Why the Welsh rugby union team flatter to deceive

Wed, Mar 19, 08 12:08
Rank it:
RSS  Digg  del.icio.us
What`s Online:

Warren Gatland: Transformed Welsh fortunes (gettyimages.com)

There has been massive hype since they won the Grand Slam, but does beating five inferior teams really make you world-beaters? Wales will get found out when they take on the might of the Springboks.

'If anyone thinks the All Blacks, the Springboks or even the Australians are quaking in their boots at the sight of this Welsh team, they need to get their heads checked'

As I write this article it is four days after Wales won their first Grand Slam since 2005 and, as an Englishman living in the Principality, I can honestly tell you it has been torture.

There is no doubt Wales deserved to win - they played the best rugby, they were the most disciplined and fought the hardest. But the way everyone is reacting down here is like the 1970s have returned and Wales are the best side on the planet!

Just like the English and their football team, the Welsh tend to over-hype their rugby successes to the point of ridicule. First Minister Rhodri Morgan has been leading this crazed patriotic scrum by proclaiming: "What Warren Gatland and Shaun Edwards have done is to turn the men in red into men of steel, just like the Welsh teams of the golden years 30 years ago."

To an outsider the clamour currently surrounding this team is madness. If anyone thinks the All Blacks, the Springboks or even the Australians are quaking in their boots at the sight of this Welsh team, they need to get their heads checked.

They have won one tournament in which England and Ireland seriously under-performed and France used as an extended training session to blood in younger players. The less said about Italy and poor, poor Scotland the better. And if you think I'm just a bitter Englishman having a rant, listen to what All Blacks legend Justin Marshall had to say about it: "Wales apart, it was a below-par Six Nations and the true test will come against the Southern Hemisphere teams."

For Wales, this championship was won by getting the basics right. Warren Gatland has done a brilliant job taking the team from World Cup also-rans to Six Nations champions and I don’t begrudge him or the team their success. However, all he has done is instil some mental toughness and get a previously shaky defence to start playing with some nous and belief (did I mention much of this defensive prowess was due to an Englishman by the way?).

To concede only two tries in the whole tournament is to be commended, but Wales were hardly facing the stiffest of opposition. Coping with truly world-class backs like an in-form Brian Habana or All Blacks star Dan Carter would be a different ball game altogether, and one with which Wales would struggle.

Throughout the tournament the Welsh side were disciplined, doing well on the lineout and in the scrum. The kicking of James Hook and Stephen Jones was proficient and in Shane Williams and Ryan Jones they had the standout players of the tournament. Consistency was the by-word and, with the exception of the first half at Twickenham, Wales achieved this.

They also had a sense of purpose and unity off the pitch which no doubt helped the situation as well. Gatland, Shaun Edwards and Rob Howley run a tight, disciplined ship. Compare this to the rumblings surrounding Eddie O’Sullivan and Brian Ashton at Ireland and England respectively, plus the disruption that was created by the storm in a tea cup relating to Danny Cipriani's ticket-delivering adventure and you realise how significant this was.

Gatland also succeeded in not putting the side under any extra pressure by under-playing expectations and making sure the squad was as free from controversy as possible. You could see the benefit of this in the way Wales played. They seemed to carry out their talented coaching team’s instructions to the letter and won games as a result.  

In the aftermath of this win, the Welsh nation needs to calm down a little and get some perspective. They are not world-beaters yet and if they are to achieve that, this is just the first step. Think about what happened after the 2005 Grand Slam when the players took control of the dressing room and Mike Ruddock, the architect of the success, was ousted. Another three years of under-achievement followed.

All they can do is hope Gatland and his team can start to build something a little more permanent - and not get completely destroyed in their June tour of South Africa.

