Home > Rugby > Rugby Union > The shame game: Burger and Harlequins have reduced rugby to football's level
by Phil Lythell on 18 August 2009
Email this Article (1) Comments
Rugby, as we are continually told, is ‘a man’s game’ though recent events seem to be showing a rather cowardly and less masculine image.
In recent weeks and months, we have seen rugby union players Alan Quinlan of Munster, Dylan Hartley of Northampton and, most prominently, South Africa flanker Schalk Burger commit the quite heinous crime of eye-gouging. Or scratching someone’s eyes out, if you will.
Crossing codes to rugby league, it has been revealed that Bradford Bulls' Fijian international, Semi Tadulala, has been cited . . . for pulling an opponent’s hair!
Now correct me if I’m wrong, but don’t these incidents seem, stereotypically at least, to be more reminiscent of a scrap in a schoolgirls’ playground?
Hardly the macho image extolled by those who champion the game.
The advent of professionalism in the 1990s was always going to raise the stakes of victory and as a result ensure that cynical acts on the rugby field would increase.
However, it seems that rather than get in a good old-fashioned fist fight, today’s protagonists would rather plumb the depths of fair play, not to mention manhood.
The fiasco at Harlequins - whereby a fake injury to Tom Williams was enhanced with the use of a blood capsule in order to reintroduce specialist kicker Nick Evans to the fray with the game hanging in the balance – serves to underline this even further.
The fact that such a level of subterfuge has entered the modern game is alarming enough, though perhaps the most extraordinary aspect of this is that it was sanctioned by head coach Dean Richards.
Richards was a stalwart for England and the Lions as well as domestically with Leicester, and he was feared by opponents as a highly physical and intimidating No.8. It seems bizarre that a player so well-versed in the old school of rugby should become so entwined with all that is wrong with the game today.
Football’s image has suffered hugely in the last 10 to 20 years due to the increasing lack of sportsmanship and the exponential increase of players feigning injury. Comparisons have often been made to rugby, venerating the latter as a bastion of fair play and respect for the referee.
I have not always bought wholly into this argument; after all, you can get revenge on a player in rugby by punching him repeatedly in the face and earn no more than a ticking off. Even a finger in the cheek of a player in football and you are given your marching orders with no questions asked.
However, rugby has, by and large, held the moral high ground over its footballing cousins for a number of years, though these latest low-points might see that situation change.
In fact, the sports are slowly becoming more similar as professionalism becomes more entrenched and the game assumes a stronger position in mainstream entertainment.
One only has to look at the appearances of Matt Dawson and Austin Healey on Strictly Come Dancing to see a softening of rugby’s hard-man image.
Taken together with Gavin Henson’s penchant for shaving his legs, we are seeing almost an emasculated breed of players taking the field, unafraid to show their feminine side and far less intimidating as a result.
Having said that, I might just change my mind if I ever find Bakkies Botha or Simon Shaw charging headlong towards me!
Comments (1)
on August 21, 2009 on August 21, 2009
Not sure i agree with you Phil, Rugby has tamed down a hellva lot since its gone professional. I remember the days where kicking, biting, headbutting and punching were accepted as the norm. Eye gouging has no place in this sport nore does the above mentioned crimes but you have to admit rugby has changed dramatically to give it a cleaner image. The British media love to make a drama out of things other than rugby itself so if you are worried about rugby's image have ago at the press. Burger's incident was lambasterd by the press in the UK which would have you beleieve that it had never happend before. Everyone was disgusted and Burger was disgraced, yet if you compare it to eye gouging incident in the Heinken cup tie it wasnt on the same level hence burger getting 8 weeks and the munster no 8 getting 13 weeks.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Tipsarevic stuns 9th seed: Andy Roddick crashes out of US Open
Straight sets win for Andy Murray over Lukas Lacko at US Open
Liverpool midfielder's praise for Torres and Gerrard
Arsenal Champions League Chelsea Cricket news Euroleague Fantasy football Football news Formula 1 Liverpool Manchester United NBA Newcastle United Premier League Sports news Tottenham Hotspur Transfer rumours Twenty20 UEFA UEFA Champions League
© SportBuzz All rights reserved 2008 Sportingo- Sports News & Sports Articles site. Sportingo delivers fresh sports news and analysis by fans-Football News, Tennis News, Rugby Union News, Rugby League, Cricket News, Cycling News, Basketball News and other Sports TV. XML Sitemap 2008.