Home > Rugby > Rugby Union > All Black magic dominates rugby union's World XV for 2008
by James Mortimer on 03 December 2008
Email this Article (8) Comments
The International Rugby Board will hopefully not select a 2008 World XV, because it would be filled with endless consternation and debate.
For while Shane Williams is without a doubt the premier wing in world rugby, it is somewhat singular to name him the best player in the world when overlooking men such as Richie McCaw, Sergio Parisse, Matt Giteau and John Smit, who are all of vital importance to their teams.
But despite the ruthless assessments now under way of nations such as England, the game is blessed with an abundance of genuine superstars and game breakers. Let’s look at the team I would select...
The custodian position of fullback belongs to New Zealand's Mils Muliaina (Waikato, 68 Test caps, 24 tries), who has benefited from playing in position and not being challenged by the likes of Leon MacDonald. Captaining Waikato this season, his dependability has increased and his positional play is unmatched. He is now earning comparisons with Christian Cullen and George Nepia.
Lee Byrne of Wales deserves back-up spot. He has had an outstanding season both in the Six-Nations and autumn internationals.
At wing we of course see the inclusion of Shane Williams (Ospreys, 59 Test caps, 44 tries), who has been in sparkling form, his dancing feet even making the likes of Bryan Habana look ordinary. He broke Gareth Thomas’s try scoring record for Wales this season.
New Zealand's Sitiveni Sivivatu (Waikato, 34 Test caps, 24 tries) just pips Peter Hynes and Cedric Heymans for the second wing spot. Featuring in 13 Tests in 2008, his consistency over the All Blacks' end-of-season tour earned his spot.
At outside centre we select Stirling Mortlock (Brumbies, 74 Test caps, third-highest point scorer in Australian history), who finished the season at inside centre but is no doubt the best No.13 in the game, closely followed by the silky Ireland captain, Brian O’Driscoll.
The position of inside centre sees us blessed with three world-class players, but All Black Ma’a Nonu (Wellington, 33 Test caps, 11 tries) makes the team after not only an outstanding end-of-season tour, but a revelation of a season where he has looked twice the player. He just pips Jean de Villiers of South Africa and Welshman Gavin Henson, both equally world-class players.
The crucial position of fly-half goes to Dan Carter (Canterbury, 59 Test caps, third highest point scorer in New Zealand history), who at 26 could go on to become the greatest player of all time. Regarded by many as the most complete No.10 the world has ever seen. Back-up spot goes to Australia's Matt Giteau, who is as brilliant individually, but has yet to control games as Carter has done.
At scrum-half we see much depth from the All Blacks and Springboks, but Scotland's Mike Blair (Edinburgh, 50 Test caps, 5 tries) has had such a strong season behind an average Scotland pack that he is being tipped to captain the British Lions in 2009. Nominated for World Player of the Year.
From the back of the scrum, at No.8 we see outstanding Italian captain Sergio Parisse (Stade Francais, capped since 2002), who just pips Rodney So’oialo and up-and-coming Welshman Andy Powell. Parisse's ability in the loose and interplay around the field is a large part of why the Azzurri both as a team and a scrum are becoming genuine top contenders.
At open-side flanker, we of course pay homage to New Zealand's Richie McCaw (Canterbury, 70 Tests, 14 tries), who is unchallenged as not only the best in his position but is becoming a remarkable and formidable captain. However, there are quality sevens in world rugby, with Australia's George Smith and Martyn Williams of Wales both brilliant fetchers.
At blind-side flanker, the menace of South Africa's Schalk Burger (Western Province, 49 Tests, 10 tries) is unequalled as a destructive player. He narrowly pips the French tackling machine Thierry Dusautoir to the post.
The tall timbers of lock feature Ali Williams (Auckland, 61 Tests, 7 tries) notable for being the only All Black to feature in all 15 games of the 2008 season. He has relished the opportunity of being senior lock and has all but eliminated New Zealand’s problems at the lineout.
Despite being criticised for his work rate, South Africa's Victor Matfield (Blue Bulls, 80 Tests, 5 tries) is unequalled as the world’s premier lineout jumper. Matfield this year became the first international captain to beat the All Blacks at home since Martin Johnson.
The big men of the prop ranks are first represented by New Zealand's Tony Woodcock (Auckland, 49 Tests, 5 tries) who as loosehead is unrivalled possibly as the best in the world. Woody caused significant problems for the Wallaby, Welsh, English and Irish scrums this year.
The bolter for the world team is Scotland prop Euan Murray (Northampton, 25 Tests, 2 tries), who has had a remarkable 2008 allowing the Scots to dominate the Puma packs, and then causing an All Black second XV huge problems. Feted for a British Lions berth.
Finally, at hooker, despite being switched to prop, we see South Africa's World Cup winning captain and hooker John Smit (Clermont-Auvergne, 81 Tests, 4 tries). The most capped Springbok captain of all time, he narrowly pips his Tri-Nations rivals of Stephen Moore, Andrew Hore and Keven Mealamu.
