Home > Rugby > Rugby Union > Springboks won't win any rugby popularity polls - but they top the All Blacks as world's best
by Sean Bowman on 19 June 2008
Email this Article (8) Comments
Supporters of the All Blacks and the Springboks have their own justified arguments on who is the best, but the facts speak for themselves.
Popular world opinion states that the Boks are the most hated team in world rugby – why? I believe it's because of South Africa's tainted past and the scars of apartheid. It will take South Africa a further 10 years to shrug off its bad image.
If you listen to commentators and journalists from around the world they would have you believe that any success on South Africa's part is down to the opposition not playing to their full potential. Any predictions you see from international journalists are generally conservative when the Boks are concerned. I believe it's because of the negative image South African rugby has and not down to the actual playing potential. This point is proven by the very low percentage of correct predictions by international journalists where the Springboks are concerned.
On the other hand, when it comes to the All Blacks, it's a different story completely. Everybody in the world loves the heritage of New Zealand rugby and journalists write off any team set to face them in a Test match. This reputation has made the All Blacks seem invincible. I am about to prove that theory wrong
Here are the facts which I believe make South Africa stronger than new Zealand right now:
Comments (8)
by Jimmy on June 20, 2008
Popular world opinion says that Springboks are most hated. I have never heard that - try the English or the French mate. What world opinion are you talking about. As an All Black supporter we respect that Boks and know they are they only nation to consistently match us. Everybody loves the All Blacks!?! Journalists always write off their opposition. IT IS THE OPPOSITE. The All Blacks, as a consistent world performer, are more often than not loathed - a proven pattern in sport where the more successful teams are not supported. How on earth are you backing up your facts. In last years WC QF against France almost all journalists were picking Les Bleus for the upset! You need to back up your claims.
Your "facts" that back up the Boks are stronger. SA has two IRB players of the year - the same as the All Blacks with Dan Carter and Richie McCaw. Best locks maybe (what about the Wallaby locks), best scrumhalf - maybe on last years form but du Preez has had a poor 2008. But the All Blacks have a better front row and a better flyhalf. So that cancels that advantage. Quickest and fast loose forward trio??? On what grounds - I do think that Burger is the best number 6, but McCaw is the best number 7. Kankowski isn't even the first choice Springbok number eight - and nominee for this years IRB player of the year - THE IRB HASN'T EVEN RELEASED IT'S NOMINEES. Quickest back three? I think Shane Williams proved recently that your back three are not the fastest in the world. And Chavanga and Jantjes again are not the first choice three quarters. I do believe that the Boks and the Blacks will be the world's dominant teams, but don't quote "FACTS" unless they are actually backed up.
by Greg Smith on June 21, 2008
AH, confederacy of dunces... the RRBRS Award (Royal Rugger Bugger Rocket Scientists Award) goessss toooo..... JIMMY ! FACTS ! Subjectively... a fans perogative AND the Boks are the GREATEST (and did I say... the Springboks are the greatest ?) Yip... the Springboks are the greatest ! A fact ! he, he... how you like them apples ?
by Brad on June 23, 2008
Freak
by Ivan Nel on June 27, 2008
Greg Smith, I do'nt know if you're a saffa, I am and I do not share your sentiments. Your arrogance reeks. Yes let us not fear the ABs but there is a 2 way respect between the nations that folk like you dont seem to get. As Jimmy said, there's no fact to your story. By popular opinion yes, the boks may have the best lineout, but the ABs do have the best scrum. The boks may have slightly better loosies (with Richie being injured) but the kiwis have the best 10 in the world. We may have slightly faster 11,14 and 15... but that doesnt make up for their defensive inefficiencies. On paper, the sides are pretty evenly matched but add to the pot the home ground advantage. Yes the boks are called World Champs but would you rate England after winning the cup in 2003 and losing nearly every game thereafter except the one they drew against the u/12C girls team from the local blind school. Until the day we beat the kiwi's more than they beat us... We're still number 2 mate. Every knowledgable Rugby supporter in SA would agree, we needed to beat NZ in the final of the WC to really claim the champ card. If NZ thrash us in NZ and win in SA too... well, we're gonna be labelled all kinds of nasties.
I have never heard that the boks are the most hated team in the world... In the nineties maybe we had a reputation for being dirty, but that has since faded. I also remember SA getting enormous support from the neutrals at the WC. Habana was one of the biggest tourist attractions at the show. The only teams I know of that are disliked by many... and this may be biased since im south african, but I know England and Australia top those lists. England because they are bad winners, and Australia because they are irritatingly good at every sport.
by Strums Rubgy on June 27, 2008
Ivan, Where do you live mate? I live in the UK and i can tell you now the Boks are dissaliked by all of the UK and Austrailia. The main reason is down to "arrogance". If you live in the UK, then i would like to know where you watch the games because i will join you.. Also if you care to read Planetrugby or Rugbyheaven you will see what i was talking about in relation to international Journlists views on "the bokke". Yes the boks got the netural support at the worldcup and yes everybody hates england.. but we are talking about the fact that no netural will support the boks if they are playing France, wales, NZ or Aus.. FACT!
by Ivan Nel on July 29, 2008
Strums, perhaps you see that allot in England, but the english hate everyone dont they? most of all France? I live in joburg, and I seriously don't see that we're of the more arrogant sides, yes our pathetic commentators have orgasms when we score, not unlike the aussies or even the welsh commentators that miss everything a welshman does wrong, one thing we would have to agree on, is that the Kiwis have a world of respect in the sport, and deservingly so, SA is trying to break those labels of yesteryear, we behave on tour (unlike england or aus), we behave off the field... if people still hate us, its a long time hatred that has other roots i feel. The aussies hate us because they are really bad losers and we keep beating them in sa.we hate them because they whip us at cricket and pretty much everything else. And i do read those sites, more than often there are words of praise for springboks, for the team and their achievements in the face of serious adversity. back to the point though, i agree with you that it will take a long time to break that image we seem to carry, but i think we've made strides...
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Tendulkar, Ganguly, Dravid and Laxman - why are Indian cricket fans so tough on the Fab Four?
Spurs go one better than Barcelona in Krakow – now bring on Hull City!
Ouch! The TOP TEN freak sports injuries
Arsenal Champions League Chelsea Cricket news Euroleague Fantasy football Football news Formula 1 Liverpool Manchester United NBA Newcastle United Premier League Sports news Tottenham Hotspur Transfer rumours Twenty20 UEFA UEFA Champions League
© SportBuzz All rights reserved 2008 Sportingo- Sports News & Sports Articles site. Sportingo delivers fresh sports news and analysis by fans-Football News, Tennis News, Rugby Union News,