Home > Tennis > Serena Williams' toughest opponent is her own mental state
by J.R. Williams on 19 October 2007
Email this Article (34) Comments
Free £10 bet when you register at
Serena's worst enemy is . . . Serena Williams. Yes, that wonderful, athletic, fearsome woman-warrior who has shot to the top of the tennis world and fascinated us all.
Serena Williams strikes awe, and even a little fear, into the spectators, so just imagine what she does to a player on the other side of that net. Serena and her sister Venus's humble beginnings have become modern-day legends, and their class and form are both upheld and adored. So why has Serena lately been struggling? She is the last person on the tour to win all four Grand Slams, so we know that she can dominate on any surface, but what is piquing her? What is her stumbling block?
For one, like any celebrity, Serena's problems are actually not problems at all. This year she has won one Grand Slam, a Tier 1 title, and she has reached the quarter-finals of the remaining three Grand Slams. I'm sorry, and maybe it's me, but I'm having a hard time finding out why this isn't considered success.
You, me and everyone else knows that this is a successful season. The problem is that Serena's expectations for herself are extremely - and I do mean extremely - high. And the other problem is that she shares these extremely high expectations with the press and her fans. By doing so she lets us know that if she doesn't attain them, she's not doing so well. Even though she's ranked sixth in the world.
Just how high are her expectations of herself? It's simple. Serena doesn't want to lose a match. Any match. Not at a Grand Slam, and not at a Tier 4 tournament. She doesn't care if it's Justine Henin or anybody else on the other side of the net, she does not expect to lose. Some might argue that this is true for any competitor. But I say, not so. Lest we forget, Marion Bartoli's confession during her Wimbledon fiinal post-match press conference: "I truly am just happy to have made it this far and to play a Williams sister in the final"
For any other player, they hope to win just five Grand Slam titles, let alone eight like Serena has won so far. She's a great player and everyone knows it. Serena's other problem is her competitive spirit. And yes I say competitive spirit rather than her attitude. Her now infamous "lucky shots" dig at Henin was brilliant to say the least.
Whatever happened to athletes being smarted by a loss, saying something off the cuff, and that driving them to perfection? Boxers do it all the time. American football players talk smack ON THE FIELD. And let's not even get to Basketball. Don't you know there's a reason you can't ever hear what the players are saying to each other on the court?
My point is athletes, true athletes, make the type of comments that Serena and Justine have made about each other. It'll never go away. So people need to grow up and remember this isn't little league. This is the professional sports arena, and these women are warriors. Serena made a dig at Justine. Justine's made digs at Serena. So what? Deal with it.
Serena is not out of shape. That should not even be an argument. You think you can play as well as she does, and not be fit? As my mother would say, "Child, please!." Serena's body looks amazing as usual and she is of African-descent, so I'm sorry if she's not going to have eastern European stats. She is who she is.
Serena's game only suffers because Serena is not there mentally. And I don't care what anyone says. She isn't there. Her mental ferocity has to match her legendary backhand. And right now, she's a physical lion and a mental kitten. Yes Justine is playing the best tennis of her life. Duh. She's rocking and she deserves her No. 1 ranking. But when Serena gets her mind right, it's all over for Justine, and we all know it.
Only Serena can stop Serena. She isn't the type of player who can be stumped by a lesser opponent on their best day. That's her sister Venus. When Serena is mentally fit, Serena is unstoppable. She's physically fit, but not mentally. Yet the year is about over and the Year-End Championships in Madrid will be all the rage for tennis fans everywhere, who are hoping to see Serena's return to brilliance. I for one will be watching, and like everyone else I can't wait for another post-match news conference.
