Home > Rugby > As the Rugby World Cup approaches, who are the world's best 15 players?
by Harshan Jeyakumar on 22 July 2007
Email this Article (30) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Comments (30)
by Ross on July 21, 2007
Just a couple of slight alterations. Conrad Smith has to be included. Arguably the best creative centre in the World. Schalk Burger is another huge omission. Total agression and commitment in both attack and defence. A true giant. The lack of Northen Hemisphere names speaks volumes. Come World Cup time, I think we'll see just how big the gulf is between New Zealand, South Africa and the rest.
by John Christie on July 21, 2007
I don't know how Gregan would go behind a pack like this! - he plays the Aust game which is "chess like rugby" where the backs wait for good clean fast delivery from Gregan, but with a more explosive forward pack such as you've picked, I think Gregan would get in the way, you need a half back that is bigger and more robust behind these forwards - Brendon Lenoard mate. Gregan is like a dancer - but he is no power house operator in the loose play thats for sure!
by Roy Withers on July 23, 2007
NH rugby isn't doing great, but at IC you have to pick either Darcy/Jauzion. Parisse is a shoe-in at 8, his compatriot Castrogiavanni would probably eat Woodcock alive. Another SH player but not part of the tri-nations is Hernandez. Best FB in the world, who obviously suffers because of his nationality. I shouldn't expect any objectivity from a SH Rugby correspondent.
by John Christie on July 23, 2007
Roy, Is Castrogiavanni playing for Italy in the World Cup? - if he is I think he may meet Woodcock in the first game? It will interesting to see if you are right! Have any other NH international props "eaten Woodcock alive"? - he's played most of them.
by Enda O'Connor on July 23, 2007
why is it all tri-nations players??(mainly), surley paul o'connell must be in the 2nd row, D'arcy should be in there and Ibanez should be in for mealamu???.........
by Brad on July 24, 2007
Pierre Spies is poor i didnt see him do anything special in the tri nations he isnt half the player So'oialo is. As for biased comments none of those players deserve to be in the best team i mean Ibanez... Please!
by Harshan (author on July 24, 2007
why is it all tri-nations players??(mainly), surley paul o'connell must be in the 2nd row, D'arcy should be in there and Ibanez should be in for mealamu???......... Paul O'Connell did get some though, more on the bench than as a start but i hadn't seen enough of him at his best to include him. As for Ibanez, the guy couldn't get a game in France's 3rd XV against NZ and he was tour captain!!
by enda o'connnor on July 24, 2007
Ibanez was tour captain and didn't play because he's a 1st team player, he was one of the key players that won the 6nations, O'Connell has played immense all season as he always does
by Etienne on July 25, 2007
1. Woodcock (agreed); 2. Mealamu (agreed); 3. Hayman (agreed); 4 & 5. Bakkie & Victor (agreed); 6. Burger (move Jerry to 8); 7. McCaw (agreed); 8 - Jerry Collins (moved from 6. He played at 8 at the previous WC); 9. Fourie du Preez (Gregan doesn't compare at the moment. Did enough in the S14 to convince me); 10. Carter (agreed); 11. Rupeni Caucaunibuca (haven't seen him play recently, but if he's playing at 75% of his best I'd still pick him. Helluva gamebreaker); 12. O'Driscoll (I'll move him to 12 to accommodate Mortlock. He's played there before); 13. Mortlock (he's in devastating form currently); 14. Joe Rock (agreed); 15. Latham (agreed).
by Scott Donaldson on August 05, 2007
I would prefer Fourie Du Preez, he is a devastating halfback. The loosies are ok, but Burger and McCaw are both fetchers and play the same position (South Africa have No6 as more of an openside role). I would probably go with Collins at No6 and be accused of being more biased.Spies is great if fit. I would Sharpe at lock, I believe the Australian lineout is awesome. Obviously at the expense of Botha. The centres Giteau will be pushed hard by Jean De Villiers, Luke McAlister and Yannick Jauzion.