WORLD XV: 15 -M. Muliaina (New Zealand), 14 – S. Williams (Wales), 13 – S. Mortlock (Australia), 12 – M. Nonu (New Zealand), 11 – S. Sivivatu (New Zealand), 10 – D. Carter (New Zealand), 9 – M. Blair (Scotland), 8 – S. Parisse (Italy), 7 – R. McCaw (New Zealand), 6 – S. Burger (South Africa), 5 – A. Williams (New Zealand), 4 – V. Matfield (South Africa), 3 – E. Murray (Scotland), 2 – J. Smit (South Africa), 1 – T. Woodcock (New Zealand).
SECOND XV: 15 – L. Byrne (Wales), 14 – C. Heymans (France), 13 – B. O’Driscoll (Ireland), 12 – J. De Villiers (South Africa), 11 – P. Hynes (Australia), 10 – M. Giteau (Australia), 9 – J. Cowan (New Zealand), 8 – R. So’oialo (New Zealand), 7 – G. Smith (Australia), 6 – T. Dusautoir (France), 5 – N. Sharpe (Australia), 4 – B. Botha (South Africa), 3 – T. Mtawarira (South Africa), 2 – A.Hore (New Zealand), 1 – L. Faure (France).
Comments (8)
by Greg Smith on December 04, 2008
The eternal rugby union conundrum - a good 'star' player vs better player (without the stardom)..... I've met plenty rugby players that would/could have made the GREATEST stars look ordinary... the Kiwi's and Wallaby's are GREAT showman and like with cricket play the field game and PLAY the audience... creating extra STAR value... if I had to pick a World XV to play Mars(for death stakes) I'd pick a different XV and the STARS generally lauded with praise by the like of James Mortimer and your average rugby pseudo-expert wouldn't crack it... for eg... Frans Steyn is PURE talent... secured at Fullback he'd run rings around Mils Muliaina... My EARTH vs Mars XV would also include MORE genuine players and less acting player-stars from New Zealand and Australia... but that would also depend on whether the ELV rules were being played because if so, you'd not need TRUE rugby union players and could do without the size, height, weight and talent avantage of South Africans and go with showmen from the South Seas
by James Mortimer on December 04, 2008
Greg - were you watching rugby this year? The All Blacks didn't play the entertainment card this year (normally I would agree with you) but played a more pragmatic game. To call the All Blacks of 2008 showman is wrong. As for Frans Steyn, did you watch the baa's baa's game. He was possibly the worst player on the field. In time he will be a good player, but he has got a long way to go. Give me Mils anyday.
by strums on December 04, 2008
James your articles have slowly grown on me but there is still a strong biased view to your opinions i must say... For Bakkies Botha not even to be mentioned is laughable.. A world 15 would'nt have Ali and matfield in the same team, they are similar players. Matfield is in a class of his own so he would pip ali on class. You need an enforcer to compliment the skills so it would be between Thorn, O'Connoll or Botha.. Botha takes it through amazing performances this year(did you see that try saving tackle) . I understand your need to put Ma Nanu in due to a great season for him but to put him ahead of De villers is unfounded as Jean has proved what an asset he is to the bok set up this season and has been his usual outstanding self... I agree with your selection of Blair but to have Cowan ahead of Januarie, Dupreez is again unfounded. Cowan was ok but he has his limitations, for one he wasnt properly tested this year. I also disagree with you selecting O'driscal as back up centre as he has had a dreadful season and wont make the lions 15 this year. Conrad and Jacobs are the inform 13's. Either way both our opinions are just that, if the world 15 was chosen up here in the northern hemphishere no doubt it would be riddled with Welsh players
PS: I still think player for player the boks are strong than the AB's... Our problem this year was our limited game plan not actuall class in talent This NZ team is a weaker one than i have seen in sometime but what you guys do better than anyone else is play the game how its meant to be played and you desverve the tag of number1 due to a stirling team performance. Aus proved last night that it is how you play as a team that counts..This is what we have to go through every year as a bok supporter
by David Sanderus on December 04, 2008
Mate, the "show men" from the south pacific win year in year out, home and away, close games, score blow-outs. Or do you mean a team of south africans versus Mars when the draw sees fiji and argentina as the path to the money game? (PS wish the ABs had that draw just quietly)
by Greg Smith on December 05, 2008
DAVID, mate........... how old are you
by Brad on December 15, 2008
Greg you have lost the plot you need to live in the real world mate. Your so bias is pathetic to say Steyn deserves a world spot before Mils Muliaina is a joke, you probably think Luke Watson is better than McCaw and Butch James is better than Giteau. Get a grip champ.
by strums on December 16, 2008
butch is better than Giteau... PS Luke Watson was never good enough to don the bok jersey
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
How Graeme Smith cast agony aside and proved he is cricket's Captain Courageous
Manchester United v Chelsea: Stand by for drama at the Theatre of Dreams
Has Walter Smith finally lost the plot at Rangers?
Arsenal Champions League Chelsea Cricket news Euroleague Fantasy football Football news Formula 1 Liverpool Manchester United NBA Newcastle United Premier League Sports news Tottenham Hotspur Transfer rumours Twenty20 UEFA UEFA Champions League