Is serena that good? is she being let down by her mental frailties? Post your comment or write an article for Sportingo
Comments (34)
by tennisfan on October 19, 2007
i disagree with the comments made.. justine is right now the best in women's tennis.and i don't think even if serena is 100% mentally and physically fit will she be able to reclaim herself as being world number 1.Frankly, i feel, with many new and upcoming tour stars, i don't think she can dominate the field as she did in 2001-2.plus the only reason why justine lost the match at miami this year was her lack of self-belief a belief that she was able to beat serena.now that she has beaten her in all the other 3 grandslams, she is definitely dominating serena.and i don't see serena coming up to world number 1 again at the pace she is going.right now the confidence Justine has can help her beat both the williams sisters.and in the US open, Justine beat both of them in back to back matches.and serena says she is ready to reclaim the world number 1 spot.isn't that being mentally ready to win matches ?yet she still lost to elena dementieva in the finals of the moscow tournament.I just dont think she has the ability
by Conrad on October 19, 2007
Justine deserves to be number 1 this year, but my money is on that Serena, if she lives up to half her potential, will be remembered, perhaps not statistically, as the woman without equal.
by Aasim Shaffi on October 19, 2007
I love serena she is my second fav player with venus coming first. But the author is seeing mental issues as the biiger downer for serena this year. After winning AO serena got injured, returned in Miami and the Wimbledon thumb injury has only lost it's grip recently. There is some sort of mental problem right now with serena i cant put my finger on it but who can. Some nice statements in the article and just for the record a 100% serena could knock a 100% henin into next saturday. But serena is facing some mental problems or something like that but we all know that she can overcome it.
by Lefty Serve on October 19, 2007
tennisfan probably said it best. Justine is the Roger Federer of woman’s tennis. She is not a “media type” such as Anna, Sharapova and the “Sisters”, she is a simple, quiet woman who does her talking with her tennis racquet. For this reason, the media will always speak of Serena as a person who is invincible if she really “wants” it. Well, that is the past and this is the present. In case anybody has not noticed, Justine has the most professional work ethic in woman’s tennis and she has evolved and improved (yes, we all know about her personal life), in her mental and skills to a point she, like her male #1 counterpart, can adjust her game with her wide variety of shots and styles to beat anybody on the planet. Her only challenge now (no, not Serena) is managing the limitations of her body so she is fresh and ready for the slams. Sorry media, you can do all the talking about the “Sisters” and Justine will stay under the radar and win championships.
by Former Serena Fan on October 19, 2007
You guys in the media and some of you Serena fans are so obsessed with her that if Justine win’s Zurich, the WTA finals, All the slams next year and the Olympic gold medal, you still will be saying “yes…but IF Serena was (fill in the blank) she would have blown Justine off the court…). You cannot compete with a fantasy. While the possibility of Justine matching Margaret Court, Evert or Martina would be a stretch, ending up 5-6 slams ahead of the sisters is very possible.
by Jason on October 19, 2007
It's so funny and kinda tragic how people in this world lose faith in someone because they're not 100% anymore. If people don't like Serena, then fine...don't like Serena. But that doesn't mean that she's still not good anymore. Justine is a smart player, but we all know that EVERYONE is SO HAPPY that finally someone has beaten these two black girls back to back. You finally have a little amo. for you haters. Well in case you forgot, their rivalry is tied 6-6, and they both have MANY years ahead of them. So you go ahead and give Justine ALL the credit. As if. And we'll just have to wait and see who comes out in the end. But I can tell you one thing...Justine's small body can't handle much more. She'll probably retire like Kim Clijsters did.
by Jaglo on October 19, 2007
I have to agree with the author that Serena's mental status is off. She is experiencing some things off the court that is interfering with her game. I am not sure what is going on but it is something that she is not discussing. You do not have to change anything in tennis just like basketball if you are the best at it. The best of what Serena has done has been working throughout her career. I will give Justine credit....she is an awesome tennis player but Justine cannot beat Serena when Serena is mentally stable on and off the court. Serena has so many more interests besides tennis...boyfriend, clothing line, commericals, parties, etc. Justine only has to play tennis. No disrespect to the Justine fans, but she has no answer for Serena when Serena is on her game. So, I do agree with the author, Serena is Serena's worst enemy.
by Keith on October 19, 2007
Jason: By reading all these postings they dealt with tennis, NOT race. WHO brought the "black girls" issues into this? Who knocked Serena because she is black? This is a tennis discussion, power, style etc., NOBODY has discussed likes or dislikes because Serena is black. I am part African American and if I like or dislike Serena it has nothing to do with her race, it is her game and my preference to her showing a little more class after the matches (which she did this week, by the way).
