Home > Rugby > Banned for life - but rugby villain Brennan is not all bad
by mary louis on 20 March 2007
Email this Article (3) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
An open letter to Trevor Brennan
To be honest with you, I didn't know much about you before the event. Of course, I had read some articles in the press, especially one in a French rugby magazine and paused on your profile because a) you were Irish and b) you were playing for Stade Toulousain, who to me are the Crusaders of France, if not the Northern Hemisphere.
This article stated that you owned a pub -- so apt for an Irish rugby guy, but so unhealthy for a professional sportsman. That's what made me stay much longer on your profile. Anyway, the next I heard about you was in January. I didn't even watch the match, to be honest (January is the exam period here) but I read all the articles -- you apologising, people commenting on it, the guy complaining, the club doing its job, the federation not really. Then I thought : ''He is just a human being, like everyone else.'
When you are a rugby player, playing is your job, from the first second to the 80th minute. But before and after the referee blows, you are just a man. And what is more important to a man -- his family. A player's family will always be there: it was there before rugby, it makes the same sacrifices during your career and it will be here after rugby!
So Trevor, what you did was just showing you were not made of muscles only but also made of flesh -- made with a heart. For this reason, I will never blame you for your act. A suspension for life was just not the right thing for the European Rugby Cup disciplinary panel to impose. They made a huge mistake in suspending you for life for a fist in the head of a 'supporter' -- at least, someone attending a match, because if he were a supporter, he wouldn't have behaved like that.
During international matches, John Smit, Victor Matfield and some of their Springbok teammates are little short of terrorists (the word may be too strong but I can't think of a better one to represent my feelings). Yet they scarcely get yellow cards. But ask Dan Carter, Aurelie Rougerie and Jerome Thion if they shouldn't be suspended.
You lose your mind just one time and BANG! And Trevor, guess what? You aren't Zinedine Zidane -- his action during the 2006 World Cup Final in Germany could have killed that Materrazzi guy, and what did the French captain get? Suspended for just five matches, which never penalised him since he had announced his retirement after this particular match.
Trevor, I don't know whether you have followed Zidane's example, and that's why you said you retired before the ERC disciplinary people suspended you for life. But I do hope you will get half of a third of a quarter of the support in your country that Zizou got here in France. People forgave him because he defended the honour of his family.
Now that you have time, take care of yourself and your family and please keep the keys of your pub. Maybe you'll get a visit some day from the girl who supports a player made of a flesh, made of a heart.
Comments (3)
by areYouKidding on March 20, 2007
Are you joking? You would need to be careful about what you're saying re: the Ulster supporter. He is currently taking legal actions against not just Brennan, but also the news agencies that are claiming that he fired personal insults regarding Brennan's family at him. The supporter was in about the sixth row of seating. Brennan climbed over the hoarding, up the steps and physically attacked him. Brennan is a big lump of a fella. Do you not think he could have easily done serious damage to the supporter. Over the matter of the insult. It's Brennan's word over the word of all the spectators in the vicinity. How was Brennan to be sure of what he heard, and more especially who shouted what. It's not exactly like there were only 2 people in the stadium. Who do you believe? Regarding labeling players as 'terrorists'. Not all NZ players are angels either, as BOD can attest!
by JJ on March 20, 2007
How can you call the South African rugby captain a terrorist? He is one of the most honest rugby players in the world - and a national hero. You insult all South Africans. Brennen acted like a thug. He retired to escape punishment - so he is a coward as well. Smit use his rugby money to put disadvantaged kids through school, for heaven's sake!
by Mary Louis on March 20, 2007
I had told the editor not to publish the article if he/she thought it was too 'not objective'. I don't say "You should all punch the people insulting -or not- you" but I maintain that Trevor's suspension is way too harsh! yes Kiwi players aren't angels ; there are dangerous people everywhere! If you want to have a closer answer, just e-mail me!
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Losing Shaun Pollock has left South Africa a jewel short of a shot at the crown
Bruce, Keane, Ince, Hughes? Finding the RIGHT Manchester United man to succeed Ferguson
The SEVEN secrets that turned Usain Bolt into a world-beater
Arsenal Aston Villa Barcelona Chelsea Everton Football Liverpool Manchester City Manchester United Newcastle United Portsmouth Real Madrid Sunderland Tottenham Hotspur West Ham United
© SportBuzz All rights reserved 2008 Sportingo- Sports News & Sports Articles site. Sportingo delivers fresh sports news and analysis by fans-Football News, Tennis News, Rugby Union News, Rugby League, Cricket News, Cycling News, Basketball News and other Sports TV. XML Sitemap 2008.