Are Wales going to be out of their depth in South Africa? Let us know by using the comment box below, or submit your own article.
Rank it:
RSS  Digg  del.icio.us
Comments
Morgan Edwards (19/03/2008 14:38)
is that the poor poor scotland that beat the very very very poor england?
(19/03/2008 14:38)
twunt
Ifan Jones (19/03/2008 14:38)
Who said Wales were world beaters? A straw man argument here. Every Welsh person I've spoken to has said that this is just a good platform to build on for the future. Of course there are some people to whom Welsh success will always be intolerable. The hype about Wales winning the Grand Slam is far more justified than the hype surrounding England just because Danny Cipriani had one good game. If I recall corrently Jonny Wilkinson had a great game against Scotland last year and was lauded in a similar manner. now he's been dropped.
David Vaughan (19/03/2008 14:45)
Who said we were world beaters after beating the poor teams? How do you know we'll get found out in S.A.? Aw bless, did little Wales beat the mighty England? Aw, don't choke on those sour grapes!!
Jock Strap (19/03/2008 14:46)
I wonder what Graham Smith thinks about the jizz-fest that once surrounded Jesus Wilkinson but now surrounds Tranny Cipriani
Jebus Wilko (19/03/2008 14:47)
And the English don't over hype their rugby successes? 1/10 Must do better.
TaI (19/03/2008 14:48)
We'd better listen to him. After all, the English are the world's leading experts on getting trashed by South Africa at the moment.
Alan (19/03/2008 14:52)
"Just like the English and their football team, the Welsh tend to over-hype their rugby successes to the point of ridicule." That should be "like the English and their rugby team" surely? Cipriani after one game anyone? After the win over France?
Jamie (19/03/2008 15:13)
I live in England, and the clamour surrounding Cipriani and a good victory over an unmotivated Irish side with nothing to win matches anything from Wales, and with much less justification. The All Blacks may not be worreid about Wales, but Dan Carter is not quaking in his boots over Cipriani either.
Bb (19/03/2008 15:24)
With all due respect to this journalist (I use the term loosely) I have not seen any crowing from the Welsh supporters around me suggesting we are world beaters. Unlike that supplied by the Anglo-centric media every time England are involved in anything. Take the build-up to the Wales-Ireland match in this year's Six Nations. Three quarters of an hour before any other team were mentioned. Now that's true myopia. With the greatest of humility, I suggest this chap follows the M4 to the East, they don't even charge for it.
Rob (19/03/2008 15:28)
Five inferior teams? World Cup finalist. World Cup semi-finalist. World Cup quarter-finalist. Another team (Italy) who should have beaten the World Cup finalist. Apparently it isn't a vintage championship (Wales won) but it really is a vintage year for sour grapes.
EmmGee (19/03/2008 15:32)
Massively poor article on many levels. If a Grand Slam win isn't worthy of a celebration then why bother with the Six Nations at all? The only people treating the Grand Slam as anything more than an unexpected stepping stone are some of Mr Smith's colleagues in the Welsh press - not the average fan and certainly not the management or players. Given the English propensity for over-inflation of sporting success, I suggest Mr Smith steps out of his glass house and pays some proper attention to the mood of the nation in which he chooses to reside.
Geraint (19/03/2008 15:43)
Graham - don't be so bloody silly.
Jonny Lawrence (19/03/2008 15:48)
As an english rugby fan can I first appologise for this very poor article, as it in no way reflects the opinion of the majority of english rugby followers. Secondly could Mr Smith please clarify what success the English football team has had to "over-hype"? Wales deservedly won the Six Nations and their fellow countrymen and fans should celebrate accordingly.
I Smellaratt (19/03/2008 15:53)
The only over-hyping is amongst the press and through people like you writing pathetic articles like this one. The hype is nowhere near as much as that lavished on Cipriani for a decent performance against a weak Irish team - the english press conveniently forgets his part in the defeat by Wales and the near-defeat by Italy.
Geraint (19/03/2008 15:59)
...."and as an Englishman living in the principality I can honestly tell you it's been torture." Jeez......
Cobus Basson (19/03/2008 16:06)
As a South African I must say I find the article quite interesting. I would say that the World Cup winning Springbok side under Jake White would have sat up and taken notice of the Welsh performance, but I believe they would still have felt that they would not be too worried about Wales beating them in SA. However, this is not where the Springboks are now. We have a new coach who hasn't had his hands on the team yet, he hasn't proven himself as an international coach yet, there is the usual political infighting in SA rugby and the push for quotas, we have lost about half of the World Cup winning team, our players are playing under new rules and will suddenly have to revert back to the old rules come the tests in June etc. So, if Wales want to beat the Springboks, June would present a very good opportunity. I certainly rate the Welsh team at the moment. In addition, Gatland will know exactly what to expect from the Springboks and the SA playing conditions and he is very serious about fitness, something that is very important in the second half of any game played at Ellispark or Loftus Versfeld at altitude. Good luck Wales.
