Home > Rugby > Rugby World Cup referees must stamp their authority
by ROGER NAISH on 01 August 2007
Email this Article (8) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Comments (8)
by Scott Donaldson on August 02, 2007
The referees vary so much in interpretation and this will be so tough especially when the tournament is at the business end and the matches may well be decided by a whistle blower. The interpretation of the rugby rules are so dubious around the breakdown, scrum and lineouts.
by John Christie on August 02, 2007
Test rugby should be about attrition and gain. Ref's input while it can be frustrating, shouldn't be a big focus point. Teams should be bigger than that. Anyway if it is such a problem the referee's association needs to do some soul searching and start following through more on poor refereeing performances from their blokes.
by Peter Shortell on August 02, 2007
Most people do not seem to know that at the RWC there will be an assessor at every game. The referee will not only have the benefit of his feedback, but will also get a video (or maybe it is a DVD this time) of his game with his voice as the sound track. A lot of practical effort goes into supporting and analysing referees at the top level.
by John Christie on August 03, 2007
Peter - that's good to know - hopefully toward the end of the tournament the leading teams and refs will have identified a consistent pattern. I'm glad Paddy's a NZer at least he'll favour a style that suits the AB's (just joking)
by Andrew M Beckett on August 03, 2007
Scott your comments are, IMHO, misguided. Especially your statement of "..the matches may well be decided by a whistle blower." In all of the games in which I have officiated I would like to think that the players have made more mistakes than I have. You may believe that this is a fatuous or disingenuous statement, but it isn't. Do referees commit penalties at the breakdown - that may lead to 3-points? Likewise do we offend at the scrum, lineout, ruck, maul, open play? The answer to all these is no. It is the players that err. I agree that occassionally a referee may make a decision that at the time seems curious, but players at this level should have the psychological conditioning to cope with it. Just as a #10 has the ability to put a bad kick behind him. Here's hoping for an exciting competition with few errors - from all quarters!
by Peter Shortell on August 08, 2007
Top referees travel the world, refereeing in different international competitions. They always have at least one person formally assessing their performance. In the UK the same is true of Guinness Premiership referees. I presume such competitions as the Currie Cup, and NPC are similar. Lower down there are more referees than assessors/advisers. At grass roots a referee will probably get watched a couple of times a season unless he shows real talent - in which case he can progress from scratch to national panel in a few years, carefully watched all the way.
by Philip Healy on August 20, 2007
Refa should not be distracted when they award a penalty. Kickers lean forward to gain another yard when ref is not looking. Refs should either scrape the mark of place a disc on the ground to stop kickers creeping forward.
by Iuni Sapolu on September 09, 2007
The refering of the RWC game between Manu Samoa & South Africawas riddled with refering errors which culminated in disallowing a clearly fair try without asking for the third referee's view! I am a lawyer of at least 20 years experience in New Zealand. I find Paul Honiss handling of this game against Samoa, an injustice to fairness in the game itself and unfair to the players of both teams. The advantages for Samoa were evidently shorter as oppose to advantages given to S.Africa. The Head High tackle by South Africa of a Samoan player in the air with the ball, should have called for the yellow card, but Paul Honiss did not. Honiss penalised Samoa constantly for allegedly not being on their feet when allegedly the ball was not out, was repeatedly also done by South Africa, yet,Paul Honiss did not penalised the S.A. I am disgusted with the unfair refering by Honiss. In addition the TV commentators for the South Africa - Samoa game, were condescending and patronising to say the least! Along with Paul Honiss, th
Add your comment here
PERSONAL ABUSE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
First Name
Last Name
Email
Heading
Display your favourite sport or football team badge with your comment.
Sport
League
Team
Comment *
Please enter the text you see in the picture into the textbox below. *
Tackling violence - the biggest stain on Italian football
The SEVEN secrets that turned Usain Bolt into a world-beater
How Zenit reach the zenith as Manchester United crashed...
Arsenal Aston Villa Barcelona Chelsea Everton Football Liverpool Manchester City Manchester United Newcastle United Portsmouth Real Madrid Sunderland Tottenham Hotspur West Ham United
© SportBuzz All rights reserved 2008 Sportingo- Sports News & Sports Articles site. Sportingo delivers fresh sports news and analysis by fans-Football News, Tennis News, Rugby Union News, Rugby League, Cricket News, Cycling News, Basketball News and other Sports TV. XML Sitemap 2008.