I commented on their race, as a mere stat. I didn't say they're being dogged because they're black. We've all been there, heard that and bought the T-shirt. What I am saying is that people ARE happy that someone finally beat them both back to back. Haters on the Williams Sisters were salivating for this moment for YEARS. And why? Because they can't stand them for no other reason than they're dominant and the best out there. Let's look at the stats. Serena was 81 at the beginning of this year. Venus was lower. They're now both in the Top 10...in JUST one YEAR! They're incredible. And even with this outstanding feat, everyone's so happy to count them out just because Justine Henin beat them at a couple of tournaments? Uh...pu-lease. But tennis haters are fickle like that. They're gonna keep winning just like they are now, and then we'll see who the real champions are.
Jason: Thank you for clearing this up. However, if you will note, your quote was not "people ARE happy that someone finally beat them both back to back." as on your second post, but it was "EVERYONE is SO HAPPY that finally someone has beaten these two black girls back to back.". Slight difference for being "happy" don't you agree?
by root on October 19, 2007
If any of you have ever played tennis then you know that one can not maintain a dominate position in any sport for ever. You may have broken new ground at a certain time in History,and you may have lifted the level of the game to new heigths.But like all things,to maintain this level is without question the most difficult,it requires more focus ,dedication,and above all consistant competion. The world truely passes you by,you lose conditioning,mental resolve, match toughness.Your body breaks down with age. Serena was lucky to win Australia,her one dimensional tennis aginst one dimensional players was the only reason she won.Plus the sheer luck of the draw.No doubt that if she stays in the middle of the court and you hit in her power zone she can be formidable,but move her around and you see the glaring weakness in her game Henin is by far the superior player on every level.Brain over brawn will always win in the end. Serena had her day,she was great,she is no longer great.its time to humble out or get to wo
by Randall on October 19, 2007
Wow, there really are two camps here: The “Serena has so much power that if she is 100% she will blow anybody off the court, even Justine” to the “Justine is #1 for a reason and she can handle anybody’s power and play Federer like tennis and win slams”. In the men’s game, there are many players with more power than Federer: The Andy Roddick serve, the Gonzo forehand, All of Safin’s game, etc., but Roger Federer can take the aces and the forehand bombs and win enough points to be #1. I think there is a false assumption (based on the advent of the “Amazon Woman’s” power game 10-12 years ago) that unless you are built like a Roller Derby star, you can no longer succeed in the WTA. That a woman who can hit a 90 mph forehand and a 120mph serve will rule the day. And if a 5-7 Belgian with more power than Martina Hingis, but a more diverse “Federesque” type game, with serve-and-volley skills and pinpoint shotmaking, the ability to slice and topspin all of her shots and a bullet proof net game, this must be an
this must be an aberration, a hiccup in the #1 slot until the ruling Amazon woman finds herself and resumes her rightful place. Roger Federer and Justine Henin have proven classic tennis trumps baseline bangers if that classic tennis player has all the shots, the movement and enough power to execute their plans. Other than Roger’s serve (that is much more reliable than Justine’s) they are mirror images of each other. The way they construct points, counterpunch with wicket one-handed backhand winners at impossible angles, and their flawless new games. Can they be overpowered? Yes and no. For a few games or a set? Yes. For an entire match, probably not. Amazon Woman tennis fans: get used to it.