Steve Arm (19/03/2008 16:18)
Hardly a vintage six nations year, and you're right the Welsh do tend to overhype their rugby achievements to ridiculous levels. Scotland were awful, so were Italy, France played with kids and new boys, Ireland and England were poor.... - That leaves Wales to win. Let the in-fighting in the Welsh camp begin...
Hywel D (19/03/2008 16:39)
Weak 6Ns post-RWC: agreed. Wales a work in-progress with the real tests to come from the Southern Hemisphere: agreed and the applause Marshall got from the studio audience should tell you most of Wales agree. Defensive coach's nationality : irrelevant. Headline : graceless. Getting the basics right : agreed. On the subject of basics in Rugby they should include a willingness to increase tempo and use the width of the pitch and in journalism objectivity.
Rob (19/03/2008 20:19)
Let's hope no-one is actually paying you for this trash Graham. The Welsh nation should 'calm down', should we? At least we have something tangible to get excited about - a Triple Crown and a Grand Slam. What do England have? A win over Ireland in a dead rubber. No doubt if England had managed to contrive five wins out of five, they'd be currently at Buck House picking up their MBEs and you and your ilk would be calling for knighthoods for the entire coaching staff. You must be choking on your sour grapes.
L Parry (19/03/2008 21:15)
So Wales won a below par 6 Nations, eh? A bit like the vast majority of '80s and 90s 5 Nations, when England could only win against below par Celtic nations. Funny how that's never mentioned by the English media.
John Robb (19/03/2008 23:08)
No other team has won the 6N grand slam more than Wales. So, let's admit, it is getting a bit too easy. We need to pit ourselves against the stronger SH opponents. After all we beat England at HQ with an Ospreys XV.
Darren Maslin (20/03/2008 03:14)
Ha ha - Way to get everybodies back up Graham! Good on ya Gats, pity your not in NZ coaching a seriously troubled chiefs team. They could have used you.
Greg Smith (25/03/2008 00:08)
I'm South African, I couldn't be bothered with all the 6 Nations carry on, but can assure you Wales will need to improve the touring technique for success in South Africa. They have a shocking record against the Springboks in South Africa and in 1999, the score at Loftus was 93 - 13. The Springbok camp looks a wee bit fragile at the minute, so good luck Wales... you've got some catch up ahead, we've got a 90 % win ratio you need to start eroding ... I remember watching Max Boyce live in my city here in South Africa... ha, I'm sure he'll probably be shouting for Wales ? From the rest of us average South Africans, we honestly aren't too impressed with Welsh rugby, maybe unfairly, but a 100 % winning record against you at home is going to be a comfort until the Welsh learn the niknaks of touring in Africa... that maybe 2008 ? Lets see...
(26/03/2008 22:56)
shut up u english loser. they beat y=u and we beat u afce it sucker
Graham Griffiths (27/03/2008 16:31)
An excellent article, Mr Smith. You might have known you'd provoke some of this "Nya, nya, you're just jealous because England were rubbish" childishness. But let's just look at it objectively. Wales well deserved their Grand Slam triumph, but whether you like it or not the standard was extremely poor. One of the main factors was that they had a coach who has managed to get it through to players not to give away stupid penalties. For years it has baffled me why forwards especially commit ruck offences right under the referee's nose, giving away an almost certain three points in their own half. Nobody seemed to mention that when England lost the very forgettable World Cup Final. Wales deserved to win the Championship, but were guilty of some pretty poor stuff themselves, and if they do show well in their tour of SA I'll be very surprised.
Steve James (30/03/2008 19:25)
For all the bitterness in this rant, you could ask me a thousand times, would you rather be England or Wales at the moment, 1000 answers = Wales. England are confused and woeful currently. Welsh folk like my self realise that we come from a tiny country and competing with others who have a far larger pool of players will always be a challenge, but as long as Wales are competitive and not huge underdogs to quality teams like SA and NZ, steal the odd win, I will be happy. Beating England for the next few years (as the last few years) is just an expectation these days.
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED







*
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team




Adobe Flash Plug-in Needed

This website requires a Adobe Flash plug-in. Please download the latest version of the Flash plug-in by clicking here

Daily Poll

Who will win the Champions League?