by rury on August 07, 2007
1.Andrew Sheridan (Eng) 2.John Smit (SA) 3.Carl Heyman (NZ) 4.Victor Matfield (SA) 5.Paul O'Connell (Ire) 6.Jason White (Sco) 7.Richie McCaw (NZ) 8.Shalk Berger (SA) 9.Dwayne Peel (Wal) 10.Daniel Carter (NZ) 11.Brian Habana (SA) 12.Matt Giteau (Aus) 13.Brian O'Driscoll (Ire) 14. Rococoko (NZ) 15. Josh Lewsey (Eng) I Know Berger doesn't play No 8 but i had to get him and white in the team
by Max on August 11, 2007
1. Castrogiovanni 2. Ibanez 3. Hayman 4. Matfield 5. O'Connell 6. Burger 7. McCaw 8. Collins 9. Peel (Gregan? im aussie, your joking) 10. Carter (If only Larkham could kick goals) 11. Habana 12. O'driscoll 13. Mortlock 14. Sivivatu 15. Latham
by pat on August 16, 2007
1.woodcock (NZ) 2.Ibanez(FRA) 3.Murray(Sco) 4. Jack(NZ) 5. Matfield(SA) 6.White(Sco) 7.McCaw(nz) 8.Chabal(fra) 9.Peel(Wal) 10.Carter(NZ) 11.Habana (SA) 12.D'arcy (ire) 13. Tait(Eng) 14.Rococoko(NZ) 15. R. Lamont(Sco)
by a european rugby player. on August 26, 2007
what about mark jausion,mc alister,or darcy for number 12 ? and hav giteau as a reserve(utility back ?)
by Mark on August 29, 2007
Leaving Schalk burger out is a huge error. He is the most dominating flanker out there and has proved his right to be in this world 15 side.
by tom on September 03, 2007
listern guys, i may not play footy or no any of the players ur talking about but none of u have metioned the greatest players in history. Jammy Bartel and Cameron Ling
by James on September 03, 2007
i totally agree with tom, however i think that Marcos Baghdatis is a much better Tennis player than Cameron ling
by pistachio on September 05, 2007
Burger is an openside (ie #7) despite wearing the 6 due to the peculiar numbering system the Boks use. So although Burger is pretty bloody good, he isn't good enough to take Ritchie's spot.
by Scott_S on September 17, 2007
Good to see a nice mix of NH and SH. Josh Lewsey though... Hernandez, Muliaina, Latham. No way Josh should be 15. Apart from that you're pretty much spot on!
by josh on September 17, 2007
dont be a fool, the best 15 are: 1: woodcock 2: melamu 3: adam jones 4: ali william 5: chris jack 6: jerry colins 7: richi mccaw 8: sabastein chabal 9: dwyane peel 10: dan carter 11: bryan habana 12: gordan darcy 13: brain odriscol 14: shane williams 15: percy montgomery greegan is too old, peel is a lot better, guiteu or watever is rubish, tom shanklin, gareth thomas, leon mcalister, i could name way too many centers better than him
by James on September 20, 2007
Everyone seems to be ignoring the Pumas, not suprising cause they always seem to be the outcasts of the rugby world Some of the best forwards in the world, Roncero, Fernandez Lobbe, Albacete Then theres Hernandez at FB who is the worlds best FB in my opinion, and behind a monster pack like the ones being chosen, a halfback like Augustin Pichot would go great!
by kasey on September 23, 2007
Are you kidding me! Jason White looks great in comparison with a very poor scotland side and in fairness looks decent in the english premiership. But he's not even on the same planet as Collins. Outrageous call. Also.. who ever picked Matthew Tait at 13 in a world rugby 15 must be having a laugh. A very talented player in the right side but he hasnt even begun to prove himself at international level!.. england fans.. watch out for Jordan Turner Hall at quins. probably England 12 in a couple of years..
by kiwi kalum on September 27, 2007
1.Phil Vickery 2.jon Smit 3. Carl Hayman 4. Chris Jack 5.Victor Matfield 6.Schalk Burger 7.Richie McCaw 8. Gearge Smith 9.Augustin Pichot 10.Dan Carter 11.Bryan Habana 12. Matt Giteu 13.Brian O'driscoll 14. Shayne Willams 15.Chris Latham SUBS: Castrgiavani,K.Mealamu,P.O'Connell,J. Collins,S.Larkham,M.Jauzion,Hernandez... Unbeatable team!
by rusty on September 30, 2007
could stand to have a few more irish!i'd back paul o'conell any day against any second row in the world
by Hendrik Hoffman on October 05, 2007
I think from what we have seen so far my team pick would be: 1 Os Du Randt, 2 John Smit, 3 Carl Haymen, 4 Chris Jack, 5 Victor Matfield, 6 Schalk Burger, 7 Richi McCaw, 8 Sabastein Chabal, 9 Fourie Du Preez, 10 Dan Carter, 11 Bryan Habbana, 12 Matt Giteu, 13 Stirling Mortlock, 14 Joe Rokocoko, 15 Percy Montgomery