by rikka on October 19, 2007
Say whatever you want to guys; Serena is definitely in much a better shape than she was at the AO, and she won there so she can obviously be the best (behind justine) wheter she's fit or not. But let's FACE IT she's not the Serena of 2002. Guys I do love her and I AM among her biggest fans, that's why I say: she needs to lose weight, she does need to be faster in order to beat justine
by Jason on October 20, 2007
I'm sorry but I agree with the author on this one. Serena not fit? What tennis channel have you been watching? Justine's been kicking her butt, because Justine's learned how to play Serena better. Justine's hitting those angle shots and commanding each point from serve on. Serena can run just about ANYTHING down, and her sister Venus basically needs to be nick-named "The Wall". She is fit, and I'm sick of people calling her these names. How about you go out there and play 3 sets of professional tennis and see if you don't pass out. The woman can play, and she has the endurance. Lay off already. It's such a TIRED argument.
by rexus82 on October 20, 2007
Are you kiddin' me? Serena's only human, not a robot, therefore even if she was mentally 100%, on any given day, she will always be second best behind JUSTINE HENIN. Yes, the 2003 Frech open SF wasn't the best match between these players bcoz of henin's behavior,and yes, back then in '02-'03 serena was the better player, but come on! Those ydays are over! There's a new dominant tennis quuen now from belgium, just accept this fact. Henin beat her 3X and all at a GS, and the fact that serena was winning in str8 sets at the US open b4 playing henin proves that serena was 100% fit mentally & physically. I know proud african-americans are the hardest to admit the truth, but face it, whether serena's 100% mentally or not her glory days are over. Just accept this fact.
by tennis on October 20, 2007
Her Us open campaign was impressive to say the least, winning all her early round matches in straight sets until she met Henin and again, she lost to Henin, this time straight sets loss. Serena was 100% at the US Open then what happened? Oh, yeah, that tiny world #1 belgian bested her, again. Will serena be able to dominate Henin again during her hey-day? Probably not. Henin's all court game and versatility (like federer's) will always triumph over serena's 1 dimensional powergame. Henin's days will be over but not until some other player who's got henin's all court game comes along. Until then, we just have to admit that Justine Henin is currently the best women's tennis player, and not even serena's powergame could take that recognition away. Allez Juju!
by Randall on October 20, 2007
Tennis: Your comments are right on the money. I would suggest there is a replacement for Justine Henin. She is 17 years old and her name is Aliez Cornet http://www.alize-cornet.com/ she just won the French Open Girls and gave JJ a scare in the US Open. She has a lot of the Justine flash and game. In 2-3 years when Justine's career is winding down, look to Aliez to move into the spotlight.
Randall:I hope that Ms Cornet also has one handed backhand like henin or federer as it is more refreshing to watch young players playing like henin or federer. I'm tired of watching women's powergame. It's about time real tennis is making a comeback. Anyhoos, I wish ms cornet all the best in the future.
Henin has only lost 1 GS final to Venus-wimbledon '01, and from 2001 to 2003 Henin lost to Venus in the Sf of GS. So, yeah, in a way that puts Venus the better player (head2head). I'm more interesting to watch Henin-Venus match than Henin-Serena, as I always, in my opinion, feel that Venus is a better player than serena. I'm a huge Justine fan, but I'm fully aware of the threats that Venus could pose her. As for serena, well, I don't think she'll ever dominate tennis again. Sorry
by serenasucks on October 20, 2007
[quote]My comments supporting the author have NOTHING to do with my skin color. I could say the same thing about caucasian fans being sooo happy that a small white woman finally beat both Williams Sisters. What a ridiculous comment. It's a game people. It's competitive sports. And you all don't even know sports well if you all are so, "Serena's days are behind her." Like, what are yall smoking? What are you on? So she lost three tournaments to Justine this year. So what. Justine has lost to her as well! It's called a rivalry for a reason. Lest we forget Navratilova and Everett? Or Seles and Graf? This is the best thing for Women's tennis right now and I for one am happy to see two players both at their peaks going at it, winning back and forth. They're tied now. And so what if Serena lost 3 quarter-final matches to Justine. Need we remember that Justine has lost Grand Slam FINALS to Venus? Jeez...get off it people. It's te