 05 September 2008
Email this Article (4) Comments
You'd think many things have changed since citizens of Rome witnessed gladiators get the thumbs-up or thumbs-down from an omnipotent emperor like Caesar or Nero.
New Zealand's rugby union this week showed how little things have in reality changed within international rugby union since these days when people were thrown to the lions at the Colosseum.
Emperor Justinian is credited with justice itself, promoting written laws which saw the emperor's powers seperated from that of an independent judiciary. This today is the cornerstone of every fair nation on the planet and has been adopted in the administration of most fair sports like the olympics and football.
Rugby union is unfortunately one of those barbarian rogue sports which defies justice like a hip-shooting cowboy in the Wild West. Without pointing fingers, New Zealand are major culprits here and they have, in my humble opinion, shot the sheriff AND the deputy within this analogy when it comes to ensuring maintaining the All Blacks' spot as the mythical ''fastest guns'' in rugby.
This is the NZRU announcement that's got my goat: "Top international referee Lyndon Bray has today announced his retirement from all rugby to take up a role with the New Zealand Rugby Union as its new High Performance Referee Manager."
What do you make of that?
Well, I've plenty of questions but think more importantly this confirms my suspicions that Emperor Justinian's separation of powers principles have not been seen or taken root in the realm of rugby union.
Referees are pawns in rugby union and this floor-crossing by Bray shows exactly where they slot into the greater scheme of things. Compensation for services rendered, golden parachutes and golden handshakes spring to mind. Bray is an example of a referee whose services to the NZRU are being rewarded with a top job within ''the organisation''.
In South Africa we've seen plenty of this where, for example, Reserve Bank officials legislate in favour of billion dollar profits for major international corporations and then suddenly appear on their boards of directors. This move by Bray, to me, is exactly that.
The International Referee Panel of the International Rugby Board should be a strictly independent entity with an unbridgable divide separating it from national rugby unions. I'm shocked that the NZRU can be so brazen about their close relationship with Bray.
With Bray handing on his one-eyed tips and tricks to another generation of referees we're assured of at least another decade of horrendous refereeing from New Zealand and Australia.
Comments (4)
by eammon on September 05, 2008
Ummm, I think the development you’re commenting on is the NZRU’s hiring of a local retired ref to train New Zealand referees primarily for the domestic competition. Sounds pretty fair to me. Bray has clearly resigned as a member of the IRB refereeing panel. Taking that aside for a moment...you are aware that referees aren't allowed to referee games involving their own country, right? I mean I know South Africa profited from that cosy hometown referee scenario when it was in effect, but their mediocre home record in recent seasons should have alerted you to the fact that's now been corrected. Given that Bray no longer contributes to the IRB refereeing panel and given that New Zealand referees can't referee New Zealand games anyway, I can't quite see what your point is here. I can tell you think you have one by the bitter tone. Not pointing any fingers, but you are suffering from paranoid delusions.
by John Dennis on September 05, 2008
Sometime one needs to take a step back from ones self and think......do I actually know what it is that I am talking about? Quite clearly not as the previous comments from eammon state how could he of been any benefit to the AB's camp? I think someone has fallen off the wrong side of the World Cup winning team and decided to take a bite at a country with about 15% of the population of SA decided that they are better than us (excluding the world cup of course) and decided to take a pop at our fair nation. I can assure you pal you have got it so very wrong. When Jonathan Kaplan retires and decides to do something similar with SA, will you be happy when other rugby playing nations decide to write such pants in the newspapers? I think not and I am looking forward to the day when this happens and another nation publishes some as mediocre as the publication! If SA could just get rid of the misconception that everyone has something more than them, then and only then will you actually understand that Kiwi's like SA and that is that. Be quite harden-up and it will be fine. Oh and how is your new coach getting on????
by Ben Blair on September 06, 2008
Is this 'article' supposed to be a piss take? It sounds like a drunken fan slurring over his pint moaning about the most ridiculous thing. Seriously there must be better things to write about surely?
by mike julian on October 24, 2008
pot calling the kettle black when you look at the republic's history regarding referees
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
How Graeme Smith cast agony aside and proved he is cricket's Captain Courageous
Manchester United v Chelsea: Stand by for drama at the Theatre of Dreams
Has Walter Smith finally lost the plot at Rangers?
Arsenal Champions League Chelsea Cricket news Euroleague Fantasy football Football news Formula 1 Liverpool Manchester United NBA Newcastle United Premier League Sports news Tottenham Hotspur Transfer rumours Twenty20 UEFA UEFA Champions League
© SportBuzz All rights reserved 2008 Sportingo- Sports News & Sports Articles site. Sportingo delivers fresh sports news and analysis by fans-Football News, Tennis News, Rugby Union News, Rugby League, Cricket News, Cycling News, Basketball News and other Sports TV. XML Sitemap 2008.